Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 February 2006

Will DirecTV and EchoStar bury their differences for triple play?

It transpires that the two biggest satellite TV companies in the US, DirecTV and EchoStar’s Dish network, might actually be prepared to put aside their (considerable) differences and share the costs of building an internet access network to provide their customer with a return path.

If they go ahead, the economies of satellite delivery could be compelling, as long as the creation of the return path network did not cost too much. Such a move would almost certainly create services that undercut the Cable and Telco offerings, and save DirecTV a huge amount of money on its high 20% per annum churn rate.

The key idea of a return path is that the satellite Direct to Home (DTH) providers could offer triple play services in competition with both the cable operators and the US telcos. Such a move might provide the framework for a global model for the future of DTH TV companies.

We have written about this many times, and the candidates and the obstacles are manifold ‘ it could be a WiMAX network, but the spectrum is in short supply; it could be a partnership with an existing WiMAX network, perhaps Clearwire, but this may make Clearwire a lot of enemies among rivals that it must co-operate with.

Also DirecTV CEO Rupert Murdoch is not a man that does things by halves. If he can own the network he will. Which is why the open confession from both companies this week in the US media that they are not only talking to each other, but doing it without hostility, is a bit of a surprise.

We know that Murdoch has personally visited many broadband companies and has explored powerline, CLECs, WiMAX and may even be considering Mobile Satellite Services, with a 1.5 GHz signal coming down and going back up to the sky. Such a service, targeted at mobile, was announced by Mobile Satellite Ventures (MSV) last month which offered Boeing $1 billion to built a three satellite network, but we suspect that Murdoch wants to move faster than that, and would have his own ideas on how a satellite could manage a national wireless broadband service, and anyhow DirecTV has the capability to do that itself.

Murdoch has said publicly that he’s definitely going to set up the triple play with a broadband network, and that announcements will be soon, and that he has up to $1 billion to get the job done.

MultiChannel News put two and two together this week pointing out that DirecTV secured a US patent in December for technology that reduces interference in a combined satellite-terrestrial network and suggested that this that might give us a clue as to how DirecTV would create its return path. But in truth this could be almost anything. It could be about avoiding contention between a WiMAX antenna and a satellite dish, it could mean a combined network that uses both satellite and terrestrial stations to set up an IP path to the home.

The truth is DirecTV applies for about 1 patent a week, so it’s hard to discern a strategy from its patent filings.

We were told last year by Israeli firm WiNetworks that it had solved technical issues of how to send satellite video data down the same cable from the roof of a building as that used by IP data and that it was pitching this to both US satellite companies.

The simplest guess is that DirecTV and EchoStar might team up on a joint broadband wireless, probably WiMAX, network using this technology to create a hybrid IPTV system. The WiMAX network could offer telephony and internet access and carry commands for interactive TV and even a VoD service, and the satellite would deliver the bulk of the TV, as it does today.

But another guess might be that a hodge-podge of different broadband offerings in different markets might do the trick, with WiMAX in some markets, satellite where WiMAX won’t reach, and best effort internet from a customer’s existing broadband supplier, when they have neither option.

But if we had to bet on it, we’d assume that although they may be in talks together, a deal between DirecTV and EchoStar is still unlikely to come to fruition. Quite simply they both have enough money to build or partner for some kind of network of their own, so why get in league with one another?