Apps are funny things. On the iPhone they are, for the most part, little more than gimmicks, promoting a download and discard mentality. Ask your kids of they still play ‘Angry Birds’ and watch their faces turn up, as if you are the least hip person on the planet, and that’s just the 12 year olds. The 18 year olds just shake their heads and display as much pity as that age allows.
On Smart phones, iPods, iPads and other tablets Apps move too quick for the adult human eye to follow. They also turn the young into obsessive touch junkies, playing frenetically for hours on end. On an iPhone that is pre pay that’s a blessing to the parents, but it can be a nightmare for the networks that they are attached to.
We know about the legendary strain on the AT&T cellular network in the US due to the Apple iPhone, and offloading much of this to WiFi seems to be one of AT&T’s core ambitions. Data downloads eat network resource but also prevent players from using their phones quite so much for voice. Accepted that voice is a declining portion of cellular revenues anyway, and becoming commodity, and since post pay voice is in bundles and in LTE we are moving to a world where everything is data, even voice, the next five years will be all about experimental charging mechanisms for cellular that get around any shift away from voice usage (we have a report on LTE data charging if you are interested email [email protected]).
For some time cellular operators wondered about putting other applications on their devices, especially when subsidizing them. What if people played with the apps too long and forgot to make quite so many phones calls? This was seen as particularly worrying on a phone that cost $300 or more of subsidy. Cellcos were worried they were paying through the nose to stop customers using their services.
Well if that was a legitimate concern for cellular networks, both on Apps and on mobile video, then surely the Apps part of the equation will come up once again as we enter the world of TV Apps, but at Faultline we think this might be even more of a worry ‘ not to pay TV operators or to TV set suppliers, but certainly to broadcasters.
Broadcasters rely on more and more of a modern family’s leisure time being used to passively view TV. Broadcasters are collective happy to move this from passive viewing to active viewing and wish to invest in interactive sessions. This brings new potential for new, high value advertising which can augment a free to air mentality. Any interaction that takes a broadcast viewer away from the TV programming but doesn’t carry them to a broadcaster’s walled garden, results in lost eyeballs to advertising and a fall in broadcast revenues.
We heard that eternal mantra at the Connected TV Summit a few weeks back, ‘that European households spend more and more of their time watching linear TV than even before,’ a sentiment that we cannot agree with and feel it is tantamount to burying the broadcaster’s head in the sand, and close to outright lying.
Nielsen and its ilk are directly responsible for this. Back in December 2003 Nielsen in the US confessed that it had lost 10% of the 18 to 34 year old male TV viewing audience in a single quarter. It blamed use of DVDs, DVRs, the internet video games consoles and piracy. Since then it has never confessed to a single quarter when linear TV viewing was less than the prior quarter, both in the US and throughout Europe.
And this is in spite of DVD penetration, DVR penetration, video games consoles and internet use all rising radically during that time. Piracy has stood more or less still, and YouTube was launched somewhere in those years.
Instead Nielsen has ‘massaged’ those figures by adjusting precisely what it measures from time to time, incorporating most DVR viewing and adding in views of video from broadcasters’ own web sites, to name but a few. It has carefully adjusted its yardstick to fit the requirements of its customers, and today has everyone convinced that despite all these distractions, plus the distraction of all things mobile and all things tablet, that even today TV viewing figures are going up. Trust us, they are not.
The DVR allows people to watch TV without viewing adverts and to view content in less time. So if you tell Nielsen that you watched the soccer, it puts you down for 90 minutes plus the 30 minute preamble and the 15 minute post mortem, when what has actually happened is that you started viewing after 40 minutes, fast forwarded through all the preamble and the adverts, but also through the stoppages, and half time breaks and watch perhaps 60 minutes total, less than half the time Nielsen allocates to the viewer.
This happens the same on all DVR activities and if you watch a snippet online from a web site on your handset on the way to work, this is added as if it were linear TV viewing. People working unsociable shifts, unemployed, and the effects of recessions all amplify the audience figures for TV and there are more and more potential misguided methods of recording viewing, but in essence the appearance of Apps on the TV are a final hurdle that is a step too far even for Nielsen to cover up.
Take the game Angry Birds which is really an iPhone and Android Market download game, which is now available on the web. Most of these users are in the US and Europe and there have been around 200 million downloads of this game and on average each player puts in at least one minute per day, so 200 million minutes a day, or 6 billion minutes a month or 100 million hours.
This seems a lot for a single game, but when you divide that by say the 300 million people who live in the US and the 550 million in Europe, then it only has the potential to interfere with about 6 or 7 minutes of TV viewing per viewer per month. So not a problem.
