Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 May 2011

Deutsche Telekom is confident enough to talk about spending $39 billion

While we have spent long hours criticizing and condemning AT&T’s deal to buy T-Mobile USA, from a point of view of it harming competition in the US. There remains a critical question for Europe ‘ what will Deutsche Telekom do with all that money ‘ some $39 billion.

A number of European sources including Bloomberg this week reported on a speech given by Ronald Mahler, head of Telekom’s European operations outside Germany in Europe, and he is saying quite openly that at least some of it will be used to dominate European fixed lines.

Many fixed line businesses are either weak or still controlled fully or partially by the local government and are in need of liberalizing. It is already negotiating to buy the remaining half of Slovak Telecom and Mahler could just as easily take a peek at assets in Austria, Poland and The Netherlands says Bloomberg.

To us these suggestions make some sense, but not too much ‘ Austria is neighboring, and it could feasibly buy Austria Telecom, which anyway has done a pretty poor job of maximizing its pay TV operation using IPTV, but both Telecom Italia and Orascom have tried before to buy into Austria Telekom and the government holding has always deterred them and of course we have to look just as much at mobile holdings, and T-Mobile and A1 would create a 73% plus cellular monopoly. Other Austrian pay TV operations are all cable, and unlikely to attract DT, which now has no cable holdings.

Poland for us is also a booming market, but as we point out, owning fixed lines is all very well, but it has to be possible to monetize them ‘ you don’t buy into businesses which are slowing or losing revenue ‘ unless you can turn them around ‘ so DT needs to target IPTV and triple play as a critical area. And it would make sense that Deutsche Telekom could target operators where there is less pay TV penetration than its own country, 60% or under, unless it can buy a company that has a big share already. Poland has a penetration of 78% and Cyfrowy Polsat is the out and out leader, but is a satellite TV operation, with 3.3 million customers.

Deutsche Telekom is a fresh convert to satellite and is launching DTH operations in Germany, and already owns them in Romania, Hungary and Slovakia. It’s suddenly at home with this technology and a more creative play could be to buy a telco that has a poor or non-existent IPTV operation and purchase a major DTH business. In every case where DT has a satellite operation, it also have IPTV so it can offer a triple play.

So Cyfrowy Polsat could be a target, but since France Telecom owns Telekomunikacja Polska, and since Cyfrowy Polsat already has a market capitalization of €6 billion, it would mean that DT pays through the nose and still doesn’t achieve any fixed line dominance. Perhaps if it also bought Netia, which owns the second-largest fixed-line network in Poland, it might achieve enough momentum to dislodge France Telecom. Another company mentioned by Bloomberg is Telefonia Dialog, a subsidiary of Polska Miedz a big mining conglomerate, but it has only 466,000 physical lines and some wholesale lines on the incumbent’s network, which might be big enough for DT to get a start in Poland. Exatel was also mentioned, by so far, like Telefonia Dialog, has no triple play opportunity and would be a start up in TV.

The Netherlands could again be a dual play, where you buy both a satellite TV operator and an ISP, but this would be far cheaper. It might buy Tele2 there, with its 150,000 or so IPTV lines and try to leverage the M7 Group out of its main Satellite investment in Canal Digitaal, or simply launch its own satellite service. Tele2 would be a pittance, and Canal Digitaal is not a public asset, but would likely cost over €1 billion given that it has over a million subscribers and is growing faster than any other operator there in pay TV, except KPN itself. KPN has around 350,000 IPTV customers and 75% of these are triple play customers. But in a market that is already 95.7% penetrated with Pay TV it makes little sense for DT to take over a minnow, and the market capitalization of KPN At €15.5 billion and the hostility of such a takeover, is likely to prohibit a purchase there. It must be remembered that DT has some ISP lines there, so it could potentially simply add IPTV and build out, but that’s not the DT way. Where it buys it has a chance at dominance.

