Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 December 2011

Yahoo on the block? Does all the smoke mean a firesale?

Yahoo, like Hulu before it, is supposedly up for sale. Bids are arriving and newspapers are trying to get exclusives on who will land the prize, and what exactly they might do with it. Like Hulu it will almost certainly end up having to solve its own problems, shrink still further and fail more, until someone smaller is able to buy it. It’s preferred route appears to be taking onboard a 20% strategic shareholder.

That’s interesting, but we can see that the leaks to newspapers are coming from Yahoo ‘ not the bidders. That’s what happens when the board sacks the CEO and each board member follows their own priorities. Sure Yahoo WANTS a 20% shareholder, but does anyone WANT 20% of Yahoo. The current board has blatantly blocked moves by CEO Carole Bartz to do anything with the property, as it previously blocked the merger with Microsoft, which would have been in all shareholder’s interests. The company’s board dreams of being great again, but that outcome is exceptionally unlikely. Ask MySpace. When the world moves on, especially on the internet, it moves on.

The only way that Yahoo makes anyone any decent amount of money is focusing on the areas where it is successful, partnering everywhere else, and lending its brand to innovators who have new ideas. To do that it needs to be controlled by a thought leader in internet thinking. Private Equity players, like the ones who are supposed to be behind the attempts to buy into Yahoo ‘ such as Thomas H. Lee Partners, Silverlake, Andreessen Horowitz and Providence ‘ all who have been mentioned in connection with one bidder or another – usually borrow heavily and need predictable revenue figures in order to make a calculated play.

It is true that Yahoo revenues are pretty predictable, if falling. Its display sales are stable and the search revenues mostly went down due to presentation issues. Mostly.

In Yahoo’s last quarter it said revenue decreased 24% compared to 2010 which it attributed to decreases in both display and search revenue, but over the nine months of this year display revenue increased slightly, but were offset by falling search revenue. This was down to a re-statement of revenues because some dsearch revenue now goes to Microsoft, as well as the loss of an Affiliate in the Asia Pacific region. Income was off $12 million, but operating expenses were down $51 million.

The long and the short of this is that Yahoo is on a short fuse, as far as private equity is concerned and we don’t see how any private equity company can get involved and leave the existing board in place. Thomas Lee and partners is supposed to be considering an out and out purchase of the company, all the other leaked bids are supposed to be for this magic 20%, which we really cannot see as being workable. This is a company cutting costs to keep under its revenue, not growing revenue, and the rate of fall of revenue could accelerate at any time as it loses more and more brand equity.

When we think about Yahoo we each think of different things. Some think financial information, others a search tool, a mobile company may think about handset video delivery, while consumers may think about Yahoo’s ability to show live events the world over.

In revenue terms the company is a display advertising giant, and a search advertising second rater. But more than anything it is misunderstood. We cannot claim to know what Carole Bartz was referring to when she was asked who should now run Yahoo, just as she was booted out, and she replied, ‘Me, because I know what needs to be done.’

Because sure as hell we (Faultline) don’t know what to do with it, and we doubt that private equity groups can do more than cut it up and sell it on. Microsoft might genuinely be a home for the troubled company, and merged into MSN (and if later you added AOL) may create a foil for the Google’s and Facebooks of this world, though it looks like the old world fighting off the young world, and we know how that always ends. Internet audiences are fickle and can change overnight.

This whole issue with Microsoft is due to the deal Yahoo did 2 years ago to put its search with Microsoft’s Bing engine. It means that revenues that were previously stated as entirely Yahoo revenues now have to be partially stated as Microsoft revenue. Accordingly it has cut its costs. This doesn’t mean that the number of pages that were viewed on Yahoo or Yahoo affiliates have gone down, just that more companies take a share of the money.

The deal was back end loaded – initially it had a revenue guarantee, plus 88% of the revenue would show on Yahoo’s books, plus up to $150 million of compensation from Microsoft to pay for transition costs. At first it would have looked like Yahoo revenues were fine, but they were always going to go down, more or less in line with the current figures. These numbers were predictable two years ago , and this crisis has been created by the removal of Bartz, rather than quarterly numbers showing mismanagement.

The transition to using the Microsoft algorithms was completed in the US and Canada in the fourth quarter of 2010, so those transition payments have begun to disappear and next quarter is the first year on year quarter without them. It will be a bloodbath in Yahoo shares ‘ hence the need to do a quick and dirty deal now. However the rest of the transition costs, outside the US and Canada, will keep going well into 2013.

Yahoo now expects display revenue to remain flat for the fourth quarter, with search revenue down further, but search page views bizarrely are up 2% in the quarter. So it is likely that once we are really comparing like with like, the revenues will stop falling. At least for a while.

Our favored outcome, now as before, is that Microsoft buys the company out, and sells off what it doesn’t want, but failing that, anything that sees root and branch management change, and the focus needs to be on video going forwards, an area where Yahoo has excelled, even in the most recent dark years.