Why would anyone want to patent a technology, simple as it might be, for remote individuals to watch a video game that is in process of being played out by two people the watcher doesn’t even know?
That’s the result of a new filing by Microsoft, and at first glance it may look like something unlikely to make much cash for the Seattle software giant.
But actually, we think that this, and other things like it, will form the basis of an entirely new form in-home entertainment, and one that eventually will be able to go on the road into portable players.
The move was reported in GamesIndustry.biz and what Microsoft has filed is a patent to allow remote players to join multiplayer online Xbox games as spectators.
Spectators will have access to instant replays and representations that make the games look like any other sporting event.
Observe any two or more game players in a room with either PlayStation, Xbox or Gamecube and you will see frequent and multiple types of player interaction. As gaming has gone online, remote players can play each other, this was used as the basis for these strangers messaging, and eventually talking to each other. But while communication is the archetype for building a community, joint play, group play and watching classic game outcomes, are more likely to involve a large, diverse and widely scattered audience.
This has several dangers in the new broadband economy. Fundamental to what Faultline has been preaching these last few years is that there are MORE activities that attract people in homes which have genuine broadband communications. An increasing number of new types of entertainment activity, means that existing activities have some of their economic benefit diluted. TV programming that is watched by a smaller audience eventually attracts less advertising revenue, and has less to spend on content, creating a vicious cycle.
Think of the effect this has on existing conventional leisure activities. Initially for each game that was sold, it only had the potential to stop one family from watching one TV. For much of the time a platform game occupied one person in a room with one TV, while the remainder of the household watched TV or indulged elsewhere in the home in another leisure activity.
Gradually as games had two player and four player modes, and changed their graphics to accommodate this, and added controllers and memory cards to control and record the results of play, this rose to two brothers (or sisters) in a household, and on to their two friends, but it remained household constrained. The behavior that developed both when one player was passive, or when they were temporarily ‘out’ of a game (their character was dead or out of ammunition or whatever, for the rest of this level) is that they take on the role of adviser. They say things like, ‘This is where that big boss gets you from behind’ or ‘I always go left here because there are less aliens’ or whatever. The key thing is that past gaming types have allowed passive gamers to remain interested in the continuing game session and it has become part of the gaming experience.
With the advent of broadband connected games, growing out of the knowledge built up by operating Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games (MMORPG), households became connected. Both Sony, but especially Microsoft, have seen this opportunity early, and begun to plan for when gaming is a global spectator sport.
The learned ‘passive’ gaming activity is now part and parcel of the learning curve of any gamer. Watching how someone else handles a given situation, or watching an avatar with different powers, is all part of the learning experience that makes a gamer better equipped to dominate a particular set of gaming skills.
The problem has always been that there have only ever been two, or potentially four, views of how the game is progressing. Each active player has a view of what’s around him or her, and they may have a special button to give them a map or birds eye view of proceedings. Offering any of these views to remote players that want to watch, is of some use, but a new ‘viewers’ portal that allows all views or a choice of views or a combination of views of existing combatants, would make ‘observing’ games more acceptable.
Also, key to this process is the fact that the processing power required to offer this facility, should neither slow down the game play, nor rest on central servers. These connections have to be peer to peer and work from some form of multicasting of the game playing data, and central services should only serve to introduce gamers of the right level and interests to find each other. Otherwise game watching systems wouldn’t scale.
This is one of the roles we have speculated might be undertaken by the PS3 when it arrives on the scene, given that it has immense processing power.
What this will inevitably lead to is a longer period of interest in any given game. Players can become relatively expert on their own, and then continue to a ‘new level’ of expertise by looking at the play of others. Beyond this global gaming competitions would be easy to set up. Leagues and knockouts and group play can all be sponsored by the type of technology that will make it easier and easier for bigger and bigger groups to play and viewing playing.
Converting the entire experience to one which is storable on a Blu-ray DVD drive (or HD DVD), and which can be viewed as easily on a TV set which has no games platform, as on a TV driven only by a games platform, could lead to mass viewing of games, after they have been played. DVR capability would be ideal, and the addition of a hard drive to both the Xbox and PlayStation was always inevitable. Being able to download ‘classic’ encounters that highly rated gamers hold on their devices, after hearing about a particular sequence of play, would also be a good attribute to add.
What we expect is that there will now be a step by step, intellectual battle to develop patents and play capabilities, and then to put these into practice in software that can be retrofitted to the just arriving generation of gaming platforms ‘ Xbox 360, PS3 and Revolution. This is the next set of generational steps to be made in the gaming war. Making any particular video representation of a passive view of a game look sufficiently different from the last game that was played, will also become a subtle addition, so wider avatar variety and retention of voice comments, even expert commentary, will also lead to more advances.
This is likely to punch an ever larger hole in TV viewing activity and other home entertainment activities. Anything that makes a game entertain for longer (typically players will come to know a new platform game in about three to five weeks, and then get bored with it and begin to play it less often) will not only increase the number of hours that these players will spend away from other activities, but also increase the perceived value of a game, allowing the authors and publishers to charge more for the game and also the platform.
This brings us to business models. Will the platform owners make it free to ‘watch’ a game, or will the price of viewing a game be ownership of the console or ownership of both the specific game and the console? To a certain extent, if the replay or viewing experience is reliant on having the game code, then the games owners are limited in what business models they can apply. All viewers and players would have to have a copy of the relevant game. But if the game viewing could be condensed and converted into some underlying language, then a viewer, rather like an acrobat reader or media player, could be offered either free, delivered with any game or purchased, at a cheaper rate, separately.
Would it be of greater benefit to allow owners of a console to view a game free of charge, in the hope that players would feel they have to go out and buy it, or would it be better to charge more for the game in the first place with gamers having the knowledge that they were going to go through a longer enjoyment curve on the game? We would eventually expect some experimentation here, although this is likely to be under the control of the actual platform owners, rather than games designers themselves, so perhaps limited experimentation.
Regardless of how they exploit this, the more hours that players spend either playing, watching or learning about games, the more revenue the entire industry will take, and the less time that players and their friends will spend indulging in other TV based leisure activities.