What’s $2 billion between friends? Or enemies for that matter. Google is clearly trying to think outside the box-square-triangle on the subject of Hulu and according to insiders, in particular those reported on the Business Insider web site, has gone back to the owners of Hulu and asked for more content rights in return for more money. The price difference is over $2 billion more than the current best bid offer for Hulu, of $1.9 billion reportedly made by Dish Networks.
That technically means that no-one ‘ not Amazon, Google, Dish or Yahoo ‘ came up with a price over $2 billion for Hulu ‘ the price that owners Fox (News Corp) , Disney and NBC (Comcast) thought would be the absolute starting point for the auction.
The truth is that Hulu itself is not worth it. It’s on track for revenues of $500 million this year if current CEO Jason Kilar can be believed, with much of that advertising driven and something below an $80 million run rate for Hulu Plus, in the $8 a month subscription service which is in its first year. Kilar insists that it is profitable, which, depending on just how profitable, probably puts it on a value of 1 times revenue. Naturally the studios see it as worth 4 times that as an absolute minimum, but any financial adviser confirming that to them, is just sucking up to them.
This is what’s behind the Google gamble ‘ we think the bids will be too low for you to sell, so let’s get in first with an offer for a Hulu with far better movie resale terms.
The Business Insider gave some nonsense about Dish needing to buy the technology as much as the film rights, which is why its bid was the highest. Quite clearly the Business Insider hasn’t run a DTH operator or augmented a placeshifting technology like that provided by Sling Media with cloud streaming, as Dish has. This type of technology now can be taken off the shelf using totally standardized equipment and software, with any one start up ready to offer it for next to nothing to land a reference site like Dish. It also neglects the fact that Dish owns Blockbuster that already has movie rights and movie streaming, run for it by Rovi subsidiary Sonic Solutions. Dish also owns Move Networks which also invented adaptive streaming. It needs more technology like a hole in the head.
Like anyone about to buy Hulu, Dish has its own assets to leverage, and the Blockbuster brand, along with the new Blockbuster Movie Pass service, which is supposed to compete with Netflix and which by the way, uses technology similar to Hulu.
Dish will offer almost 14 million homes a free year on Blockbuster Movie Pass and thereafter charge $10 a month. It offers movies as well as games rentals, and it is about streamed movies, but right now most of these movies have to be consumed on the PC, because there are far less ways to get the service from the internet to the TV than there are for Netflix. Blockbuster streamed services can be viewed on TV with any of the existing set tops which are already internet enabled, which CEO Joe Clayton insists is in the millions, but we’re not quite so sure it’s that high.
But in a very generous move it has also offered its Mail It! Service ‘ online DVD rental just like the original Netflix business, as part and parcel of the package with up to three disks at a time. The Stream It! Version has just 3,000 movies.
This is a noble start, but the comparison is odious ‘ Netflix at $8 a month compared to $10 and the choice of 3,000 movies, not 30,000 and rising. This will only cut it as a free offering and Blockbuster needs to land some new content ‘ such as the rights of Hulu, in order to fill this offering out and be genuinely competitive.
The other part of the offering not reflected by Netflix is the Watch it! option, with 20 premium movie channels from studios like MGM, Epix, Sony Movie Channel, and PixL, but that’s just mixing and matching viewing options with an existing Pay TV service.
What’s really going on here is a form of TV Everywhere ‘ with Dish giving the services away for free for a year in return for a two year commitment to one of its more expensive pay TV services and free for three months when given away with one of its less appealing options.
This now means that the studios have to go back to the drawing board and consider three options ‘ continuing to run Hulu, which some executives from the owners have said is not going to be considered; sell it to Blockbuster at the price offered, or take Google’s hint and offer longer, more penetrating TV and Movie rights to Hulu and invite bids once again. Of course it cannot offer one set of terms then accept the Google deal, which suggests different terms which were never on the table for the other bidders.
Google is being clever. It is saying, ‘The sky’s the limit’ if you work with us on improving these terms ‘ which is something it needs in order to change the world’s attitude to its attempts to turn YouTube into content that can be viewed on a TV ‘ with Lean Back and licensed studios options. But we think Blockbuster is being even cleverer, saying ‘If we bid over your expected minimum the bidding may have gone higher, but by sliding in as the highest bidder below that level, you may decide to offer it to us anyway.’
Of the three options it makes the most sense to go exclusive with Dish, and haggle a few $100 million more out of them, and be rid of the adventure, which was ill-conceived anyway.
Keeping it leads to internal arguments on how to proceed, but also potentially it undermines other online offerings from its customers. Selling it to Google may give it a definitive head start that allows it to overtake Facebook’s new video offerings and Amazon’s and makes a new and dangerous King of the Hill. The middle way is probably right, and Dish may land this one.