We are not going to even try to compete with all the words of praise that will rightfully be aimed at Steve Jobs for the way he created Apple and then rejoined the company to take it to dramatic new heights as the world’s most valuable technology business.
It goes without saying that, along with everyone else, that we have the utmost regard for what Jobs has done in terms of taking the technology industry forward. To us his key contribution has been to be fearless and to never worry about what everyone else is doing, but instead he plowed his own furrow, made his own calculations about what the public would like and could never be turned away from his mission to create or find the ‘next big thing.’
But leaving the praise there, at a scant two paragraphs, his resignation this week raises a number of issues, even though he will continue as Chairman and, health permitting, and will be looking over the shoulder of the new CEO Tim Cook.
Those issues are very simple to raise, but tougher to address. Will Apple be the same company without him? Will it be quite so bold and innovative as it was with him at the helm? And even if it is, will investors believe in the company in quite the same way?
The second answer should only be answered over time, by the answer to the first, but we are sure that shortly after us completing this article the US stock markets will take down the share price of Apple, as an instant gut reaction, before giving Cook the chance to show what kind of man he really is once his mentor has taken a back seat. In grey market pre-trading the stock was already down 10%. It will be tough on Cook. How can he introduce a new product with Jobs as his chairman? What if Jobs disagrees with him over something? Of course he will defer to Jobs, even though Jobs will no longer have day to day hands-on feedback.
In a strange way Jobs has done the easier thing. He has created new form factors for handsets, for PCs, for laptops and in the iPad, an entirely new device category. When you do that, and do it well, it’s very hard for the pack to follow you, and if they do, you can keep them at bay with rhetoric and legal actions and minor updates, for quite some time. But once rivals begin to offer products that Apple itself would have been proud of, and the current crop of HTC and Samsung devices fall into this category, a different type of focus is required at the company. Sometimes the instincts that Jobs has had over the years will have been wrong for the coming years. Will Cook have the strength of character and will to push Apple new ways and new directions once that becomes necessary. He can try to emulate Jobs, by always innovating his way out of trouble, or he can shift to a more evolutionary approach to product design, as most other companies do. And as for being fearless, that is easier to do with a company you feel you ‘own’ because you built it, and harder when you are looking after it for investors, with the founder peeping over your shoulder.
And again, as if to underline that, even if Cook does have such reserves of character, will investors see any step he takes not as prudent management, but instead as ‘un-Jobs like.’ In the past when icons have moved aside and the replacement has been the right man, investors have made their life hell, and pushed the new man aside and replaced them with a completely wrong type of character. This is almost bound to happen here, as investors have gained from Apple, but rarely understood it.
You may want to draw parallels with Microsoft, which is a shadow of its former self under Steve Ballmer, as it was under Bill Gates, and yet he has all the same advisers in place. If you have been in technology a while you will remember the dramatic changes in direction at IBM once Lou Gerstner took over, divesting the company of any vestige of vision, and imbuing it entirely with pragmatism. It may have been the saving of the company, but it was certainly a major break with its past. We fear that Cook will not be allowed to manage with impunity, that he will be given too short a time to prove himself and that an interregnum will follow that could be potentially disastrous for the company. Employees love Jobs, will they remain loyal even if Apple just appears to stumble?
The entire venture capital world will come knocking at the Apple door, saying to senior people ‘Steve has gone, party’s over, do you want to run your own show,’ offering them start-ups, which they hope will have some of the Jobs’ fairy dust.
We already have an example of what happened before at Apple when Steve Jobs originally left to create NextStep, at the time thought to be too entrepreneurial to lead the size of company that Apple had become. The Board had brought in John Sculley, fresh from his ‘win’ of the cola wars (where the battle between Pepsi and Coca Cola continues to this day). Sculley’s job was to bring pragmatism, heightened marketing and to put a leash on Jobs. The board at the time felt the need to bring in a ‘bigger’ celebrity than the one they had. It would be impossible to bring in someone with a better pedigree than Jobs has today and that route was disastrous anyway. But it may not stop desperate investors trying. Only the fact that Jobs has taken up the mantle of Chairmanship will prevent something similar happening today at Apple. But for how long?
In Faultline’s first issue in early 2003, Apple had a market capitalization of $9.8 billion and we could see the beginnings of the shift to consumer electronics at Apple, and said that somewhere should buy it quick while it was still affordable, or it would grow to overtake everyone. That all came to pass and more and even after taking off yesterday’s 10% it has a value of $348 billion.
Sadly, it seems that Jobs’ multiple health problems, which are shrouded in secrecy at Apple, have finally defeated him. He is reported to be mainly housebound, though he attended a board meeting on his final day at work, and in his farewell statement he said: “I have always said if there ever came a day when I could no longer meet my duties and expectations as Apple’s CEO, I would be the first to let you know. Unfortunately, that day has come.’
We wish Steve Jobs well, and hope he has a long and happy retirement, and he has time to enjoy the fruits of his past labors. We fear however that it may not quite be that straightforward.