Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 June 2011

Same old claims from Nielsen, it must wake up to Netflix realities

The same inevitable conclusion has been reached for the umpteenth time by leading US TV watcher Nielsen, that yet again during 2010 the average American watched more TV ‘ up by 22 minutes a month over the previous quarter, up to 159 hours viewing TV per month.

This is the traditional conclusion for what has become a quarterly reporting service from Nielsen called its Cross Platform Report ‘ which is supposed to take in pay TV, broadcast TV and the watching of streaming video on a laptop and also on smartphones.

There are at least two things which makes alarm bells ring when we read this type of release from Nielsen ‘ the first is that although the report is quarterly this is the first time that a press release has been issued with conclusions from the report. What this means is that this is the first quarter when a comparison with this time last year is possible ‘ in effect it is the start of the service and there have been no previous press releases containing data about Cross Platform viewing.

You have to be really careful believing a company that has a vested interest to say that TV is healthy and doing fine, and which doesn’t want to show the world how much streaming there is. Which brings us to the other point ‘ its survey of some 7,500 people asks about streaming to a PC, but does not ask about streaming to a TV. It asks about DVD and DVR viewing, but not streaming to a DVD player.

So this is a cross platform report, which is not fully cross platform, and refuses to accept that Netflix ‘ the biggest challenge that pay TV in the US has ever faced ‘ even exists, and that TV Everywhere can only be terminated at a PC, which is not the case. This is because Nielsen makes some comparisons with last year’s Q1 Three Screen Report, which of course doesn’t take in video streamed to a smart TV. It will probably be another year before it has enough data on streams to TV sets, and guess what, it will headline with TV being healthy.

Nielsen says that TV in the home includes live usage plus any playback viewing within the measurement period, Timeshifted TV is playback primarily on a DVR but includes playback from VOD, DVD recorders, server based DVR’s and services like Start Over. So it doesn’t include catch up TV services sent over the internet, so not Hulu Plus either.

We think there is a considerable element of the Kings new clothes about this report and if Nielsen can be trusted to bring good data to the party, it won’t be for some years when it has all of the elements of a multi-screen strategy. Tablets for instance are not mentioned and we’re sure it plans to collect that data, but it needs a year or so of data before it’s of any use it seems.

The truth is that people probably ARE watching more TV, on average, in a recession, when you include all the out of work people that can’t do much else. But if you add TV Everywhere to the TV and Netflix to the TV, then Nielsen’s figures would be MUCH, MUCH higher ‘ and we can’t see that. Facebook alone should have accounted for some of those hours (although many people use Facebook and watch TV at the same time).

We think that the pure TV numbers are really going down dramatically, and if Nielsen was to compare like with like, it would have said that people are watching more TV content via DVD and DVR and online, and even on their phones, but not on TV ‘ but it prefers to add it all up and claim that TV is on the rise.

It says for instance that 91% of all homes in the US still have a pay TV services and there is no evidence of cord cutting. But what Nielsen should be looking at is whether or not there are behavioral changes which will lead to cord cutting. It should also be looking at the level of engagement that TV brings these days ‘ if people are only partially engaged with TV viewing and are also working or tweeting or commenting on Facebook at the same time, their responsiveness to advertising MUST be going down, due to a lower level of engagement with TV ‘ and as a result people should switch their ad monies from TV to, say, Facebook, or just pay the same but across both.

And anyway Nielsen came out with some very trendy looking graphs that state the ‘bleeding’ obvious. It has long been fond of saying that if someone watches a lot of TV they watch a lot of every type of TV ‘ live, DVR, online streaming should therefore all rise together. Nielsen says it’s identified a radical shift in this previously noted TV viewing pattern, with those people who watch the most online streaming (to laptops) watching the least TV, and vice versa. This trend amplifies in the 18 to 34 segment and the result is the graph below.

Anyone that has an 18 year old in the house knows that they watch most of their TV on a laptop using a catch up service. They only watch TV when they are in fact ‘not watching’ it and are instead doing their homework in front of a TV.

It’s fairly easy for Nielsen to fast forward this trend and work out that ALL TV is going online by the time this 18 year old generation becomes the 55+ generation, which is, of course, not for 37 years ‘ unless something changes ‘ and of course that change may be that streaming becomes viable for a larger part of the total audience, or becomes easier to install. Things ARE changing and a wider group of viewers will take up these streaming services and come to rely on them. This group of 18 to 34 year olds will be advocates of this type of viewing and it will spread.

This is how all such developments go. Youngsters find something new and claim it for themselves and identify with it. Then it gets easier and more players find a justification to launch into the space and advertise the fact. Then even newer viewing behavior emerges in the next generation and so on.

Nielsen does its customers no favors by trying to hide the fact that we are heading to a place where cord cutting may happen in droves, but may still be avoided with prudent action ‘ whereas instead it tends to just preach that nothing bad can happen to TV, when we all know it will.

Nielsen says, ‘With traditional TV (in the US) representing a $70 billion-plus advertising market, it’s no surprise that other content players want to get in the game and established players continue to innovate across platforms. Though we’re seeing strong growth for mobile and Internet video, traditional TV remains dominant. Each month, US consumers spent nearly 159 hours viewing TV in their homes, 4 ‘ hours viewing Internet video on their computer, and more than 4 hours watching video on their mobile devices,’ said Matt O’Grady, Executive Vice President, Media Audience Measurement, Nielsen. ‘The good news for both media companies and advertisers is that it’s clear consumers are willing to pay for high quality content.’

I’m not sure that anyone is going to subscribe to something with such overwhelmingly unrealistic optimism ‘ except most advertising based businesses cannot survive without Nielsen services.

Mobile video viewing may only be a handful of video hours a month, but it increased 41% over this time last year and more than 100% since 2009.

Another interesting graph is the one above, showing how satellite is still on the rise, cable in the doldrums and Telco TV growing, while broadcast only homes remain static. The movement is slow except that cable has lost over 2% of US homes in the past 12 months. If this accelerates slightly then significant changes in the landscape can happen in 12 to 24 months.

Time-shifted television continues to grow says Neilsen, both in the penetration of DVR devices in the home and the time spent using them, rising by 1 million people in the last quarter alone and by over 7.4 million over the year, but says this averages out at 2.2 hours a week, although it continues to confuse this stat by doing that as a percentage of total homes not those with DVRs. We would expect DVR viewing times to be approaching more like 2 hours a day, rather than per week in DVR homes and until this is more realistically represented by Nielsen we can’t believe its numbers.

We’re not saying that the Nielsen data is useless, only that it can show upwards and downward trends and it can compare different cultural trends, but it trails behind what’s happening in technology and appears to be comfortable playing a reactionary role rather than the leadership one which is needed in TV change right now.