Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 March 2006

Yahoo TV executive has to rethink his view on video properties

Buried in a New York Times piece this week, focusing on whether or not Yahoo would continue to sponsor and create its own content, is an important subject for the Faultline.

It has always been universally stated, time and time again, that telcos when creating telco TV should partner with content, not create it. It was the same way before them with cable companies (mostly). So will it be that way with portals?

The NY Times piece focused on differences between Lloyd Braun, a former senior executive at ABC Entertainment, and his boss at Yahoo, CEO Terry Semel.

It seems that the TV executive went for a huge budget for creating shows and got it thrown back in his face. Instead the Yahoo crew felt that getting user generated content was the way forward.

Their differences have apparently now been settled and the strategy adopted is one of lower budget with user involvement. The purchase and ramping of sites like MySpace have happened since Braun was first recruited, but it seems somehow crass to go get a TV specialist and then tell him NOT to produce good TV, at least not the way he has always done in the past.

User generated content is the equivalent to reality TV for the broadcasting networks and cable networks, and even then it has largely been produced in order to cut their content spend. It doesn’t always have the same appeal as professionally produced programming.

When Google first began Google Video it introduced the prospect of the wider world contributing video, and even though it is now trying to convert the service into a market place for paid and free video content, it immediately uncovered one problem ‘ how should users navigate video content? Other portals have the same problem and perhaps a search engine is only a small part of the answer.

Video content that is made up of 5,000 professional films and TV series is one thing. Navigation is through favorite genres, actors, directors, music score writers. But with millions of user contributed videos of varying quality, with a huge range of topics, that’s quite another thing.

What MySpace has done is create community in its social networking site. The core index is a buddylist. See what your buddies say about themselves and what they have recently said to others and to you. Look at the music they like, the videos they have made of themselves. But is this a way to index all video?

Could it extend to films that buddies have seen, or buddies of buddies. Can it take in films they rate highly, videos they have made themselves, and if so can everyone see them or can they be shielded under the owner’s control? And it is the same for paid for, professionally produced video as for user contributed video, and how do you invoke quality and decency standards?

These now are what Braun has to engage with, and look for a paradigm that works, without it being a direct copy of MySpace, with a number of technical capabilities that make it both easy and foolproof. And again, why would you employ someone from the TV world to do that. They’re probably the least capable as they have to overcome preconceptions all the time.

Better to pay a group of 50 youngsters to act as your ideas engine and your field research group.

One idea that has worked for Yahoo has been the site Yahoo built for the 2006 Winter Olympics. Photos could be loaded from Flickr Yahoo’s photo-sharing site, and blended in with professionally produced content.

In the meantime Yahoo will continue with the content that it has come up with, except for its famous ‘The Runner,’ series with someone running across America trying to evade identification by the public at large. This was one of Braun’s ideas at ABC that it didn’t run with, and that now Yahoo won’t either.

So expect Yahoo to embrace things like blogs and innovative content sharing that have no parallels in the world of broadcasting.