But so far Angry birds and the 200,000 other games that sit on App stores are mostly played on portable devices, so they eat dead time ‘ travel time, waiting time, etc.. But put them on the TV and for every minute that someone plays this game and all of the others, it will not only dent the viewing figures of those who are playing, but also of those who could otherwise watch the TV.
And this is worse that when gaming consoles were attached to TV sets for the first time, more like giving everyone in the home their own Wii console. We see wholesome adverts of whole families playing the Wii on the main sitting room TV set, and if that had ever been true, it would have more than dented viewing figures, but of course the Wii has the advantage of being attachable to ANY TV set, especially the retired bedroom portable.
App stores will require the processing power of a pretty high level cpu, an Intel chip, an A4 or some kind of powerful 1GHz ARM chip or a dual or quad cpu version of the same. You’re not going to find these in multiple TV sets around the home for some years to come. So when a TV manufacturer like Samsung or Sony decides to offer an App Store, then its long game strategy is to ensure that when you next buy a TV set, you buy it from the same vendor. CE manufacturers don’t care if you watch linear TV, play games or go on the internet, as long as next time you buy a TV, you buy it from them.
But inevitably as they drive connected function into their devices, these devices are frequently the main viewing device for the home, and this presents a potential block on viewing. The same can be said for a set top that is attached to the main TV in the home. So an Apple TV or a Roku box can monopolize the main TV screen for a home, in a way that a gaming console rarely did.
The pay TV operator has almost the same motivation as the TV manufacturer. They want continued subscription revenues, potentially some VoD advertising upside or application advertising, and they want innovation to prevent churn. They don’t care what they addict you to, as long as you are addicted as a family ‘ be it cartoons for the kids, Glee for the older kids, games for the boys and NFL for dad, as long as you cannot consider cutting the cord.
Which is perhaps why telco pay TV operations such as Verizon’s FiOS were so early in to the App Store game two years ago, and why Google TV will have an upgrade to include Android Market. Samsung and Sony both have app store strategies of their own and devices like the Roku has both an App store and a Channel store and this week had Angry Birds put on it, and is using the Blinkx video search on the system to bring tons of internet video to the platform. Roku doesn’t care whether or not you watch Linear TV at all, only that it gets a larger installed base and that it can use that base to gather up extra add on revenues.
Apple is this week introducing its iCloud web music store, but where will you choose to play music in your home? Well the beauty of Apple is that you can play it on a number of devices, but one of them is the TV your Apple TV is attached to. Already the TV is one outlet for Mac held video.
There have been tons of announcements over the past two years, but still there is no mature market understanding of what things like Yahoo Widgets and Rovi Widgets will do to traditional viewing patterns, because the products are barely out of the stores.
Our take is that this is why Broadcasters continue to design MHEG style systems for YouView and such, simply because their business model says they must keep all traffic inside their walled garden, so despite having some of the best content anywhere, especially catch up from prime time, broadcasters will continually get connected TV wrong, blocking any open path to the internet.
Pay TV can be a bit more circumspect and have quite a broad based walled garden, taking in lots of internet partner material and focusing on the overall slickness of the TV experience, while device makers have a similar aim in simply pushing their brand.
The pure internet plays, such as Google TV, start with an inherent disadvantage, because they must replace the linear TV paradigm almost from day one, with a new UI and new search tools, and that’s expensive and still not assured of near term success. That’s why the most exciting connected TV experiences will initially come from pay TV operators who control both the on device UI, and its cloud based augmentation with search and recommendation, which will begin to chip away at linear channel hopping as the best method of content discovery.
Eventually the player that finds a way to navigate the entire video internet, such as through a Blinkx search channel or how TiVo manages it with on the fly metadata interpretation, will pick up the most customers. They get nothing from linear TV channels, and are the most prepared to replace them.
If pay TV takes the lead in making the connected TV experience a hybrid between what a TV viewer already knows and pure internet function, it will lead inevitably to less and less TV shows being watched. What will stop that is when multi-room strategies emerge, where the connectivity of all a home’s devices are built into a home gateway, and can go to all TVs in the home, the one in little Tommy’s room that was for the PlayStation, the one in Jennies room that the family uses for Wii-fit, the one in the playroom which isn’t HD and the main TV viewing area.
But there will be an interregnum, during which pay TV may reign, but when the main viewing platform for the home becomes overcrowded and members of the family form queues like a supermarket, to play their TV App. Broadcasters, like everyone else, will try to move linear TV to tablets via apps designed purely to extend the reach of broadcast TV, and this will lead to viewing claims being even more unreliable.
But we see this interregnum as a dark time for broadcasters, and unless they update their vision of Connected TV to invite more players, not just other broadcasters, there will be rows and rows of connected set tops lying unused in the stores. Sand the next time someone tells you that this year we are watching even more linear TV, ask yourself and whoever said it , ‘Is that really likely?’