Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 September 2011

MoCA’s certification rate accelerates to 100 devices

MoCA (Multimedia over Coax Alliance) has now certified more than 100 MoCA products, 45% of them since the start of 2010. ‘We expect this certification rate to continue to increase as we expand into new geographic markets and into the home installer/retail segments,’ said Charles Cerino, MoCA president and an executive at Comcast. He’s no doubt referring to the acceptance of MoCA by European cablecos like Liberty Global.

MoCA has fewer product certifications than HomePlug but its products have not been aimed at the consumer market. MoCA says about 85% of the 100 or so MoCA certified products are used by pay TV operators. The remaining 15% are available at retail and used by installers. MoCA backers hope to raise consumer awareness of MoCA and increase sales at retail and through the growing cadre of installers.

HomePlug currently has the edge in the retail market sales wise, although that could change if and when more consumer-friendly MoCA products come to market. Every home has power lines but some of them don’t have coax, especially outside the US. However, there is more coax in Europe than many realize especially in multiple dwelling units (MDUs) and homes with multiple TV sets.
MoCA dominates the whole home DVR market. We don’t know of any that come with powerline networking in the US. What is driving MOCA in the pay TV industry is the recent popularity of whole home DVRs that are connected to multiple TV sets in a home.

The only exception is AT&T and some smaller telcos in North America and Asia who are using the HPNA networking which Sigma Designs’ CopperGate developed.

MoCA backers also see opportunity in Europe. Liberty Global, the largest cableco outside the States, has standardized on MoCA capable DVRs. The UK’s Virgin Media has not picked a home network scheme but is said to be evaluating MoCA and may start deploying TiVo boxes with MoCA by year-end. The recent increase in popularity in Europe for MoCA is due to its use as an in-home backbone extending Wi-Fi, or as high speed Internet access. The spread of tablets and smartphones has increased the need for every room in the home to be in a Wi-Fi hotspot.

Stephen Palm, senior technical director at Broadcom, chair of the MoCA Certification Board and a driver of the P1905 standard, said, ‘MoCA’s rigorous Interoperability Certification program is designed to exceed the service provider’s expectations for robust video networking, enabling them to choose from a broad portfolio of products for worldwide deployments.’

Two clouds have appeared on MoCA’s horizon. One is the ‘every wire in the home’ technology called G.hn or HomeGrid, which is intended to run on powerline, coax and telephone wires. A few G.hn products are expected in the first quarter of 2012 and volume shipments by summer of 2012. Initial indications are that the G.hn gang is aiming at the powerline market in Asia. They say HomeGrid works better than other powerline technologies in MDUs (multiple dwelling units) which are prevalent in Asia.

Some G.hn backers have told us that pay TV services in Asia don’t think HomePlug will meet their needs in MDUs. They have been considering running Ethernet or coax but are now evaluating G.hn’s use over power lines.

The other potential threat to all the wireline technologies is an enhanced version of Wi-Fi. Celeno, Quantenna and other companies like Broadcom have developed Wi-Fi chips with multiple antennas (MIMO) which they say can compete against wireline networking in video quality and content security. Turkey’s Airties, Netgear and Google’s Motorola Mobility have developed or are working on STBs and other equipment with the multiple antenna Wi-Fi chipsets.

We live in interesting times in the home networking industry. Smart TVs and other smart devices like tablets and Blu-ray players, both wireline and wireless, are rapidly increasing the size of the market. There are about 300 million or more homes in North America, Europe and Asia that have or are candidates for home networking that can handle HD and higher video quality.