Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 March 2006

Zhone Technologies still has its shirt on broadband last mile

For the majority of its lifetime Zhone Technologies, formed in 1999 has had to operate in what has been a recession for the telecommunications equipment suppliers, and never even had a product of its own until 2003.

But with $500 million in initial investment and the proven leadership partnership of Jeanette Symons and Mory Ejabat, the founders of Ascend Communications who sold out for $24 billion in 1999, it was never likely that the management was going to panic.

At Ascend Symons and Ejabat rode the ISP wave and in Zhone the deal was supposed to be that they rode the broadband wave.

But in January it delivered yet more bad news for its long suffering investors, with impairments of $102 million for acquisitions it has made forcing it back into losses of $107 million for a quarter in which it had revenues of only $53.2 million.

Last September Zhone completed acquisition networking specialist Paradyne, a company that has been around simply forever and once was part of AT&T, for $185 million, and which had settled into the DSLAM market, itself acquiring Net to Net Technologies a year or so earlier, also focused on the DSLAM market.

Much of the write down was associated with Paradyne, along with Sorrento Networks, acquired back in 2004. The company has thrived on acquisitions which is why it carries so much goodwill on its balance sheet, driving the impairments.

Taking to Steven Klein Steve Klein, Director Video Solutions at Zhone this week he said that the company began life with the acquisition of Nortel’s AccessNode business, which it deliberately took on board as a cash cow to bring in early revenues. Its strategy has always been to replace those access nodes with DSLAMs but even now it has a residual revenue stream from it.

In its early days it has also acquired Vpacket a VoIP business, Xybridge a softswitch supplier, Optaphone in short haul wireless, Roundview and IP engineering specialist, CAG a telecom subsystems builder and Premisys multiple access servers.

The company has a look about it of a business that was growing by acquisition, but without too much of a plan, but in 1999 it reversed into Tellium and got itself public, and revenues for 2005 have somehow clawed their way up from $97 million last year, to $152 million, despite the acquisition based losses. The company still has $71 million in the bank, with only $29 million in debt. Plenty of companies that operated in the telecom market in the early 2000 years are in a lot worse shape.

‘From day one it has been the company’s philosophy to build next generation access devices,’ explains Klein, putting it squarely in the IPTV market. ‘And the philosophy has been to borrow big money and acquire legacy installations.

‘That’s what we did at Nortel and that’s what we did with the NEC Transmission and Access business,’ said Klein.

Although Zhone has been around for quite a while, starting out in 1999, the product that it was started for has only been out since 2003, called the Multiple Access Loop Concentrator (MALC). But it is a slow ramp, because the company has been forced to target smaller telcos.

‘We haven’t actually bothered pushed the MALC at the big incumbent Telcos. That’s a great business if you can get it, but Alcatel dominates that market, and the sales cycle is about two and a half years.

‘We got most of our business out of the CLEC (competitive local exchange carriers) market and our biggest customer in the US is Cavalier Telephone. Outside the US we have customers in Brazil, the UAE and Eastern Europe.

‘But we are finding that the CLEC market is coming back strong. Sure the market has fallen by two thirds, but those that are still in it are much stronger and more stable.

‘There are 178 independent telephone companies and lots of these are interested in trying to offer IPTV and triple play, but there are only 2 or 3 that have installations above 5000 homes. There are a lot of rural Telcos in middle America offering triple play to maybe 1,000 to 2,000 customers,’ said Klein.

Another influence on business has been the arrival of Microsoft on the IPTV scene says Klein. ‘There have been huge ripple effects from SBC buying into Microsoft TV. For one thing, back when all the smaller guys were doing IPTV, the studios never thought much about it. Very few operators bothered with content protection. Since the day that Microsoft announced a deal with Alcatel at Supercomm two years ago, the Studios put out an edict within 30 days that all content had to be protected.’

‘I was working at video trials a US West at the time, and they were working well and they had high take up rates, but they were stopped in their tracks.’

‘The other thing is that has slowed the IPTV market has been the perception that you need a lot of servers to do it well. There are 23,000 servers in the AT&T implementation. A head end for a small telco will set it back $2 million and that’s a big investment. They are worried that they will have to put together a system like AT&T, and that after spending $48 a head buying in a channel line up, which they will only be able to charge $59.95 for leaves a tight margin. People are worried they won’t get a payback on IPTV, so there is paralysis in the market,’ said Klein.