FCC chairman Tom Wheeler used a speech at the Washington DC based startup incubator 1776, to hint at the likely outcome of the Comcast-TWC merger decision, although both sides of the debate are interpreting his remarks at will. Either way, his comments decried the lack of competition in US broadband markets, saying that the only way to reduce prices was to make sure there are more choices.
Now that the deadline to submit comment on the proposed merger has closed, the FCC has all the information it will use to make its decision. But this admission of a lack of competition, combined with high prices and poor availability, undermines the Comcast-TWC argument that their merger can’t be opposed on competition grounds as they don’t currently compete in the same markets. The other institution that also has to give its blessing to the deal is the Justice Department.
Rather, if you read a little into Wheeler’s words, it doesn’t matter to the FCC that Comcast and TWC are not competing directly, as the whole USA suffers from a lack of broadband competition. Unfortunately, until we see the final decision, this admission of a lack of competition doesn’t completely refute the Comcast-TWC logic. Don’t be surprised if all the lobbying dollars spent somehow manage to push the merger through despite what it will do to rip the pay TV industry apart.
Nonetheless, the chairman admitted “users cannot respond by easily switching providers.” Wheeler said “as a result, even though there may be competition, the marketplace may not be offering consumers competitive opportunities to change providers, especially once they’ve signed up with a provider in the first place.”
Wheeler also noted that while 93% of US residential customers had access to broadband, only 15% had access to a line faster than 4Mbps from 3 or more competitors in a region. The FCC definition of broadband, which Wheeler admitted was outdated, is currently set at that 4Mbps figure. Given that HD video streaming requires more than a 4Mbps connection, Wheeler said “this is why we have proposed updating the broadband speed required for universal service support to 10Mbps.”
And this decision appears to have sparked panic amidst the ISPs, with Verizon and AT&T already scrambling to declare that customers simply don’t need 10Mbps, as “consumer behavior strongly reinforces the conclusion that a 10 Mbps service exceeds what many Americans need today to enable basic, high-quality transmissions” according to the latter. You do wonder why AT&T’s press office hasn’t spotted the disconnect between “basic” and “high-quality,” but this is coming from a company that believes that its customers don’t want a fast enough line to watch a Netflix stream in 480p.
Turning again to the FCC data, when you increase the speeds of the line, the proportion of customers able to access a line from 3 or more providers falls dramatically. AT 10Mbps, only 9.8% of customers enjoy 3 or more ISPs competing for their money. At 25Mbps, the number drops to 2.4%, and at 50Mbps the figure is only 1.6%.
A similar drop off can be seen in the ratio of consumers who reside in markets with only 2 providers, but the most dramatic proof of a lack of competition can be seen in the high-speed data. 55.3% of Americans can only access a 25Mbps line from 1 provider, and 61.4% can only get a 50Mbps line from a single ISP. You can chalk the slower lines down to historic under-investment, but the figures you see in the high-speed market looks like straightforward anti-competitive practices enabled by an anti-competitive marketplace – something which the FCC shares a role in regulating.
Of particular note is that 6.3% of the population of the country with the largest economy in the world has no access at all to a line faster than 4Mbps, with that percentage rising to 8.4% for 10Mbps lines, and around 20% for both the 25Mbps and 50Mbps markets – which the FCC calls “the essential infrastructure of the 21st century economy.”
To address the lack of competition seen in the FCC figures, Wheeler proposed the Agenda for Broadband Competition. Its four main aims are to protect competition, including opposing anti-competitive acquisitions; encourage competition by opening new mobile broadband spectrum; introduce net neutrality laws to ensure “the internet remains free from barriers erected by last-mile providers (can you hear Netflix cheering?)”; and where competition cannot be expected to exist, the FCC will “shoulder the responsibility of promoting the deployment of broadband for the sake of consumers and innovators.” The latter is particularly important for the 14.5 million Americans who live in rural areas, of which 25% have no access to a 4Mbps connection.
And Wheeler points to examples of competition that did improve local broadband markets. After Google announced its Fiber project in Kansas, the average speed surged 97% to a respectable 34.4Mbps as the incumbents tried to compete with the new Gigabit entrant. While orders of magnitude slower, the 97% increase shows that there was room in the market for improvements to be made to the speed of the network – importantly, improvements that were not being made at a time where the cable and telco industry was making record profits. There was money to spare to improve the lines, but due to the lack of competition, the profits were not plowed back into the service. AT&T has managed to lose fixed line subscribers for the past 7 years, but posted net income of $18 billion in 2013.
Another cause for concern is the power that Comcast-TWC will hold over the content market. TWC’s entire media budget could be swallowed by Comcast – who would then be the most powerful player in the game, with the ability to cripple a show or network if they do not agree to its terms. So not only could all of TWC’s content spending disappear from the market, Comcast will be better placed to further abuse its position as the largest pay TV company in the business.
But Comcast remains unrepentant, stating “our transaction will have no negative impact on the competitiveness of the broadband consumer market. Our two companies don’t compete for customers anywhere.” Unfortunately for Comcast, that’s the exact problem that Wheeler has identified – that two of the largest ISPs in the country have managed to carve the country up into numerous tiny monopolies. This looks like the opening chapter of a traumatic moment in history for the US ISPs.