Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 September 2011

Apple now get Samsung to pull the 7.7 inch version of Galaxy Tab

Samsung will stop promoting the Galaxy Tab 7.7 tablet in Germany, due to another injunction won by Apple in a Dusseldorf court. A few weeks ago it manged to get the Galaxy 10.1 inch tablet banned in Germany. Both decisions are subject to review once the court makes a final ruling on Apple’s claims that the Tabs infringe its design patents.

Samsung was forced to drop the new Galaxy 7.7 from high profile promotions at the IFA consumer electronics trade show in Berlin. The new 7.7 and a 5-inch tablet/smartphone hybrid were seen as a way to hedge Samsung’s bets, should the 10.1 lose the next round of court battles, this month. Apple’s case revolves around the shape and appearance of the Tab, and since the iPad maker does not offer a smaller sized tablet, it was thought that the 7.7 inch model might be safe. But not so.

Samsung, while saying it “respects the court “, also added that the decision “severely limits consumer choice in Germany”. It pledged to pursue all available options, including legal action, to defend its intellectual property rights.

The initial German injunction briefly applied to the whole EU, but a subsequent court decision ruled that the Dusseldorf judge did not have the power to rule against a non-EU firm across the whole region. However, a recent Dutch injunction, this one against Galaxy S II smartphones, does have Europe-wide implications as the action was brought against Samsung Netherlands. If Apple succeeds in stopping holiday season sales of the Tabs across the whole EU, even if it has to engage in country-by-country actions, Samsung stands to lose sales of at least 500,000 units, estimates Strategy Analytics. Apple also has injunction cases pending at the US International Trade Commission.

Apple originally charged its former friend in the US in April, accusing it of “slavishly” copying its products. Samsung, which holds the second largest number of patents in the US, countersued in Seoul, Tokyo, Germany and California.