Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 September 2011

Nagravision insists it’s had cloud search for years, offers soft DRM

Say NDS and people reply Nagravision, and vice versa, so when it transpired that for the Horizon project at UPC and for other projects, NDS had deserted the principles of a lifetime and embraced software only video protection, it was only a matter of time before Nagra would be admitting to the same thing.

The Nagravision presentation at IBC showed that the company is already there and has been there for some time. Not only is it very quietly accepting than in an iPad dominated world that it must have software only protection, it has also broadened its software strategy, taking in cloud search and recommendation systems and end to end TV middleware, in much the same way as NDS has in its contract with UPC in Europe.

Matthew Huntington, Nagra’s VP of product marketing said to us, ‘What we saw at IBC was NDS virtually taking our slide pack from six months ago and copying it. We were there way before NDS, and have installed and operated this kind of system at Canal+ in France, Mediaset in Italy and Digital+ in Spain.’

But he didn’t emphasize the switch to software only DRM systems. ‘We’ve operated outside the traditional conditional access sphere for a good many years. We bought OpenTV which gave us Middleware and since we completed the acquisition of the rest of Open TV we have been re-architecting its software. We went into digital asset management with our Lysis acquisition,’ (that was 10 years ago).

At the show Nagra was mostly pushing the deal with Gracenote where it has integrated its eyeQ system in to its Federated Head End. Gracenote seems to be a resting place for the Philips fingerprint technologies ‘ both music and video ‘ which it has used to build into huge content recognition databases. The eyeQ system now uses this technology to search metadata on linear TV channels, VoD content, and can make recommendations based on moods and on past viewing behavior. Gracenote is now owned by Sony and it is one of a number of partners that Nagra has opted to work with for recommendations.

But on the thorny question of software based DRM, Huntington said, ‘There are two version of our Persistent Rights Manager (PRM) one which works with a card or card-less hardware security system and another that works with White box cryptography and obfuscation to harden software environments.’

‘We try to use our NOC (Nagra on a Chip) and embed it on a chipset, and use that as the basis of our PRM on multiscreen devices. We have versions on about 6 chipsets, including Renesas, Sigma, Trident and M-Star,’ (and on the Broadcom HD set top chips, a deal which was announced at the show). PRM has been around for about 2 years and has been installed on 6 million devices, but mostly with this NOC hardware protection.

‘In Multiscreen, we try to have Nagra on every device. For pay TV we have one or more gateway devices which descramble it and distribute it through the home, but some devices we just cannot get the NOC on so we will support other approaches such as using the DLNA’s DTCP-IP protected streaming.’

DTCP-IP is a protected streaming protocol approved by the DLNA for termination of a service on both fixed and portable devices. The problem is that on a generalized device with an operating system, anyone can install a reverse compiler or a debugger and use it to get underneath this on the device and steal its keys. This is why the white box cryptography, as Huntington calls it, is required. The three core techniques involve checking that a piece of software which resembles a debugger is not running before decrypting a key, obfuscating both object and source code so that it doesn’t make any sense to someone trying to understand the system and using constant authentications every time a system unit talks to another unit, so that only authorized transactions can execute.

One cryptographic experts said to us at the show, ‘If a chip based cryptographic processing region is a 10, then software hardening is a 2 or perhaps a 3,’ suggesting that eventually for HD commercial video services to genuinely go multiscreen, that the ARM based processors manufacturers who are driving tablets and handsets, will have to includes something like Nagra’s NOC, or better still the more open CryptoFirewall that we have discussed from Cryptographic Research Inc.

Our own belief is that within 2 years these software only devices will become a source of both embarrassment and constant R&D for the DRM vendors, so that replacing it with a hardware assists is already on the agenda. It is only the fact that Apple does very little to help security vendors on its A4 iPad chip, which has led to software only fortification getting its day in the sun.

‘People recognize that there is a difference between the quality of security that you get with hardware and software only protection,’ admitted Huntington, ‘and software only has to rely heavily on renewability and be operated within an overall secure service offering, where you can react swiftly to compromises, but tablets right now are not the big problem, since the bulk of video which is not hardware protected is being watched on a PC.’

He may be right for now, but given the plans of numerous pay TV operators around the world, that will rapidly change in favor of tablets over the coming 12 months, we feel.

On the Nagra slide pack there was one system built around a Zinwell set top, which Huntington said was a ‘future’ project and that he could not talk about it, only to say that it was a pure OTT project, with no hybrid, coming out in Europe this year. We’ll keep our ears pinned for that one.