Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 September 2011

US falls do not mean the dream is over at Netflix

Netflix has put out a small guidance note that has its investor audience queuing to sell its shares right now, with the simplest interpretation being that it is no longer a growing player and that in the US it will lose 1 million subscribers this quarter. This isn’t really the right way to think about this.

The diagrams below show what Netflix thought its customer mix would be with its new deals and pricing, and what it now thinks they are going to be having seen the number of people that have actually cancelled on September 1st rather than pay their first month at the new rates. (Diagrams only in pdf version)

At first glance this stops Netflix becoming a growth story, and is a good reason for the idea that 1 million customers are lost. What we need to see is that Netflix has previously had 24.5 million domestic US users. It said it would reach 25 million but has actually fallen on this one time pricing event to 24 million. So half a million customers have been lost in the quarter. Revenue tells a different story.

The revenue Netflix produced for last quarter, around $788 million, with probably all but $8 million coming from Domestic, which breaks down very roughly to being 18.8 million people that got free online and paid for DVD rental at around $11.40 a head average, with the rest of its customers paying online only at around $8 a head.

What that would have generated if the Netflix forecast had been right, given the new pricing, was new quarterly revenues of something like $888 million of domestic revenue instead of $780 million, and a further $16 million internationally, mostly from Canada, as it doubles its online only offering there.

Instead that is more likely to be around $864 million plus the $16 million overseas, a total of $880 million, and a rise of 11% to 12% in a single quarter. It will then have a lot of costs of set up for Latin America and in subsequent quarters begin to see that having a positive effect on its revenues. Given that Netflix only grew 9.7% last quarter, if this happens, it makes Netflix an accelerating stock, not one that is slowing down.

Latin American revenues will begin to hit fully in the fourth quarter and two quarters later European revenues will cut in, while Domestic revenues may suffer a quarter or two of further disruption as people belatedly drop out of the DVD rental side of the business, and then that too should go back into solid growth.

All of which will make the investors who took 14% off the company’s share price during the past day or so feel rather embarrassed we expect.