Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 October 2005

WiMedia promises UWB standard by year end, sidelining IEEE

The deadlocked battle to produce the IEEE 802.15.3a standard for high data rate, short range networks will become ‘irrelevant’ because of parallel work being done by the ECMA body, which could produce a workable standard by year end.

This is the view of Stephen Wood, president of the WiMedia Alliance, one of the two groups (the other being Freescale’s UWB Forum) battling to provide the core technology for 802.15.3a. Although, with the WiMedia Alliance gaining ground among the all-important digital home manufacturers, there were indications that Freescale would come to a compromise solution, the Alliance has chosen instead to back away from the IEEE and get its technology adopted by an alternative organization.

The cooperation with ECMA (originally the European Computer Manufacturers’ Association), which has worked on standards in areas such as DVD interchange and scripting languages, indicates three key pressures on the vendors seeking to establish their UltraWideBand (UWB) technologies to bypass the increasingly political and unwieldy processes of the IEEE; to get standardized products to market as soon as regulators permit in order to start building market mass; and to win European support for a technology that has, to date, been regulated only in the US.

All this made ECMA attractive because it has a fast track process that contrasts with the IEEE’s. The susceptibility of the IEEE mechanisms to allow protracted political battles often only marginally related to technical issues, threatens its role as the premier arbiter of layer one and two networking standards.

Deadlocks and battles, such as those that have hobbled the UWB-based 802.15.3a proposals, the current 802.11n fast Wi-Fi work, and the sidelined 802.20 mobile broadband activity, mean that standards are not keeping pace with the rapid change in market demands and that vendors are becoming frustrated. While the Byzantine procedures of the IEEE may offer golden opportunities for some companies to manipulate the system, they also increase the risk of one vendor or group setting a de facto standard, sidelining the other players, because of the strength of demand from the OEMs in the wireless, digital home and PC communities. ‘ECMA has a very deterministic process that is impossible to jam up like IEEE, and it is readily defused if any vendor tries,’ explained Wood. ‘For instance, once a project is adopted it cannot be voted against for any reason except technical.’

The WiMedia Alliance’s decision, first to create its own MAC layer, at odds with the IEEE 802.15.3 specification signaling that it would seek to set its own standards, and then to seek an alternative body to ratify that new technology, rather than returning to the IEEE fray, is the first, but unlikely to be the last, major break with the key networking organization. Wood said that recent progress among regulators with the UK and Japan close to finalizing rules for UWB and the rest of Europe set to follow had made fast action imperative. ‘While regulation was the long pole in the tent standards could take as long as they liked but now that is changing,’ he said in an interview this week. ‘There was the potential for China to do its own thing as it did with WAPI (its Wi-Fi security standard) we were running out of time.’

This led to the unusual situation of one standards body taking up a project that was still officially active within another. The willingness of ECMA to take up WiMedia was no doubt the result of much lobbying, but also reflects the global move to wrest control of international technology standards from the US. The European standards institute ETSI, for instance, was set to follow the IEEE in setting its own short range UWB-based specifications, but with the European Union publishing a mandate authorizing (read pushing) ETSI and the other key European body, CEPT, to get the work done, there was not only impatience with the IEEE stalemate but an opportunity to seize the initiative.

The situation could not have been sweeter for the Intel-inspired WiMedia. The option of relying entirely on a de facto standard is certainly possible in the consumer electronics world, given its support from Sony, Samsung and other giants always raised risks in the PC world, more sensitive on these issues. The chance to take advantage of the rising impatience in Europe and Japan to push an alternative standards body was a fine solution for WiMedia. Regulators in the EU, Japan and elsewhere are close to making their final rulings on UWB but are prevented from doing so by the lack of standard guidelines on key issues such as how to define ‘detect and avoid’ the method that all regulators will mandate to ensure UWB devices do not interfere with other networks in the same spectrum. The need for a quick international solution was very real, and WiMedia took the initiative in proposing one, and in so doing, confirmed its victory in the market.

‘Many standards activities take place in the US and there is often ignorance of the standards processes elsewhere,’ admitted Wood.
He expects the ECMA standard to be completed in December and to be adopted by the International Standards Organization the only body fully recognized by China and ETSI around the middle of next year, paving the way for a mass market by 2007.

ECMA and ETSI have a joint committee, which will modify the base standard for the specific requirements of European regulators in areas such as detect and avoid.

This seems to leave Freescale and the UWB Forum – which supports a technique called Direct Sequence UWB, in contrast to WiMedia’s OFDM-based approach, out in the cold. It is possible that the IEEE will continue with its work and if the WiMedia players were to leave the 802.15.3a taskgroup, it could theoretically ratify DS UWB as a rival specification, but it is rare for two standards bodies to behave in this way. Wood believes it is more likely that the taskgroup will be allowed to expire and Freescale will then, presumably, decide to support the new standard, or push its own technology as a proprietary or de facto solution. ‘We won’t see a second standard,’ he said confidently, and the ECMA specifications are applicable in the US too.