Perversely the countries with lower penetration today in pay TV include majors like the UK, as well as Sweden, Portugal, Italy, Switzerland, Spain and Greece where DT already holds control of OTE. Smaller countries, more likely for DT investment, might be Latvia, Estonia, the Czech Republic, Croatia and Lithuania, although in Croatia DT is already the dominant supplier and Pay TV operator

In our opinion Italy is out because of Mediaset’s strength and Sky Italia and the intensive way they are fighting it out there; Spain is out because of the current economy there and the fact that France Telecom has nascent investments there ahead of it. We think it is happy with its Greek control with local interests owning the rest of OTE, and it will use this as a vehicle to buy full control of RomTelecom (there remains 46% in the hands of the government).

Likewise the UK has a three way storm brewing in pay TV between Sky and Virgin and the YouView consortium, and already Telefonica and Orange have an ISP head start there, which should make it a no go for DT unless it buys BT, and that would eat all its money and bring it a heap of trouble, both political and financial.

Equally glibly Sweden is too well served and Portugal has both Telefonica and France Telecom in attendance, which just leaves us with Switzerland where Swisscom’s dominance goes pretty much un-resisted. Of course DT could buy Sunrise the second placed player there, which conveniently moved into the hands of private equity group CVC Capital Partners from TDC a year ago, after it acquired the fixed lines of Tele2 in that country paying around 3.3 billion Swiss Francs, around €2.6 billion.

That’s a deal that would make a lot of sense, given that half of Switzerland speaks German anyway and culturally they are very similar. Also the fact that Pay TV there is led by declining cable assets, and Swisscom has yet to seriously build out its customers base in IPTV, which makes it perfect for triple play. Pay TV penetration is 54.6% as at the end of last year.

Among the smaller central European players of Latvia, Estonia, the Czech Republic, Croatia and Lithuania, Scandinavian interests in the form of ViaSat, Telenor and TeliaSonera are already strong in Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania, and these countries really are very small. At some point a move on the Czech Republic is almost a certainty for DT we think. Towercom’s Skylink is attacking pay TV very hard in both Slovakia where DT plans to buy to 100% ownership and in the Czech Republic, and once again DT could adopt a dual approach, buy a satellite TV operator and buy ISPs to go with it. Skylink has been growing in this market faster than any other pay TV operator and if DT wanted to get under the nose of the Telefonica owned incumbent telco, it could do no better than to buy Dial Telecom, which is currently suing Telefonica for blocking access to its broadband lines. The combination of making the going easier in Slovakia and getting into a new market might force DT to make overtures to Skylink.

So if we were guiding the DT strategy for Mahler we’d be backing him all the way in Poland, but suggesting he hits out on at least two more fronts, in Switzerland and the Czech Republic if the deal to sell T-Mobile USA to AT&T goes ahead.

Let’s assume that out of $39 billion that $7 or $8 billion goes into a special investor dividend, that $5 billion is used to pare down debt, that another $5 billion will want to fill its coffers and a further $5 billion goes in accelerated capex around the company ‘ that still leaves a war chest of $16 billion and it could do all of what we have suggested for that and still have change for any contingency deals that come up. Its triple play powerbase would go from touching a population today of 134 million in Germany, Croatia, Greece, Hungary, Romania and Slovakia to reaching a further 56 million and a total of 190 million people, by adding Switzeland, the Czech Republic and Poland to the mix.

And if it wants to get the most use of its money, the strategy that it has employed in Greece where it owns 30% and local investors enjoy its guidance and take the rest of the business, then it can spread its influence far and wide and keep locals on board. This is somewhat similar to the strategy that News Corp operates in its investments. Either way expect Deutsche Telecom’s fixed line portfolio and in particular its triple play operations involving pay TV, will be radically higher in 12 to 24 months from now, even if it chooses different targets and it may soon have over 33% of the EU population in reach of its services.

Already we expect DT to be the 6th largest pay TV operator in Europe by 2014, and if it goes on a spending spree, it would easily topple both France Telecom and Kabel Deutschland and be sneaking up behind the big three of News Corp, Liberty Global and Vivendi come 2014.