Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 September 2011

Dish ready to batter Netflix if it can land Hulu and a Starz deal

When we heard Dish Chairman Charlie Ergen say in a results briefing that Netflix is probably too far ahead to be caught, we sensed it was little more than flak, to keep us all from the truth, which is that he is angry that Dish never got there first and that he desperately wants to take on Netflix.

That was some months ago and he has continued putting his ‘ducks in a row’ and will likely come out with a clear strategy shortly, but whatever that is, it has now become clear that the purchase of Blockbuster, as we always said it should, was part of bringing the guns around to face Netflix.

While we continue to believe that Netflix will be a tough act to follow, and that the broadening of its revenue base to Latin America and Europe will make it almost impossible to extinguish. It’s funny how Blockbuster, under its own steam, was unable to put up much of a fight, but as soon as new management came on board, with a little investment cash, the rules have all changed, and now the Netflix share price is sliding on major concerns.

One of the biggest concerns is that on the day that the Netflix price increases finally came into force for existing customer (September 1) its most important supplier Starz, which has rights to remarket Sony and Disney films, announced boldly that it is ending negotiations with Netflix over renewing these rights once they expire next February, 6 months away.

This is the world of TV, movies and showbiz, where we all know that brinkmanship is the name of the game ‘ such as when Dish negotiates right, for instance, to the Fox sports channels and leaves it to the last possible day to announced a new deal ‘ and that the longer Netflix is in this business, the better it will be at anticipating the destructive public statements made in the name of ‘negotiation.’ Starz will do a deal with Netflix, but right now they are playing the game of ‘Who cares?’ and seeing who can convince their public that either Netflix is fine to continue without these films or that Starz is happy to continue with a hole in its revenue.

One thing that makes us confident that Starz, a Liberty Media company, will end up with a major online delivery deal, is because on the one hand, Sony has squeezed and Disney will squeeze a lot more money out of Starz. Its contract problem with Sony was over having an upper limit for online movie delivery, and therefore resorting to a re-negotiation. Netflix made that happen a lot faster than anyone ever anticipated. If Disney didn’t have such a clause with Starz, you can bet that it will introduce one, and that, in turn, will mean that Starz will need the extra revenue from a substantial online source.

Could that be Blockbuster? Not right now, the only game in town here is Netflix, which can bring those kind of numbers to the Starz deal up front.

Netflix meanwhile has been signing as much content exclusively as it can, in the hope that a) it has more cards in its hand in this critical negotiation with Starz and b) in case it has to accept non-exclusive access to the Starz movie service online. A non-exclusive deal would mean that someone like Blockbuster could pick up the same content, and would be more amenable to signing a deal based on the numbers of people that sign for a subscription, something Netflix is known to be avoiding.

The body of investor opinion is that Starz holds all the cards, and that has been eating away at the Netflix share price of late. We don’t see it that way. If Starz is used to the higher level of revenue, it will be exceptionally unhappy to sign more expensive new deals with Sony and Disney and then not be able to capitalize on them. Also Starz tried running its own online service back in 2006 and no-one subscribed, so that’s not an option.

Into this melting pot comes the news that Dish is launching its own online service ‘ we know that just like Netflix before it, it already has such a service, but only if you are already a customer of its online DVD rental program, so taking the next step, to an online only deal makes sense, but it especially makes sense if Dish can also announce a deal with someone like Starz. That may not be quite so easy, given that Dish and Starz have a history of suing one another and we think are mid-suite right now over Dish giving away Starz channels to too many customers.

All of which makes it no surprise at all that this week Dish threw its hat into the ring to purchase Hulu, with that deal having previously only been associated with
Yahoo, Google, DirecTV and Amazon.

We ran an editorial a few weeks back pointing to the reasons why most of these would not buy Hulu, and DirecTV and Google have duly dropped out. But suddenly into the mix comes Dish, alongside Yahoo and Amazon.

We’re not sure why anyone would make Amazon the favorite here ‘ but they are. Dish has won everything it has bid for lately and although you might think it needs to preserve its cash for building a US wide LTE network, it is still used to winning and it is clearly one of the top three bidders so far. Meanwhile the asking price for Hulu is supposed to be on track to raise the $2 billion that it is after.

All of which takes us back to the chagrin with which Ergen talked about Netflix being out of sight, too far ahead to be caught. A Hulu service mostly driven by advertising and some subscriptions, but entirely driven by TV content, would sit nicely next to a Starz movie service, and all the better if it had a retail footprint and a brand name, like Blockbuster, at a price which undercuts Netflix. That would make more than just investors think twice about backing Netflix, it would drag with it a host of discontented Netflix customers with it and put a smile back on Ergen’s face.

However Netflix knows all of this and is almost certainly waiting until it has an indication of how many customers will stay loyal, before re-signing with Starz, either exclusive or non-exclusive. Sure it may have to pay 10 times as much as the $30 million a year it used to pay, but then again, what did it raise its prices for if it wasn’t to up its margins to pay for deals like this.

Meanwhile the Netflix content negotiations overseas in Latin America and Europe, will also be unearthing new content it can bring back to the US, and the rate of sales take up in those territories is also just as important to Netflix as the number of customers who stick with it after its price increase. So we don’t think much of this will be clarified until Netflix knows where it stands in terms of domestic and overseas customers, otherwise it risks cutting a deal at one level and operating at another. Christmas 2011 is the earliest Netflix will offer public numbers on its current growth rate, but already CEO Reed Hastings will be aware of how US cancellations are going. But he will be playing those particular cards close to his chest. But in the end he is now running a global business, and what happens purely in the US may soon hold less interest for him.