Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 November 2011

UltraViolet Digital Locker stutters into life

After three years in the making, the commercial launch of the UltraViolet digital locker last month might have been expected to go more smoothly. In the event we have been left asking whether the well-publicized difficulties early users have experienced will undermine the whole venture, or are merely teething troubles. For the big players that have declined to join the Digital Entertainment Content Ecosystem (DECE)’s Ultraviolet initiative and run their own digital locker system, in particular Walt Disney, US Telco Verizon, and Amazon, the problems have confirmed the wisdom of their decision for now. Apple is also outside, as always plowing its own furrow, with Apple TV, and will take particular pleasure from UltraViolet’s poor start.

The absence of these players itself undermines the major advantage of UltraViolet for consumers, which is that it should end the situation where online video services all have their separate ecosystem with different formats, players, and usage models. For example a movie purchased from Apple’s iTunes will not play on an Xbox, and a TV show purchased from Best Buy Cinema Now will not work on a Walmart VUDU player.

The big idea of UltraViolet is certainly to move ever closer to the “buy anywhere, play anywhere” model originally provided by physical DVDs that can be moved between devices. It represents an attempt by the movie studios (except Disney) to recreate the value of the DVD in digital form, with the focus on promoting an Electronic Sell Through business model, even though rental will be supported as well later. It is also intended to combat piracy and reduce the amount of movie ripping via peer to peer file sharing protocols such as BitTorrent.

UltraViolet has in fact garnered great support, with members of the DECE consortium including all major CE (Consumer Electronics) vendors, leading technology vendors like Cisco, the major studios except Disney, and many leading pay TV providers including Comcast and Cox Communications, as well as video retailers or distributors such as Blockbuster, Netflix and LoveFilm. There was also an interesting and significant addition just before the launch last month, when hotel pay-per-view programming distributor LodgeNet Interactive joined DECE. This will clear the way for subscribers who buy movies via VoD services from their pay TV operator to view them through TVs in hotels across the US. It could also allow hotel guests to purchase a movie in their room, and then view it at home, in other hotels, or via OTT (Over The Top) services.

The first phase of UltraViolet deployment began October 11 in the US only, with the second phase to follow in the first half of 2012, including European availability, starting probably with the UK.

As part of the first phase, three Hollywood studios announced titles with an UltraViolet option. Warner Bros is selling DVD and Blu-ray discs with UltraViolet rights for the adult comedy Horrible Bosses and superhero movie The Green Lantern. Sony will follow in early December with comedy Friends with Benefits and family film The Smurfs, with Universal Pictures also joining in with an UltraViolet (UV) option for sci-fi Western Cowboys & Aliens in time for Christmas. The other major two DECE members Paramount and 20th Century Fox have yet to announce films enabled for UV.

The move prompted Disney to announce that its films will start coming with Disney Studio All Access rights in the next few months. Amazon has its Instant Video (formerly Amazon Video On Demand) offering films for rental and purchase, but only in the US at present, while its LoveFilm subsidiary offers video streaming in the UK, Germany and Scandinavia. In the US Verizon allows its FiOS TV subscribers to buy movies and view then on TVs, mobile devices and via the web through its “Flex View” system.

Disney’s is the most serious absence from DECE as a major studio because it deprives the UltraViolet ecosystem of a significant source of premium content, undermining the idea of a universal digital locker. Its decision may have had something to do with the fact that Steve Jobs was on the board and its largest shareholder. But Disney also expressed concerns over the concept of a universal digital ecosystem, recalling perhaps the fate of a similar initiative tried in the music industry a decade ago. This was the Secure Digital Music Initiative (SDMI), formed in 1998 with support from over 200 technology, consumer and recording companies. But it faded away in 2001, largely because of the logistical and political difficulties associated with having to reach agreement among so many parties. Ultraviolet is bedeviled with the same issues. So Disney has argued instead that different rights holders should be able to deploy their own locker mechanisms, because it is still possible for consumers to access all the content they have bought on all their own devices.

DECE contends that this will actually prove harder to achieve in practice without a single digital locker, because device makers would have to support different formats. Indeed one of the key components of UltraViolet is its Common File Format (CFF). This was derived from existing standards already defined by MPEG, SMPTE (Society of Motion Picture & Television Engineers), and in particular Microsoft’s Protected Interoperable File Format (PIFF) specification. The aim was to avoid having different file formats for each player, and so make it possible to copy video files between players. CFF includes separate profiles for standard definition (SD) and HD, and is likely to succeed even if Ultraviolet as a whole does not, because key components of it are being adopted by MPEG in updates to its MPEG-4 container format, and as part of the MPEG Dynamic Adaptive Streaming over HTTP (DASH) format. As a result CFF is likely to be widely deployed as a universal file format anyway.

Apple’s omission from UltraViolet is also a handicap, given its status as the single most influential CE maker. But it is less serious than Disney’s omission, because UV content can, at least in principle, be played on Apple iOS devices, so long as an UltraViolet app is downloaded. Indeed Flixster Movies, released in October 2011 as the first UltraViolet-compatible app, can stream and download UV movies onto iPhones, iPads, and Macs, as well as Android devices, and Windows PCs. However Apple’s absence from DECE does mean that UltraViolet content will not show up in iTunes, even though it can play on Apple devices via a suitable app.

This failure to appear under iTunes though has been one of the early complaints from US UltraViolet users, and there have also been plenty of blogs expressing frustration over inability to download to iPads. There have also been some self- inflicted wounds, including technical glitches such as the system hanging when steaming is supposed to start, and problems streaming inside Firefox.

DECE could reasonably point out, and has done, that these glitches will be ironed out, as will the current lack of available content, but at this stage the problems have dented consumer confidence, although in some respects by having gained so little attention, especially outside the US, there is plenty of time to get things right with the phase two launch.

However there is also a question over the business model, over whether buy to purchase will catch on in the digital age, where the allure of owning a video product such as a movie in physical form with attractive graphics no longer exists. It is true that UltraViolet allows creation of a single copy either on DVDs or some other medium such as a USB stick. Similarly it will allow video to be purchased on DVD or Blu-Rays discs and then brought into the UltraViolet ecosystem for playback on other devices in the absence of the physical medium.

This still begs the key question for the immediate success of UV of whether consumers will warm to the Electronic Sell Through buy to own model, as this is the business model driving the whole enterprise at the moment. There are conflicting views here. Digital movie vendor Acetrax, which has its own UV-like digital locker system, has observed a swing from rental to purchase over the last year. In mid-2010 only about 20% of its business was purchase, reflecting the fact that movies cost on average 2.5 to 3 times more to buy then rent. But now it has moved to almost 50/50 because movies are now moving out of the VoD window quite quickly, often after three months, at which point they become unavailable to rent. This had the effect of increasing digital purchase because people were too lazy to drive down to their nearest DVD store where they could still rent the hard copy. The difference was often only a dollar or two anyway.

Acetrax admits though this is purely a reflection of the windowing rules and that rental would predominate again if retailers were able to have the content on this basis for longer. The availability of movies to rent at low cost through Netflix and other online services has in any case familiarized consumers with that model.

Now though the studios are moving en masse against rental, and here both Disney and Apple are aligned with UV, as rights holders seek to reverse a decline in the takings of their premium content over its lifetime. Electronic Sell Through is seen as a way of increasing lifetime content revenues.

This debate though over rental versus purchase may last only as long as consumers can actually have physical copies or at least remember having done so. In an all-digital age the distinction could cease to exist, and even the need for personal digital lockers may not endure forever. Alternative models could arise, such as payment of royalties that diminish over time for each viewing, varying according to the device.