Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 December 2011

US battle over media pluralism rages while Europe dithers

Like the rainbow, a happy compromise over media pluralism and cross ownership can never be reached, because it is impossible to satisfy all parties including regulators, freedom groups, content owners, TV service providers, and media moguls. The issue has been on the boil all year in the US with a series of rulings and actions, culminating in recent heated exchanges between the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB), and an organization called the Free Press set up in 2002 to challenge the influence of corporations over government policymaking. The NAB and Free Press disagree not just on what the rules should be over media ownership, but also over how existing ones should be applied.

Most if not all democratic countries have some rules designed to prevent ownership of newspapers, radio, and TV becoming too concentrated. In the US the situation is more complex than in many other countries because of a three way split between national, regional and local media, and this has made consensus among all groups harder to obtain. Rules that protect local media outlets from being squashed by large national players can themselves prevent small players at that local level from growing through mergers and acquisition that are no threat at a country level.

The current situation is that within the biggest 20 US media markets, a single company can own a TV station and a newspaper. A US media market is defined as an area, such as city, or state county perhaps, served by a single cable TV service or local newspaper. In markets below the top 20, cross ownership of a TV station and newspaper is prohibited. However a single company can own two TV stations, but no more and even then only when there are at least eight competing stations, under the so called duopoly rule. Furthermore if one station in a duopoly is in the top four within a given market, the other must be number five or below.

These rules have been challenged repeatedly and with increasing fervor by media groups, which argue that the media landscape has changed utterly since these regulations over ownership came into force several decades ago. Then all TV was Free To Air, and far more newspapers were sold than today. Now there is competition among cable, satellite, and IPTV operators, with Over The Top also making its presence felt, while many smaller newspapers are dying. As far as newspapers are concerned the objections make sense since the rules are helping to suffocate them by blocking mergers with other media groups that might enable them to survive as part of a larger news organization, where print can work alongside online and video.

However some media groups appear to be circumventing the rules imposed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) through informal alliances to achieve economies of scale without a direct merger. This has led the Free Group to lodge a letter with the FCC, complaining that TV stations unable to merge lawfully under FCC rules were consolidating their core operations, staff and news production, and as a result stifling local competition.

‘The FCC’s media ownership rules are intended to preserve and promote competition, localism and diversity among broadcast media outlets, which receive free use of valuable public spectrum in exchange for serving local communities,’ the letter stated primly.

But NAB quickly issued a withering response accusing the Free Group of being na’ve and out of touch with today’s media world. NAB Executive Vice President of Communications Dennis Wharton stated: “Evidence shows that when a strong local TV station shares resources with another broadcaster, the result is the creation of more local news, weather and sports. The simple reality is that newsgathering and public affairs programming costs money, and that viewers benefit by more choice from a TV station that is free to the public. If the goal of Free Press is to eliminate competition that local broadcasters provide to pay TV conglomerates like Time Warner Cable and DISH, perhaps it should change its name to Pay Press.”

This statement highlights the dilemma facing regulators around the world, which is to stimulate successful local media while also encouraging competition at all levels. Consolidation has to occur when the alternative is for media groups to close and deny the public a source of news, and in those circumstances should be regarded as the natural operation of a free market.

In the European Union there are firm regulations over human rights and consumer protection, and therefore it is perhaps surprising there has been no legislation over media pluralism. But perhaps this reflects the difficulty of reaching agreement across member states that have their own governments and regulatory bodies. Efforts are at last now being made with European Commission Vice-President Neelie Kroes in November 2011 setting up a group to provide recommendations for the ‘respect, protection, support and promotion of media freedom and pluralism in Europe.’

The group’s composition will raise concerns among broadcasters, since their interests are not represented at all. The members are Professor Herta D’ubler-Gmelin, former Minister of Justice of Germany, Professor Lu’s Miguel Poiares Pessoa Maduro, European University Institute and former Advocate-General at the European Court of Justice, and Ben Hammersley, technology journalist and member of the European Commission High Level Expert Group on Media Freedom. The group is drawing up recommendations for protecting pluralism and media freedom in Europe. It will interesting to see what lessons this group will draw from recent experiences across the pond, where the fear is that the baby of consolidated local media is being thrown out with the bathwater of anti-competitive practices.