Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 December 2011

Assia mounts vectoring assault on accelerating the world’s DSL lines

Slowly but surely Assia is taking over the DSL world and already controls some 45 million DSL lines up from 28.5 million lines as year ago, including all 16 million of AT&T’s lines. And if any organization has the confidence of the DSL community that it can put up a decent fight against DOCSIS 3.0 cable based broadband lines, it’s Assia.

As it begins to move its DSL management system out of the US it has customer wins at SFR and Bouygues in France, Orange in Poland, and such notables as SingTel and Telefonica.

We have barely mentioned the company before in Faultline, except to say that its CEO, John Cioffi, once pioneered the original DSL market at a company called Amati, which was sold to form the core of the Texas Instruments DSL business, and that he has more recently pioneered DSL management techniques to remove crosstalk from telco lines, making possible the next generation of 100 mbps DSL lines.

Talking to Jerome Joanny of Assia, senior director product management this week it’s not set to end there. Worldwide there are 368 million DSL lines compared to just 109 million DOCSIS cable broadband lines and 50 million fiber lines. Assia is after the management of all of them.

‘We probably only have a 14% to 15% market share of DSL lines right now, but we have 8 out of 10 in the US and have just opened in Beijing this year and have begun to get traction at China Telecom, as well as at companies like Swisscom in Europe.’

Joanny was accompanying Cioffi as he spoke at the London DSL Acceleration show last week, which told the audience more about the various stages of what he calls Dynamic Spectrum Management ‘ a 3 phased process which should lay out the roadmap for DSL up to 100 Mbps in the next generation and beyond to 1 Gbps further down the line.

DSM optimizes channel capacity by adapting transmissions on all VDSL2 wires in a telco bundle, based on real time changes in crosstalk interference. It goes the extra mile in cancelling out the cross talk which can occur whenever lines are bundled close together, whether that’s at the central office, the cross connect and street cabinets or on entry to a cluster of homes. By processing signals together in a management server the crosstalk can be cancelled out.

DSM divides into four levels, depending on the degree of coordination between multiple DSL lines. Right now it is all at what Joanny calls level zero, where there is no spectrum management and the management of the lines are optimized without reference to one another and the transmit power adopted is based entirely on how far the signal has to reach.

At DSM Level 1 each pair in the binder separately manages its power in order to either completely avoid, or to minimize crosstalk with only the other wire in the pair. This means the power level is decided based both on its own line conditions as well as the line conditions of its partner. At DSM level 2 the management system must be able to take into account and change the power on each line to avoid crosstalk, while in level 3 they are all processed together to as if they were a huge MIMO single service for the entire bundle. This is often called vectoring and vectored-DSM DSL lines coordinate simultaneous binder transmissions to reduce and to exploit crosstalk, while also removing most other noises

Level 0 DSM still represents most of those 368 million DSL lines the world over, and DSM is slowly being introduced. This is why Assia used the conference to introduce its new ASSIA Expresse Pro version 2.5, helping operators move through the gears, almost on a line by line basis, using the management suite of software to do things like identify lines which will benefit from upgrade to VDSL, based on a database of real upgrades and their performance when they were upgraded. The system also sends live field data to the smart phones of DSL field technicians so they don’t need specialist devices in the field, just an iPhone or iPad (there’s an App for that).

The system offers a completely new way of calculating the maximum achievable bit rate for each line, which helps telcos identify target customers for high margin products like IPTV. Version 2.5 also offers a view on the level 2 connection layer, not just the PHY.

We asked Joanny about the deal that received a lot of attention at Broadband World Forum, when Alcatel made an announcement that it was implementing DSM at Belgacom. ‘We fully expect to work with all the major hardware implementers such as Huawei and Alcatel, but this deal didn’t involve us. Alcatel has installed almost all the DSLAMs at Belgacom and is using a different technology which it calls DLM at Belgacom.’

Alcatel-Lucent also used the show to launch its 5530 Network Analyzer which offers Dynamic Line Management (DLM) features such as automatically setting DSL lines to work at their optimal power, so stabilizing service quality. It’s more designed to cut operational spend at a telco by reducing complaints than to increase the broadband speed at customers and it’s been around for quite a while an over the past 6 or 7 years Alcatel has installed something similar at 50 customer sites on 25 million DSL lines with this technology.

‘It’s a far inferior technology to full DSM, all of which are laid out in open standards now, and which Alcatel can and is likely to adopt later on. If Alcatel wants specifically to do vectoring at a client, there is essential intellectual property that Alcatel will have to license from Assia, but that’s all under RAND licensing terms (reasonable and non-discriminatory) because it’s a standard.’

The chips in that Belgacom solution were supplied by Broadcom, a company keen to retain its leadership in DSL. Rival Ikanos is strong in VDSL2 and is one of the first DSM licensees for the Assia IP. ‘Ikanos has licensed our full IP on vectoring, and its chips expose the proper management interface for our DSM system so that devices that use the Ikanos chips can be managed by ASSIA Expresse Pro,’ said Joanny.

‘Neither Broadcom nor Alcatel has licensed any IP from us as of today, but of course we are talking to both of them about this and what we will aim for is for them to implement our management interface in their devices as well.’

Alcatel openly claimed in September that the work it was doing at Belgacom would boost DSL performance to guarantee speeds of 50 Mbps and beyond, calling it the world’s first commercial introduction of VDSL2 Vectoring. We don’t think that can really be true if Joanny is right. Broadcom did however announce the same week that it had the world’s first central office chipset for vectored DSL.

‘You should look in the 2012-2013 time frame for Phantom mode to begin occurring in the market. This piggy backs on DSM level 3 vectoring because without cancelling crosstalk you can’t use multiple pairs of lines to send an extra phantom signal between them,’ said Joanny. The phantom DSL technology has been demonstrated by Alcatel and others about a year ago where at least two pairs of twisted pair send a third set of signals and all of them are multiplexed together at the other end. Effectively you take one wire from the first pair and one from the second pair.

‘Last year Alcatel and Huawei both demonstrated this at 700 mbps to 800 mbps over 3 or four pairs of lines. But first off it is vectoring that gives you most benefit and to get the maximum benefits, what has to happen is that the DSLAM moves 500 feet closer to the home. That’s why companies are making DSLAM cards with 64 lines of VDSL2 in, which fit the street cabinets, instead of putting them into the central office,’ said Joanny.

‘But for Phantom Mode you will need an environment that has multiple twisted pairs to the home. That will be possible in parts of the US, but for the most part this will emerge in expensive enterprise services where the telco has to do a truck roll and install another couple of pairs. We don’t think it is likely that telcos will simply upgrade all homes in Europe with second and third lines, at that point they will think about installing fiber.’

At Faultline we can see that fixed line substitution by mobile phones will leave plenty of spare copper connections at the street cabinet which could be used to upgrade some homes to superfast broadband, but the upgrade cost to offer 1 Gbps DSL is likely to lead to a really expensive services, tough to maintain and draining backhaul capacity, and by then twisted pair may really have had its day.