Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 December 2011

OTT Video heaven to hit UK as Sky, Netflix and Amazon vie for control

All hell (or is it heaven for the consumer) is going to break lose in the UK in January in a fight for the Over The Top market, a fight that never really materialized in the US, because Netflix snuck up on everyone and stole a march with its online movie service.

And this story has lots of critical focal points involving local broadcasters, pay TV operators, ISP support, Microsoft and Apple, legal actions, not to mention the usual suspects of Netflix, Amazon and its European movie subsidiary LoveFiLM.

This battle will clear the way for dominance of Europe in OTT films, and potential access to not only a massive multi-million plus OTT movie service market, but all the spoils of such a market including advertising, Apps, and huge influence in the tablet and tablet applications market.

Had we been talking about his before the September price rise of Netflix in the US, we would have been seeing a convincing and global win for Netflix. Now it’s not quite so clear cut and many organizations, including News Corp and its BSkyB subsidiary, have too much at stake here.

The backdrop is a successful launch in OTT services by the free to air broadcasters, with tens of millions already watching services like the BBC iPlayer and Channel 4’s 4oD, etc’ But the pay TV market is now exploding with OTT intent.

The first blows were struck this with two events ‘ first the launch of both Netflix and Amazon’s LoveFiLM online movie services on the Xbox, and its 4 million or so UK customers. While Netflix actually announced Xbox Live service for its Latin American operation, this means that there are not technical issues, it has previously offered the Xbox platform early on in the US. So it should be able to launch it in the UK in relatively short order and it will have to, now LoveFiLM has it. The critical attraction to the Xbox is that using Kinect consumers have access to voice and gesture based remote controls for the TV.

There are another 10 million Xbox devices at least across the rest of Europe and BSkyB already offers its Sky Go services, complete with its exclusive movie hoard from Hollywood, on the Xbox and other games consoles. This is free to its pay TV customers.

Sky this week has also spoken out about the unfairness that regulators are placing on it in Europe in regard to movies, specifically referring to the findings of the UK Competition Commission inquiry, which said that it had found that Sky’s control over pay TV movie rights in the UK is restricting competition between pay TV providers. This it says is leading to higher prices and reduced choice and innovation for subscribers.

The suggested remedies will not be imposed until Q3 next year but those being considered include restricting the number of major studios from which Sky may license exclusive rights and by this is means first subscription pay TV window rights; restricting the nature of the exclusive deals so VoD systems could still offer them or forcing Sky to offer them on a wholesale basis, which could include offering its subscribers movie channels created with these movies on rival services.

This not only means that both Virgin and BT, its traditional pay TV rivals, will be allowed to offer Sky Movies as a TV channel wholesale, but that both would also be allowed to offer the same films VoD. It will also mean that both Netflix and Amazon should be able to offer the same movies online. Some of the money would go to Sky, but it would lose all the incentive to subscribe to high priced Sky pay TV.

Sky, like Comcast in the US, and both Vivendi and Orange in France and other pay TV operators elsewhere, has constantly added to its own content offering, as well as fighting tooth and claw to land key sports rights. When you add that to these movie exclusives it’s a compelling reason to buy the service and the reason Sky has around 40% of UK homes as customers, in a market where only 55% take pay TV.

Sky has gone on record this week saying that the Competition Commission has failed to consider the impact of competition from LoveFiLM and Netflix arguing that although these companies have traditionally not touched movies in the first subscription pay TV window in the UK until now, they have both done so in other countries and are bound to try it shortly. Poor Sky is in an invidious position, in that it has been able to boss around other pay TV players in the UK in the past, using Movies as one of its key plays, but suddenly it is faced with a complete shift to OTT viewing, as the same time as the regulator has finally got around to fixing the movie situation with respect to other pay TV players. Sky has also had to offer its Sky Sports channels to other players in the past, and although it has still made large subscribers gains since then, it is worried that it is losing its grip, or at least that it will do so in January when Netflix launches.

One place where Netflix could reverse all the damage to its reputation and set up a key peg in its UK launch is at Seachange International’s On Demand Group, which offers movies from Disney and Sony to VoD players in Europe. This is where second placed pay TV player Virgin gets its movie channels and VoD movies but this is not subject to any form of exclusive that we know of, so a Netflix deal may be straightforward. In the US movies move to a DVD and pay per view window on TV a month ahead of Netflix getting hold of movies, but the Sky exclusives cover both the pay per view window and this later DVD Window, so Sky will hope to keep both Netflix and Amazon starved of these rights.

