A week is a long time in show business and if the past week on the US stock market is anything to go by, it’s even longer in share prices. But it seems that this is especially true if those share prices happen to be in Show Business ‘ or in this case on the edge of show business ‘ the pay TV industry in the US had a definitive a price correction this week.
This could prove to be an historic turning point and despite the fact that this happened in a week when the USA debt crises has investors running for the market exit and when leadership of the US economy appeared to be faltering, the fall in share prices in pay TV are far worse and the adjustment doesn’t look like being unraveled even if the US stock market recovers from its own woes.
The state of the market will invite everyone to accelerate their multiscreen or other strategies and move on business models to make them less resistible.
Perhaps the mood of the overall market had some say in the matter as analyst sentiment finally swept aside all the arguments about cord cutting or not cord cutting with the current crop of pay TV results and crashed the share prices of every pay TV company, irrespective of its financial performance. Dish had to make do with a 20% fall in its share value, cushioned by the mystique of what it’s up to with Blockbuster, EchoStar, its spectrum hoarding and other acquisitions like Move Networks. Others would have been happy to trade places with Dish and have only a 20% fall, as share prices were re-adjusted, as the entire view of the industry took a hammering.
This week there were just few US pay TV company results to tidy away, to get to the underlying industry numbers that caused the landslide, with most share graphs in the sector looking like the Rockies (big steep drops) including those from Charter, Comcast, DirecTV and Dish.
Charter has increased the number of homes passed with video to 11.8 million but its TV customers have fallen over the past year, by a considerable 5% down to 4,173,400 from 4,407,000 a year earlier and down from 4,253,300 one quarter ago. Charter lost $1.6 billion from its market capitalization, off 25%.
It made its usual noises about revenue generating units being up, to 13.1 million from 12.9 million a year earlier, with video down as we’ve mentioned, digital video up to 3.4 million and Internet customers up to 3.35 million, a rise of 6%. Phone customers rose to 1.75 million from 1.66 million, also up 6%.
ARPU is up overall by 3% with TV at $71.40 up 3%, Internet down 1% at $41.76 a month and phone off 3% to $40.49. ARPU per Customer Relationship is up 3% to $105 with vide customers making far more at $133.84
Revenues were up 2% to $1.79 billion with a loss of $107 million up from a loss last time of $82 million, after capex of some $324 million, all of which generated $155 million in free cash flow.
Comcast naturally had revenues up by 50% when it incorporated NBC, jumping from $9.5 billion to $14.3 billion but elsewhere the story was more of the same, with TV customers down to 22.5 million homes, off by 238,000 in the quarter. Internet customers more than made up for the TV losses, up to 17.5 million from 16.5 million a year earlier and up 517,000 on the quarter. Voice customers were also up by 503,000 to just over 9 million. Even Comcast which really has a piece of performing show business in NBC couldn’t escape the cull and lost 20% of its share value down to a market cap of $55.6 billion.
Its non NBC revenues grew to $9.3 billion in the quarter up from $8.8 billion last time and to $18.4 billion year to date. The discrepancy here with the earlier $9.5 billion number is that some of Comcast’s Interactive Media is now quoted inside the NBC figures. The NBC figures themselves were up 17.1% to $5.2 billion. Capex on the Comcast network was up 5.5% to just shy of $1.2 billion and free cashflow on the whole operation was a healthy $1.52 billion. The results llok positive and ahead of expectations, but with most of the positives on the NBC side of the equation. Co mcast shed 20% this week.
Dish results also had a positive sheen, but this was more the miracle of how Dish continues to improve revenues and margins with falling subscribers as well as the mystery that surrounds the Dish spectrum trading and its other various subsidiaries.
Revenues were up 13% to $3.59 billion, compared with $3.17 billion a year earlier and net income surged 30% to $335 million from $257 million. TV subscribers were off 135,000 customers to end at 14 million in total. This was all due to lower gross adds, which were down to 572,000 from 747,000 this time last year, all of which was explained by new promotional offers from rivals ‘ does it include Netlfix in those rivals we wonder? And although Dish got churn back down to 1.67%, compared to 1.78% for the same period in 2010, it would have been better still had rivals not been quite so cutthroat the company said.
Dish touted the renewal of a deal with Frontier Communications a large rural telco which resells Dish. Frontier has 4 million customers in 27 states.
Much of the increase in revenues was down to passing on content pricing increases to customers, the company said. It also completed the purchase of Blockbuster during the quarter and said that in total it paid $238 million which fell to $234 million after a $4 million refund. This was substantially less than its winning bid of $321 million, and we’re not quite sure where those changes came from. Dish has cut another ten Blockbuster stores and in July cut 155 more, taking Blockbuster stores down to 1,500.
More direction was given on the fate of the spectrum chunks that Dish now holds, acquired from TerreStar and DBSD, in total 40 MHz of S-Band spectrum, perfect for LTE build out, but this is covered in a separate item below.
Despite the improved financials Dish has been hammered by a 20% fall in its share price since the figures came out, wiping almost $2.4 billion off the stock as investors have finally begun to notice what we’ve been saying all along, that the weak US economy, combined with tougher price competition within the industry and the additional threat of Netflix, means there will be prolonged pay TV subscriber losses across the board.
With DirecTV only recording a small improvement in subscribers numbers, this quarter is perhaps the first when satellite TV as a whole fell in subscribers numbers in the US. Overall the pay TV industry fell by some estimates by around 580,000 subscribers after factoring in gains at Verizon and AT&T and for the first time the investment community seems to have taken flight at the idea. DirecTV also had a fall of 20%.
By comparison AT&T and Verizon which have broader revenue support than simple pay TV, were off by just 7% to 8% during the week and are already recovering.