It is intriguing so see Broadcom and Qualcomm Atheros lay out their respective strategies at Broadband World Forum ‘ Broadcom has always lorded it over Atheros, as a bigger bully on the WiFi block, while Atheros was bold and nimble, and both are moving into new worlds. Atheros finally has an even bigger bully on its side in the form of Qualcomm and the two chip companies are using a combination of WiFi, set tops, DSL and all forms of SoC ‘ which take in multiple other worlds such as Bluetooth, to position themselves as broadband market leaders.
We will have to talk more deeply to both these companies multiple times going forward and see how this dustup pans out, but it promises to be a very even match. It is likely that both will eat up yet more start up specialists in the process. Both had announcements this week based on HomePlug AV, and Broadcom tried to steal the high ground in DSL markets with its G-Vector central office announcements (See separate story), which push up VDSL to 100 Mbps and beyond.
Qualcomm Atheros announced a new AR7420 chipset, ready for fourth quarter 2011 which it says is a transceiver IC chip which is the smallest, highest performing and lowest power HomePlug AV-based chip in the market, which also adheres to the IEEE 1901 standard, which is best seen as a superset of HomePlug AV since it addresses broader spectrum above 30 MHz, in this chip’s case all the way to 68 MHz. This particular version of the chip is optimized for embedded devices and small form-factor standalone adapters. It has a 500 Mbps PHY because of that extra spectrum that Atheros has already explained to us it believes is acceptable in both the HomePlug and 1901 standards, though there is some disagreement about that, with some people saying P1901 goes up to 50 MHz now and has a charter to shift to 100 MHz. Regardless it won’t be able to use all of that bandwidth to connect to legacy HomePlug devices which all sit, for fairly good reasons below 30 MHz. This is Atheros doing what Broadcom does really, coming out with a high volume and very likely low priced version of the technology, though it doesn’t give out pricing. This is another member of the 7400 family that seemed to be targeted at getting closer to G.hn performance on powerline, in order to marginalize it.
Broadcom has yet to come out with a G.hn chip and we might have expected this at the show, from its Gigle acquisition, but its HomePlug presence is from that company as well, and its first move has been to shift it to 40 nm which it says is a first with the BCM60321 Powerline Networking SoC. This is pure HomePlug AV 1.1 certified and it says IEEE 1901 compliant, which implies that it operates up to 30 Mhz only and therefore uses a 200 Mbps PHY.
This seems to be outlawing Atheros somewhat. Sigma, one of the early players in G.hn silicon, which targets three types of wires ‘ coax, twisted pair and powerline ‘ all at very different performance levels, has bet both sides of the house, with G.hn silicon, adding MIMO to the mix, as well as offering HomePlug silicon. This looks like Gigle will take Broadcom down the same route ‘ sitting on the fence route.
Marvell (see separate story) and Atheros sit either side of the fence ‘ Atheros does no G.hn product, owning as it does Intellon, the chip company which pioneered HomePlug, while Marvell has no presence in HomePlug, only in G.hn because it bought DS2, a company that helped specify G.hn and pioneered UPA powerline.
Broadcom says that its entire PLC modem design sits in 51mm by 38mm and uses
less than 2.5 Watts of power when on and provides repeating, channel bonding, failover and load balancing for layer-2 in multi-mode home networks, and, as is common these days features full remote management, which we assumes is TR-069 compliant.
Other new announcements from the two this week include Qualcomm Atheros entering the market with a video over wireless bridge, in partnership with Edimax. This uses the new AR9580 chip, which is the Atheros answer to Quantenna and Celeno specialist video chips. A WiFi bridge is ideal as a starting point and Turkish specialist AirTies did something similar, as it can connect the home router usually to a SmarTV using WiFi instead of Ethernet.
Qualcomm Atheros says that the AR9580 virtually eliminate packet loss, and as we understand it this is a 3 x 3 MIMO chip, not too dissimilar to the Celeno video WiFi chip, except it has less antennas and therefore can form less beams
Finally Broadcom has what it is calling a triple play SoC the BCM63168 which offers G.Vector DSL WiFi, Gigabit Ethernet Switching, DECT, VoIP, packet and Quality of Service acceleration, which it says will enable carriers to meet the growing demand for triple play services.