The third survey in as many weeks has been announced on IPTV and whether or not the consumer knows what it is or if they want it, this one coming from US research company In-Stat.
It says that the RBOCs face a skeptical customer base, with just 5% of satellite or cable TV subscribers who responded to a 15,000 strong consumer survey, saying they would definitely switch to a telco TV provider. With around 68 million cable customers and about 25 million satellite customers in the US, that would amount to as many as 9.3 million subscribers, which is more or less in line with the market penetration that other researchers have been suggesting over the next four years or so.
But another 13% said they would consider switching, with 52% undecided, believing they will go with the service offering the most channels or charging the least amount. Respondents said the features they were most interested in from any pay TV was time shifting, caller ID on their TV and interactive information.
If any service offers video surveillance and video telephony a further 25% are willing to pay a little extra for this.
The interesting thing is that neither the cable operators nor the telcos had a particularly good name across a wide section of respondents, giving neither the edge in pure brand appeal. The survey was sponsored by Siemens, which has a vested interest in promoting IPTV, but which has no major US telco trials.
If this survey is right, then the cable companies might as well give up and go home now. Like the two surveys before it, one by Accenture and the other rather misguided survey by Harris, it is the exact nature of the questions that are asked which defines the answers. The Accenture survey established that 46% of Europeans hadn’t a clue what IPTV was, although they said they would like VoD access to movies, DVRs and less advertising. The Harris survey mixed up file downloading and IPTV so badly that the results really meant very little.
In this In-Stat survey respondents were asked if they would like a Digital Video Recorder, and while they said a big yes this is not a basis for moving away from satellite (which first offered DVRs) or cable (which now offers them).
Similarly video telephony and caller ID on your TV set can be offered almost as easily by cable, and potentially could be offered by Satellite operators if they added an additional broadband return path, so this shouldn’t really be used as an indicator of mass migrations in US pay TV services, more a features wish list.
However if both that 5% confident of switching and the not quite so sure 13% of US pay TV services did migrate, then telco TV would emerge with over 16 million TV customers virtually overnight, and we don’t believe that is going to happen. Early adopters will have to wait until their existing contracts run out and for the new services to become available in their area, and then they must buy into the new services. Assuming that works out well, they will then gradually begin to influence consumers on the ground as they witness the quality of services at friends homes.
But also price is clearly important. The survey said that with as little as a 10% price premium some 34% would either “probably” or “definitely” switch service supplier.
Respondents also said they would like some services at no extra fees and this included caller ID on the TV (69%) interactive information (63%) and call logging (58%), and remote programming (57%).
Funnily portable entertainment applications were not a big plus for this audience, although In-Stat said that maybe as they emerged, more people would use them.