‘To Hulu or not to Hulu, that is the question; whether ’tis nobler for the Tube to suffer the slings and arrows of outrageous studios or to take arms against a sea of legal actions and, by buying Hulu, end those actions.’
That’s our Shakespearean way of asking if Google really should or really could buy Hulu. The answer of course is turning into a big fat yes, despite our nervous suggestion a week earlier that this idea was inspired by a slow Stock market day and somebody’s wet dream.
Not that it’s easy to make sense of such a deal or to interpret its outcome, because this seems to be another case of fattening frogs to feed snakes. In our mind Hulu was created as a legal counterpart to what was rapidly becoming the new source of video piracy, YouTube.
In the four years since then Google has perhaps reduced, but perhaps not quite eliminated, its tendency to allow the uploading of copyrighted content, and perhaps the studios are easier with the idea of Google taking over its still fledgling content portal, because like Apple was to the music industry, Google of late has been consistently successful with its new projects .
The inexorable growth of Youtube, the massive rate at which content is loaded to it, and the similar rate at which consumers consume it, is something that Hulu has given up hope of achieving.
Hulu CEO Jason Kilar has said recently that 1 million customers will sign up for Hulu Plus by year end and that the company will have revenues of $500 million during 2011 and shell out $300 million to content businesses.
If you share out $300 million equally between NBC Universal, Fox, Disney and Providence equity partners you get something approaching 0.2% of revenues for the studios and that’s after 4 years. The truth is that 4 years after the iTunes music store had launched (in 2003) it had sold 2 billion songs. So Hulu has not worked anywhere near as effectively as iTunes did. It is NOT on track to be the number one source of online video in the US, partly because it is not tied to an attractive set of devices, which people are buying in droves. And outside the US the studios have not been able to recreate it. It is, by the standards of those organizations who created it, a failure.
Of course you and I and every consumer knows that Hulu is highly popular and given its head it might BECOME such a monster, but as we said the day we heard of its existence, it will never been given a free rein in going to market while it is owned by three jealous studios, who would want all of that traffic for themselves.
In fact here’s what we said about it in 2007, ‘The likely outcome is that Hulu will not make it to the end of 2008, because TV network executives are too busy trying to win the market share war on TV to learn how to appeal in the entirely new experience of web entertainment.’
We’d have to be happy with only being partly right on that one, but the fact that the studios are considering selling the operation means that they aren’t happy with how rapidly Hulu is progressing, and that must be particularly poor news for the performance of the paid Hulu Plus operation. So far there are no numbers issued about Hulu Plus subscribers, only that Kilar thinks he can get to 1 million this year, which at $8 a subscriber would annualized at around $72 million, making the advertising revenue of Hulu the real earner here.
It appears that Yahoo kicked the whole idea off, approaching Hulu with an uninvited bid. Major institutions like US studios are never going to be so hasty as to accept a bid just like that ‘ and were bound to take the proposition out to a wider audience, appointing Morgan Stanley and Guggenheim Partners. Once that happened it was only a matter of time before Hulu landed at Google’s door.
Other players are free to cut their own deals with the studios, but Google is being shunned with its Google TV from even showing the free web site video of ABC, CBS and NBC, as well as Hulu itself. Google buying Hulu gets it out of that fix and gives Google a natural content edge on Google TV and on Android and Chrome devices, in much the same way that Apple products had an edge (exclusivity) with the iTunes store. We don’t think Google would ever go towards exclusivity in the same way as Apple, because it’s not in its nature, but this might even give it a hand up onto iOS Apple devices, because a Hulu app would continue to make sense on Apple.
None of this directly impacts on the Viacom legal action against YouTube, which so far seems to be going YouTube’s way, but which is being appealed to a higher court. That court will have a tough job because during the original trial it became clear that both YouTube execs and Viacom execs both knew about the levels of abuse, and both behaved badly. YouTube execs were shown to have uploaded films themselves to make YouTube more popular, while Viacom execs were shown to have uploaded their own films, to make YouTube more obviously culpable. The lower court decided that if they wanted to play those kinds of silly games, then there was no case to answer, but that doesn’t resolve the issue of the rest of the world copying the YouTube example and allowing the uploading of copyright material with impunity.
Which is why we have said that Google has a genuine self interest in being magnanimous, not letting this play out in court and resolving the issue, and owning Hulu might give it just the leverage that it needs to do that. Growing Hulu revenues, which have no element of user generated content, would act as a deterrent for Viacom seeing through its case against Google, and settling for some piffling, unannounced amount of damages and letting its content take a place alongside the current Hulu owners, might be just the right way of bowing out of the suit. In a world where Android drives the largest single device format, the ability to get your films onto that device in a privileged manner (as a home page icon) might well bring the $1 billion that Viacom was looking for in its suit against YouTube, but over time and with continued revenue opportunities.
Which is perhaps why Hulu is worth more to Google than to anyone else, and why the company has come in hard to overtake Yahoo in negotiations, according to yet more leaks made to the Los Angeles Times. The asking price is said to be $2 billion, which still doesn’t make a ton of money for the companies that started it, but it allows about twice as much cash back as each of them put into it. In our view Google should be happy to pay that price, but it may not be that straightforward.
Google wants a world where uploading is okay, where sharing is okay, and if it clings to this it may well push the negotiations too far in both Hulu and in any settlement of the Viacom legal action. It must not let its lofty user focused ideals get in the way of getting the job done here.
In April this year we estimated real sign ups at Hulu plus to be less than 300,000 and said that it’s hard to take a seriously as a business quite yet, despite the claim that 1 million will sign up by the end of this year. If it really is up for sale, we assume that it has not made sufficient progress and will miss that 1 million target, and by how much the miss is, will probably decide on the genuine value of Hulu going forwards, and a low value may make this not worth doing for the studios.
Most coverage of this deal has focused on how willing the studios will be to continue to give their content to Hulu and Hulu Plus after Google has bought it, if such a deal does take place. It is true that a ten year run at using existing and new content on a pre-arranged delay from when Broadcasters show that content, will almost certainly provide significantly more value to Google, while on the other hand the broadcasters seem happy to offer anyone except Google access to its catch up content, and that attitude will lead to Hulu under Google getting more and more rivals all the time. If Google can do this deal and extract ANY level of exclusivity for some content, it will have gone a long way to dominating OTT TV video for some time to come, albeit in the US in second place behind Netflix,.
The talks were described by the LA Times as ‘preliminary’ and the fact that both Yahoo and Microsoft are the fall-back options also probably means that Google will find a way to close out this deal, and at the same time it keeps the price up for the studios.
Google has already said that it wants to sign premium content for YouTube so this would give it that content with a single negotiation, instead of a different one with each studio, although it has already secured movie rental deals with Sony Pictures, Warner Brothers and Universal Studios.
There remains for us, the problems associated with globalizing the Hulu concept, which has already been widely rebuffed in Europe, but YouTube is certainly global and can bide its time and slowly sign content. One way would be for Hulu under Google to expect less in the way of Hulu Plus subscriptions and more in the way of advertising, Google’s specialty.