Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 August 2011

Will Hulu end up as the perennial orphan? Or will it be taken into care?

Let’s just spare a minute of silence for Hulu, the perennial orphan, which no-one wants to own. OK, the press have been full of reports saying this or that company would like to own it, so how can it be an orphan?

Let’s look at each bidder out of Apple, the new one in DirecTV, plus Yahoo, Google, Amazon and both Verizon and AT&T, and take them sequentially and see if you can see why they would want to own Hulu.

Apple’s view is that it likes to sell content, and it prefers content that can only be viewed on an Apple made device ‘ how well does that fit in with Hulu’s original specification and how it makes the great bulk of its revenues from free content with paid advertising? Not very well we would suggest and Apple would want to inherit only the smaller revenue portion that is Hulu Plus and we know that it could command all of this content anyway, if it wanted it, in iTunes ‘ so why buy Hulu?
And anyway most of that Hulu Plus revenue would not be captive on Apple devices?

Could Apple change the habits of a lifetime and not make the content devices exclusive? Well one day it may be forced too, but not until it has a Justice Department anti-trust suit compelling it to, or after Steve Jobs has handed over control to a lesser being. There is also the fact that Apple has negotiated overseas deals for iTunes in most territories ‘ and Hulu has been unable to do this ‘ the most it buys Apple is more constraints than it has today.

The only way that Apple in our view can benefit from buying Hulu is if it does so in order to get better content terms for itself from studios ‘ and we think that it is already on Most Privileged Nation status there already and it would damage relations between the studio owners and other partners, if Apple got even better terms. So no, Apple should not buy Hulu.

DirecTV is based mostly in the US, obviously it has rapidly growing revenues in Latin America as well, but since Hulu doesn’t have Latin American revenues, it doesn’t help it there. But again there is the question of rights ‘ DirecTV has as much chance of offering over the top adaptive streaming video services in the style of TV Everywhere, as any other US pay TV provider ‘ it has as many or as few ‘ rights to send content over the open internet as Comcast, Time Warner Cable and Dish.

Alright this area is a bit fuddled right now, but you’d be pretty upset if you spent money buying Hulu if later you found that all you wanted to do was give the content away, and it turns out you have the right to do that, to your existing clients, already.

We can see how a cable MSO might want to buy Hulu, although there are none in the mix, because it might conceivable bundle Hulu into a broadband price ‘ an ISP is perhaps in a better position to do this, since many have no TV service with which Hulu Plus might compete. But for a satellite DTH company to offer this, when it has no broadband lines to sell, it stretches the imagination. No, DirecTV is curious, like everyone else about what Hulu has managed to do, and wonders if there is the basis of a Netflix class service in there ‘ but it will almost certainly conclude that there isn’t. The CEO likes the Hulu UI, and it would take it as a basis for its TV Everywhere service if it could be bought for a snip, but otherwise it’s out.

Yahoo is an interesting one. Yahoo has reached multiple impasses, and perhaps sees content delivery as a way around them. It may end up selling out its Asian assets to the Chinese company that it merged them into, Alibaba. Relations between them have cooled over multiple incidents ‘ including sale of subsidiaries without consulting the board and human rights policy in China. Alibaba has tried to re-acquire the 43% that Yahoo owns in Alibaba. All of which might finally throw a ton of cash at Yahoo and see it retrench to a smaller footprint, one that might fit better with that of Hulu.

But the falling success at Yahoo and incidents like the Alibaba one, has led to a share price for Yahoo that is less than what it claims its overseas subsidiaries are worth. If it could sell them off it could be a company worth less than the cash it holds in the bank, which suggests that anyone buying at today’s share price, plus a premium, could sell off overseas assets and get the company for free. Such companies do not stay single long and while we’re not saying that it wouldn’t bid for Hulu, any deal-maker that did not factor this in, would not be worth their salt. A combination of Hulu and Yahoo for nothing, achieved by a buyout of both and the sale of overseas subsidiaries, would be even more worth doing. Today Yahoo is worth just over $15 billion, but this is on annualized revenues of around $4.5 billion, and compares badly with the $47 billion that Microsoft offered for it a few years ago.

The question arises however is just how much could Yahoo do with Hulu, and whatever it could do, couldn’t Google or better still, Facebook, do a whole lot more. As internet properties go, Yahoo is a spent force in comparison with the freshest on the block and at Faultline we think that Facebook has the potential to become one of the key methods for finding hot TV programming ‘ better than using an EPG or simply zapping, due to the personal nature of everything that goes on at Facebook. But Facebook is not thought to be bidding.

Google does make some kind of perverse sense, but right now Google wants patents more than it wants a new vision. Could Hulu be integrated into Android Market? Well yes it could. And despite that fact that Google loves free and advertising supported and is not so keen on paid services, nor anywhere near so good at them, there is still some mileage in such a deal, except for one thing ‘ Google has paid video content (some) and yet it still hasn’t really accelerated this side of the business ‘ so it might want the larger part of the business ‘ Hulu itself, and would want to keep it limited to that, and not want the paid services Hulu Plus.

And yet the same problems emerge with this deal, as emerge with any Apple deal. Google might prefer Hulu purely for Android, and not for a wider variety of devices and as such, it may do better to build services its own way rather than cut back the Hulu services. We have to also say that we think it’s against Google’s nature as a company to limit anything to just its own architecture and it probably won’t go down that route anyway, or at least not at first, but it has provided such as advantage to Apple over the years that Google may feel it needs to copy it at some point.

On the other hand Google doesn’t make revenue directly from Android and operators are free to cut out Google owned elements (such as search) and work with a rival. So perhaps this objection is not fair in Google’s case.

But even so we would expect Google to have a clear vision for video and for the incorporation of Hulu into that vision, which would lead it to a clear opportunity. You try it ‘ balance the deals it has done with content owners, the hostility which other content owners such as Viacom, have for Google and the incorporation of content into its services and its Android and Chrome strategies. It’s not easy. Once again the lack of Hulu being a global brand also legislates against Google taking it.

On balance we think that if Google bought Hulu, it would be doing favors for the owners Disney, Comcast, and News Corp and want something in return. At least it can easily make the $2 billion price tag that they are asking for the property.

The case for either Verizon or AT&T buying Hulu, or the pair of them buying it collectively, is equally weak. It would weaken strong relationships with other content owners if it favors one grouping over another, they always brand services with their own brands, they both have IPTV and will use those rights to stream the same content as their IPTV service ‘ inherently better than Hulu’s content, over the public internet to tablets, TVs and PCs in a TV Everywhere strategy. The same wrong-headed logic is built into either buying this, as it was for DirecTV.

Amazon just plain and simple has its own strategy and it could have chosen to adopt the Hulu strategy itself but didn’t, had it any love or capability for advertising revenues ‘ which so far it has not shown.

If we look at any one of the three existing owners buying it, they would have spoken before now and had options to buy it out that were invoked prior to this whole affair becoming public. And as for any studio not already involved, such as Sony, getting involved, it has all the dis-incentives of the current owners, plus the fact that none of its content is involved, plus the fact that it has built its own Qriocity network brand as a rival already ‘ one which favors Sony devices.

We could invite people to think outside the square and come up with Dish’s Blockbuster or Netflix itself. Either one might prove an opportunistic buyer or partner, with someone else owning Hulu.

All of which leaves us looking at Hulu being perhaps not such much the perennial orphan ‘ because it currently still has parents and even when it departs their tutelage they will still exist. No this is more a case of a dysfunctional family putting its, as yet, unaffected child into care before its parents constant bickering does something terrible to it.