Last week Sky made its scheduled and on demand movie services available via its Sky Go TV Anywhere service from iPhones, iPads and iPod touch devices as well as PCs and Macs, with Android coming soon. Existing Sky Movie subscribers get the service for free, while non-Sky customers can obtain it via a monthly subscription, and it is this OTT subscription that represents a direct attack on Netflix and LoveFiLM. Sky Go movies offers access to Sky’s 11 movie channels.

Sky’s arguments with the Competition Commission will fall on deaf ears we suspect, given that it has been seen to operate as a dominant force, and Netflix has yet to launch while LoveFiLM is yet to get any real penetration with just 1 million DVD rental homes in the UK, and no numbers as yet released for its online service. You can’t regulate a market based on rivals who have not much more than zero market share.

Sky said that its own research shows that under 10% of subscribers buy subscriptions because of the movies ‘ a fact it then conveniently ignores since wholesaling the service won’t lead to many people cancelling Sky if it’s correct. Having said that if 10% did cancel or follow the movies to another service that would represent a cool one million customers for someone.

Amazon would do well to marry the anticipated arrival in January in the UK of its Kindle Fire tablet, with the promotion of its LoveFiLM online video service, with perhaps new pricing and a new deal separate from DVD rental. So far it has no subscription service only for online, but has some free online movies for DVD subscribers, some which only go with the top end packages and some pay per view online options.

We know that LoverFiLM CEO Simon Calver is opposed to separating the two subscriptions, not only because of what happened to Netflix in the US, but also because he views it primarily as a churn reduction activity for DVD rentals, or at least he did when we last spoke to him.

However Netflix had its biggest growth quarters when it offered a combined service and an online service separately and didn’t hit its PR wall until it actually stopped selling them together and in the process raised the price by around 50%. LoveFiLM’s first DVD rental package which allows unlimited online viewing is £10 a month and that has to be the target price which Netflix undercuts or equals at its launch.

So far the LoveFiLM compatible device portfolio looks weak compared to the device onslaught that Netflix will bring in January, supporting just the iPad among tablets, the Xbox 360 and the PS3 among games consoles, plus PCs, and Sony, Samsung and Cello connected TVs and a number of Sony and Samsung Blu-ray players.

But if Amazon comes out with a combined offer on the new Kindle Fire it could sweep all before it. The Fire plus a subscription to Amazon Prime (which gives a subset of online videos for free) under the LoveFiLM brand, could be quite tempting and it will all depend on the pricing of the entire package. Insiders say the device may be on the market for £150 ($235) and at that price it probably can’t include a Prime membership, the service originally designed for free delivery of Amazon goods, but which now combines free online movies. In the US the Fire was $199, so perhaps it will need to charge something for Prime membership, but this might only be around half of what it usually costs ($79), so look for a £199 version with Prime bundled.

Of course the more successful tablets will also focus on partnerships with all three of these video players and if that includes Samsung Galaxy Tab’s then there’s every reason to expect Apple’s legal actions to slowly extend from the Netherlands and Germany to the UK. Apple has sued Samsung for copying its iPad look and feel, as well as key patents, and Samsung has also responded with countersuits.

Add to this the sudden arrival of all the video devices that sold in numbers in the US on the back of the Netflix service and this means that post-Christmas is the time to be buying in the UK. Sometime in the Spring YouView, which hopes to launch a hybrid broadcast broadband set top to receive most DVB-T channels and VoD, will launch with the backing of all the major broadcasters, some would say way too late.

The issue for the rest of Europe is straightforward. If Sky cannot keep Netflix at bay in the UK, where it is perhaps more dominant than almost any other leading pay TV player in Europe, then what’s to stop Netflix taking a success in the UK as an excuse to sweep across Europe. On the other hand if the combination of LoveFiLM and Sky make it slow going for Netflix in the UK, then other will have a blueprint for a plan to halt Netflix in its tracks in Europe, leaving it very little room to maneuver and with its US market stalled it will have to rely on Latin America for all its growth.