Many cable and telco operators in the US are completely baffled by the idea that regulators can force operators to open up their networks with sub-consumer priced wholesale offerings. But the entire stimulation for DSL networks around Europe come from this unbundling process, which itself was a copy of a regulation that the US tried to push through, but had revoked by its courts.
The US effort was only aimed at the RBOC telcos, which today would translate to Verizon and AT&T, and few others ‘ and it failed because a Court believed that the enforced wholesale pricing was unsustainable. But across Europe the idea of building a cost model for the provision of wholesale services has worked wonders for DSL broadband, and now Belgium is planning to extend the idea to TV and by implication to the market leaders there, the cable TV operators.
The market leaders in Pay TV in Belgium are Liberty Global’s Telenet and Tecteo’s Voo operation who make up about 90% of cable customers there. The French operator Numericable is also mentioned in the ruling by the conference of regulators (CRC) as well as minnows Brutele and AIESH, though AIESH has some relief from the ruling.
The ruling will become law from this August and compliance will need to happen by October 2012, essentially saying that both analog and digital TV wholesale offers must be made as well as one for broadband ‘ the eventual ideal is that small triple plays could be forged as virtual operators working on the same infrastructure as the cable operators ‘ what the US used to call Competitive Exchange Carriers when applied to telcos, but quite what you’d call them on a cable network we’re not sure ‘ TV Virtual Network Operators perhaps (TVNOs).
Belgacom is outside the ruling in the sense that cable operators won’t have to supply lines to Belgacom because it has its own digital network for digital TV and broadband, although technically it can ask for analog cable services to be part of its customer bundle, though clearly it won’t as it has a strong and growing IPTV base.
The only new obligation to Belgacom is that it must make access to its multicast routers available in the same way.
This ruling has some way to go before it becomes law. First off Telenet, by far the largest cable operator, and owned by Liberty Global the largest Pay TV operator in Europe, plans to go to war legally to stop this from happening, and as we said before, that legal approach worked in the US. Secondly the European Commission is reported as having misgivings in applying forced wholesale offerings on Cable companies.
But if the ruling survives in any way shape or form, even without the strength to compel the local cable operators to adhere to it, Belgacom is likely to open its doors to new pay TV operators using its own infrastructure and there will likely be a queue from any unbundled ISPs that already use its broadband lines and the outcome will not just be OTT services, but will be both OTT and multicast, and its protected QoS controlled IPTV environment and the combination could spawn a number of high quality, HD capable TV based triple plays ‘ complete with tablet targeted OTT content.
Unbundling services has proved one of the most potent forms of controlling prices, through wide scale service innovation and price competition, as well as getting faster consumer uptake. Whatever happens to this ruling, it is exceptionally bad news for cable operators, not just in Belgium, but right across Europe. If this experiment goes through without intervention by the courts or the EC, and it proves a success in Belgium, other European regulators will adopt it. In the UK BT already has plans to offer wholesale multicasts access, and is upgrading its broadband router network to offer multicasts. While cable companies can move off footprint with OTT services, as Virgin plans to with its TiVo based system, cable companies are regional in nature and rarely cover an entire territory so will have more trouble offering TVNO capability against telcos.
In France virtually all of the operators there use fully multicast enabled networks, and are already familiar with unbundling, where they are the most advanced in Europe and where they have seen the net effect on IPTV uptake. But right now they would each fight tooth and claw to retain control of their networks, though that attitude would change if they could all hijack the Orange network. However the last thing France needs is more Pay TV competition, it’s everywhere else that needs to copy France.
And if the idea extends to cable operators as well, and is taken up around the rest of Europe, suddenly every ISP will be able to offer HD capable TV services alongside OTT video, without any requirement to understand or invest in the technology ‘ so strong brands, whether they be retailers or luxury brands, could come to market with pay TV, or potentially triple play services.
Our thoughts are that this has come about due to Belgacom lobbying to the regulator, and that what it is after is level playing field with its dominant cable pay TV rivals, but the effect could be substantially broader than perhaps has been envisaged.
The ruling comes from the CRC (the Conference of Regulators of the electronic communications) which includes the Vlaamse Regulator voor de Media, the Conseil Sup’rieur de l’Audiovisuel, the Medienrat en the Belgian Institute for Postal Services and Telecommunications).
So far no detail has been set for the wholesale offers that the cable companies need to add, and no mandatory pricing has been published, but usually in Europe there will be a maximum priced involved in the regulation, perhaps expressed as a percentage of consumer pricing.
In the UK BT sees itself as becoming an aggregator, a sort of agent for TV channels, where the operator agrees with the channel owner directly, but BT will have it already multicast and ready if a deal can be struck, and deliver all channels and separate them out using simulcast conditional access. Rights issues may well become streamlined, as the EC is keen to see this happen (see last week’s Faultline).
What is driving the ruling is that international benchmarking shows that TV products in Belgium are not cheap when compared to the rest of Europe and triple plays are even less so and consumer choice is often limited to one or at best two pay TV suppliers.
The ruling was taken after consulting consumer associations, copyright societies and sector players, the CRC said and it also said that it submitted the draft ruling to the Competition Council and adapted its ruling to take comments into account. It also said that the European Commission did not initiate an additional examination so it concludes that the Commission’s concerns are not that strong. It said that the
‘European Commission did not object to the draft decisions but formulated several comments, which the CRC took utmost account of when amending the decisions that are published today. ‘