Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 July 2005

WiNetworks emerges from stealth to turn triple play on its head

WiNetworks has emerged from a 30 month stealth project with the claim that it can give global digital satellite players a shot at a full triple, if not quadruple play.

The secret is simple. Snap a specially patented WiMAX antenna onto the Direct To Home satellite dish, use the existing cabling to bring both signals down to the living room, the WiMAX internet signal and the TV signal, and offer full interactive broadband wireless services in partnership with a WiMAX network operator.

In other words, just as Faultline has been predicting for the past two years, hybrid services may well prove to be the best way for Satellite TV companies to get into the triple play game, working across two infrastructures, in this case satellite and WiMAX. And it is likely, according to WiNetworks, to be able to offer compelling pricing.

WiNetworks says it has trials on both sides of the Atlantic and has married up major satellite partners with brand new broadband pre-WiMAX network operators. One European trial is weeks away from going to a full commercial trial with live customers parting with real cash.

WiNetworks itself just holds what it sees as key intellectual property in terms of carrying the signal on existing satellite wiring, and the smart, snap-on antenna, which it says takes 2 minutes to install.

It is now setting out to explore others ways of cashing in on this topology and this includes transcoding technology that it will bring into play so that MPEG2 files that are downloaded and stored on a PC can playout through the existing equipment by converting it on the fly to a DVB-S signal, which can play unchanged on the existing satellite set top.

One way that it says that it can further improve this hybrid design is by using WiMAX Meshing techniques to broaden the reach of WiMAX signals by snapping PicoStation WiMAX base stations onto roofs where the satellite operator owns rights, such as large apartments blocks that share a single satellite receiver.

Benjamin Finzi, president of WiNetworks told Faultline, ‘When you first talk to satellite owners they always try to send everything over the satellite, because it’s their only asset, but we know a satellite needs 500 times more capacity that it has, if it wants to offer interactivity. WiMAX is the right route to offer the return path, without all the problems of latency, while the satellite is perfect for broadcasting TV to a large footprint.’

‘In the US Digital Broadcast Satellite companies experience 18% churn per annum, about 1.5% a month. We know from cable that once you offer a full triple play that falls to between 3% and 5% a year. Right now we reckon that satellite operators pay about $1,000 to acquire a customer,’ he said.

‘That includes the marketing, the set top, the receiver and the installation costs. You can argue about the precise numbers, but they are in the right ball park,’ said Finzi

His logic is that there are about 25 million DBS customers in the US with over 14 million at DirecTV and 11 million at EagleStar’s Dish network. If 18% of them are having to be replaced each year, that comes to some 4.5 million and if this costs $1,000 each, then the two companies are spending $4.5 billion between them, just to stand still at the same number of customers. To grow (which currently they are doing) they are spending even more.

If that can be cut to under 5% per annum due to the lower churn experienced when a triple play is offered, then the US satellite operators could save over $3 billion a year. And Finzi’s logic is that a fully integrated bundle can be achieved with the existing satellite TV, and hi-speed internet lines and VoIP being supplied by WiMAX.

‘It’s important that this is a fully integrated bundle. The strategic partnerships that the satellite suppliers are supposed to have had with the RBOCs, where they simply resell the DBS services and put them on the same bill, are not integrated,’ he said.

WiNetworks offers a full range of pre-WiMAX base stations built around the Intel Rosedale chip, all which offer the kind of Quality of Service levels that will be needed for video delivery in the last mile. That means that if the triple play service also wants to offer a server based VoD service, alongside the satellite TV, it should be possible.

But the most important device WiNetworks offers is a Linux based multi-service gateway which splits the two signals that come down from the hybrid antenna. And this is also the device that manages the translation between MPEG2 and DVB-S signals.

This device can offer Ethernet switching, routing, Voice over IP, Broadband internet, On Demand interactive function and Video distribution.

At the moment that’s pretty much all that Finzi will say. At IBC in September he will show off a fully configured system complete with set top, satellite services and CA/DRM system, but doesn’t want to say which of these WiNetworks is working with just yet.

If it turns out that WiNetworks is working with NDS, then this almost certainly pushes WiNetworks towards DirecTV in the US and the company probably wants to keep its options open. As for set top makers, this equipment can work alongside any satellite set tops, although better integration with the EPG can also be achieved with some work, and he confirmed that WiNetworks is closer to some set top players than others but would not name them.

‘I only have one potential partner in each European country and two in the US. If they say no, I don’t have a business. So I have to move cautiously,’ he said, by way of explaining his reluctance to pre-announce.

He also isn’t quite yet ready to reveal which WiMAX network is planning to co-operate with which satellite provider, and whether or not that is a potential long term relationship, but the entire technology means it’s time for a new take on their triple play potential.

He insists that using existing satellite DBS service roof rights lowers the cost of WiMAX deployment. Creating a triple play fixed service creates the opportunity for at least one WiMAX network operator per country to reverse what were previously thought to be the service imperatives.

TV alongside VoIP and high speed internet, with potentially a new additional interactive TV model, and eventually a broader installed network for mobile deployment when IEEE 802.16e is delivered, is not how most people imagined WiMAX to rollout. Video was always supposed to be last.

There are many other imponderables? Will this mean that every satellite operator begins backing a WiMAX network operator? Does it mean that either share swaps between them will become the order of the day? Or will DBS operators use the churn reduction opportunity to completely reverse their objectives and apply for WiMAX spectrum of their own? Will all this be possible in unlicensed spectrum or will it need licensed?

Finzi reckons this is the lowest cost deployment possible for a WiMAX network, to co-operate with a DVB player. And while we have never thought that Satellite TV suppliers were under risk, clearly the cable model and the IPTV telco efforts are beginning to put them at risk and new customer gains are becoming harder and harder, while the churn rate does remain punishing.

It is true that the relationships between SBC, Bellsouth and Verizon and the satellite providers DirecTV and EchoStar are only skin deep.

As soon as the RBOCs develop their own TV services, there is little chance that they will want to keep the DBS suppliers alive. In fact come mid-2006, the idea of killing off the satellite TV suppliers will become attractive to the RBOCs. Under Finzi’s scenario it is the DBS suppliers that will not only be able to put the final nail in the coffin of the RBOCs, but this will also gives them the power they need to hold their own against the increasingly interactive services from cable operators.

The only ace that either of these operator types have up their sleeves are converged networks. Right now, under this scenario, there is no way that a network converges. What that would require is for a single architecture, preferably the Internet Protocol, to be used to deliver all aspects of a triple or quadruple play. It is only then that truly co-operative networks can offer services that don’t care what kind of network you are on. We’ve said it before, but being able to hold a teleconference from a mobile to a TV to a PC can only happen easily and cheaply when the networks handle the video traffic in more or less the same way rather than going back and forth through specialized expensive gateways.

The final dimension in most networks which will go to IP is the cellular connection, which that’s why IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem) has been heavily invested in by cellular. This is not to create pure IP networks but to allow cellular networks to interact with IP networks comfortably.

In this scenario the last item to go IP will be the TV service, rather than the cell phone. Satellite’s cannot, under their current economics, afford to offer flexible protocols that are less efficient, which is how IP is perceived. But in the short term, this is a rapid and cheap shift into a triple play for a third power base, and if it becomes widely adopted, it may well mean that the rules for surviving triple play have just been irrevocably changed.

The proof of the pudding however will be in the number and quality of partners, and as WiNetworks rolls those out, if they are sufficiently major, then this could become a turning point in the triple play wars.