That said, UWB technologies will continue to be important in other standards, including IEEE ones. UWB is expected to be the basis of the next generation of Bluetooth and ZigBee low data rate platforms and possibly other, more long term projects such as a 60GHz specification (though Wood personally feels this is technology looking for an application, given the progress in Wi-Fi and WiMedia). It also has particular strengths in areas such as location awareness and sensors that could be incorporated into other platforms. The ECMA standard, like WiMedia, is focused only on high data rate applications at very short range (around 480Mbps over three meters being a current target), with the key markets being PC connectivity, digital home networks supporting high bandwidth devices such as high definition televisions, and smartphones.

The WiMedia architecture provides a common radio platform on top of which other standards, such as Wireless USB and FireWireless, will build the next version of their technologies, allowing for fast time to market and preventing interference between these various products.

Wood is keen that WiMedia keep its work confined to very short distances, despite the work of some innovators like Pulse~Link on the Freescale side and Focus in the OFDM camp at boosting UWB to LAN distances even within the regulatory power limits. These limits – which the FCC set very low in order to assuage fears from incumbent spectrum holders, and which may be even more conservative in Europe, hobble UWB, which can operate at long distances when in unshackled markets such as military, restricting it to a relatively small section of its potential spectrum reach and to short distances of a few meters. While Wood expects that real world usage of UWB will allay interference fears and encourage regulators to relax their rulings, he is not for lobbying for significantly more power. Not only would all the devices have to be tweaked, but it would bring WiMedia into conflict with fast Wi-Fi. For Intel, with its huge interests in Wi-Fi, this would be a self-defeating situation, though it would benefit UWB specialists eager to broaden their markets.

Intel, then, is keen to position the two technologies as complementary, with UWB addressing the ‘hotspots’ in the home where there is concentrated need for high speed communications, such as the cluster around the television and DVD, or the PC desk. Such scenarios not only allow the chip giant to spread its revenues among all its various chip lines, but also achieve its key objective, to drive the creation of digital homes that, in turn, drive the uptake of new devices, whose chips are the ones that make Intel the real money high end media PCs, handheld data servers, mediaphones and so on.

The UWB market, where chips should fall in price to $2 within a couple of years, is not attractive per se to Intel as a profit stream, which may rely on partners for the silicon itself. But the portable and low power applications, and associated user behaviour, that UWB supports will allow the giant to promote its more innovative and high margin future devices, such as its recently demonstrated ‘handtop’ concept platform for a smartphone-style product with mass storage, multi-network communications, multimedia capabilities and a fully blown PC operating system.

Intel and its allies have manoeuvered cleverly in the UWB sector and look set to take an unbreakable hold on the steering wheel for high speed, low power, short range networks. While the chipmakers both UWB start-ups and the majors make their product launches and seek to gain early market share, the real gains will be for the OEMs that can create a new breed of device incorporating UWB. The consumer electronics industry, in particular, will not care about the accusations that Intel and WiMedia have hijacked the wireless sector’s well established standards processes and steamrollered their own technology into pole position. Far more important will be a standards-based solution that regulators can accept and that now looks likely to be a reality within a year.

The renewed confidence in the future of UWB is luring a horde of chipmakers into the market, with a host of announcements in the past week. Focus Enhancements is the latest of about 15 chip designers with products announced for UWB and is planning to release a combined baseband/MAC chip by year end. The company is focused mainly on optimizing wireless media distribution in the home, claiming the ability to transmit multiple high definition TV streams through walls and over almost Lan distances, a boast shared with Pulse~Link.

While backing the WiMedia OFDM-based architecture, Focus claims it will outperform most of the other WiMedia implementations. ‘We can go much further and much faster. We go up to 880Mbps, and we can do HD out to 20 meters through walls,’ said Mike Kelly, vice president of marketing.

Meanwhile, Fractus, pioneer in fractal antenna technology, has applied this technique to UWB with its UWB Media+ Chip Antenna. This comes in a miniature size to suit digital cameras, PC peripherals, mobile phones and compact flash cards.

The Fractus antenna has been tested by one of the most prominent UWB chipmakers, Staccato Communications, as part of its Team Staccato Partner Program.

Also, Wisair demonstrated ‘detect and avoid’ technology at a committee meeting of the European technology standards body CEPT, in Copenhagen this week. The demonstration aimed to assist European and Japanese regulators in defining how to use UWB spectrum without interfering with other networks.

Detect and avoid techniques mitigate interference by searching for signals and then automatically switching the UWB device to another frequency to prevent any conflict.
“UWB can coexist effectively with both current and future wireless technologies sharing the same spectrum,” said Gadi Shor, CTO at Wisair. “Designed properly, detect and avoid provides the flexibility to support regulatory measures in different areas of the world and ease concerns about interference.”