Arxan Technologies called the other day because it was excited about DECE implementations, being a member of DECE, now renamed Ultra Violet, and because we’d written a piece saying Ultra Violet was ready for prime time.
Arxan is making a name for itself because in multi-screen video systems there is less and less potential for every device to have hardware help in protecting video assets, as conditional access systems always had. What is needed in order to support multiscreen delivery is a way of making a downloadable piece of software, such as a DRM or a DTCP-IP software client, about as unbreakable as conditional access has been for the past 20 years or so.
Unbreakable is not the right word, really what we are after is a series of protections that make it unprofitable to bother to break, either because it is only partially broken, or because the finger will be pointed immediately at the pirate or because the system will have its keys revoked, stop working and put the pirate to a lot more trouble in terms of accessing commercial content with the screen ‘ presumably a tablet computer or a PC. We want to limit piracy on software downloaded systems, to the real pirates, and even then give them some serious speed bumps.
The best known system for doing this is perhaps CloakWare which has re-emerged since the company’s purchase by conditional access firm Irdeto, under the name ActiveCloak for media and we wrote about its plans a few weeks back.
Vince Arneja, Vice President Product Management at Arxan told us, ‘The research to protect software was undertaken at a US university, after a plane crashed in China and US authorities were worried that the Chinese were able to unscramble the software used on board the plane and extract intellectual Property.’ He’s a little more vague on how that University research ended up at Arxan, but the fact that Arxan is a city district in inner Mongolia, lends some weight to the story.
Arneja sees lots of opportunities for fortifying software in Ultra Violet, but also in TV Everywhere systems, as well as App Stores. At Faultline we think it’s obvious that the world wants more entrants making their way into the segment for software only protection systems, whether that’s downloadable DRM or the systems underneath that protect them.
Arxan joined Digital Entertainment Content Ecosystem (renamed Ultra Violet or UV) last November, and UV has opted for working with five separate DRMs, in the Open Mobile Alliance OMA2, Microsoft’s PlayReady, Widevine now owned by Google, Adobe’s DRM and Intertrust’s Marlin DRM.
The idea behind Ultra Violet we have made clear several times ‘ it is a rights locker which keeps track of what content rights you have on what devices, and ensures you can move a copy from device to device, even if what that actually means is getting another copy of a piece of content sent to another device, working under a different DRM which moves keys differently. A new version should have the same rights entitlements served from some central authority. DECE came out of the stranglehold that Apple was placing on content, by making it all Apple device specific. The idea was that everyone else would free content up from being on only one type of device by bringing in some form of interconnectivity.
What it amounts to is a set of seamless transfers from one device to another within a designated domain, like a family or a set of registered devices. Yes it requires DRM, but in order for it to be taken up widely by content businesses, underneath that DRM software it needs to be tamper resistant, which amounts to containing key protection among other things.
Arxan says that various customers targeting this space has asked it to pre-fortify their software prior to shipment, but can only point to its much publicized deal with Widevine and another integrating Arxan tools with Marlin the Intertrust DRM.
The Widevine deal dates back to April 2010 with Widevine licensing Arxan’s Applications Hardening and Key Protection solutions for its DRM platform, specifically targeting TV Everywhere services to playback premium Hollywood content on virtually any consumer device.
Widevine saw it as an essential step to re-assure MSOs, particularly cable operators in the US, that it would cut out lots of concern from commercial content holders and speed their time to market with TV Everywhere acceptance.
The Widevine platform uses what Arxan calls its GuardIT and TransformIT packages for viewing on PCs and Macs.
But there are clearly a lot of customers that are not yet ready to be talked about at Arxan. Arneja said, ‘We have customers using our suite of products to satisfy protection requirements of DTCP including protection of Elliptic Curve algorithms for authentication/key exchange. Unfortunately, we’re not allowed to provide the specifics of these customers, but the general use case is protection of a multi-media application against DRM key discovery etc.’
Arxan’s GuardIT has been around for about five years but was originally used, as the Chinese air crash story goes, to protect normal commercially sensitive software. What is different about it is that it obfuscates a binary of an EXE file rather than the source code of a interpreted file. This helps with the huge problems associated with obfuscating code and keeping keys and the code that executes then apart, since they need to be rapidly assembled to decode media in real time.
The Arxan architecture has other systems in play which use authentication from system unit to system unit, which prevents that EXE file being copied, tampered with or replaced ‘ it just wouldn’t produce the right authentication code if any of those things happened.
It works in much the same way when preventing a de-compiler or debugging tool from running and can either terminate the program, offer ‘traitor’ tracing or the erasure of keys or deliberately damage other parts of the programs, such as key routines, when it discovers tampering of any kind or it can report it to a central server over the internet or do all of the above. The idea is to protect the code that any given DRM is based on.
It even has an internal firewall inside the application and uses PKI keys, Hash checking, checksum and obfuscation mapping to make executable code incomprehensible to anyone, unless the system reverses the obfuscation, which it does at run time.
Basically the customer here is the DRM supplier and that makes it clear the business model that Arxan is using, using DRM player as distributors effectively. The DRM owner can define which way the system should respond to threats ‘ the Arxan tools just allow it to choose.
In addition to protecting the DRM, an MSO client of the DRM company may have a unique set of algorithms that it wants protected as well, in a TV Everywhere system and it might just as easily want to protect streams as protect a file (as in the DTCP-IP use case).
‘There is no reason that we couldn’t underpin a DRM which is protecting an adaptive stream,’ Arneja said. ‘There is also an emerging market with Apps on both iOS and Android Market and our code makes it hard to rip off those Apps.
‘We have done integration with media players and also with software updates.
And our tools are already deployed on iOS Apps and App upgrades which are already in production ‘ mostly because the App security provided by Apple is precisely that, for Apple.’
All this means that right now Arxan is charging mostly one off implementation fees plus annual flat rate add-ons. If it tried to live off per device deals right now it would starve, but later that might come into the equation.
It is a hot area, but like so many hot areas, people don’t like to explain how the technology works too precisely in case their methods are copied. This area, is, of course, yet another grudge purchase, like the DRM itself, so it relies on millions and millions of devices paying pennies for this kind of protection, and there are only room for a few specialists in the area. Right now there are these two, Irdeto and Arxan, but more will emerge over the coming months as systems roll out and in the end we can see legal challenges and an IPR war for the battle for the hearts and minds of the DRM companies.