Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 December 2011

Comcast, Time Warner collude with arch rival Verizon over quad play

US cable TV operators are still jostling for position in quad play half a decade after some of them made their opening gambits. However the big two, Comcast and Time Warner Cable (TWC), seem to have found their long term strategy at last by teaming up with Verizon over future technology development and wholesale. The deal contains a few wrinkles that need to be ironed out, but essentially involve the two cable companies selling Verizon’s products, eventually on a wholesale as well as retail basis, with the latter effectively taking over Comcast’s and TWC’s wireless network. Verizon in turn gains valuable spectrum to expand its wireless services, and the potential to access backhaul capability for these by using Comcast’s and TWC’s networks outside its own footprint.

The deal is in direct opposition to a story which ran this week from Reuters, which says that Verizon is planning its own Netflix class service which will also compete Over The Top with cable operators. Could it be that the Reuters story is simply another aspect of this story and that Verizon will work WITH cable operators to help come up with a national service which involves the two largest cable companies. Otherwise it is taking ‘co-opetition’ a little far to be working on a Quad play with a pay TV rival while also working on a rival OTT TV network.

It did seem that Comcast and TWC already had their quad play strategy sorted out, having invested jointly along with Bright House Networks, the seventh largest US pay TV operator, in a company called Spectrum Co, holding 122 wireless spectrum licenses spanning almost the whole country. However the cable operators decided that running a large wireless network was not their forte and so as part of the deal with Verizon have sold their stakes in Spectrum Co for a total $3.6 billion. Comcast was the biggest holder with 63.6% of SpectrumCo, receiving $2.3 billion from the sale, while TWC gets 30.4% gets $1.1 billion, and Bright House Networks with 5.3% has $189 million.

One subplot is that the deal is another blow for the credibility of Wimax, since it involves Comcast and TWC withdrawing support for the Clearwire deal which uses WiMAX. This side effect comes because the two cable companies had been taking Wimax service on a wholesale basis from Clearwire, but are pulling out as part of the folding of their wireless business in with Verizon. This also reflects abysmal sales of the Wimax service, with Comcast taking 30,000 subs and TWC 27,000, which are very small numbers for operators with respectively 22.5 million and 12.2 million video customers. However, Comcast, TWC, and Bright House are keeping their stakes in Clearwire, indicating they have faith its ability to make something of Wimax, but do not want to hang around waiting for it to happen, or perhaps because right now they wouldn’t get their money back and would have to crystallize a loss.

Meanwhile their deal with Verizon allows the cable companies to sell Verizon services on a wholesale basis eventually, while all three will collaborate on development of technology that integrates wireline and wireless products and services more sweetly. This could involve developments for home networking, and for Verizon brings the potential of extending its footprint via wireless services that may include delivery of TV, perhaps over WiFi, or over LTE. One unspoken part of the deal concerned the potential for Verizon to backhaul its wireless services over Comcast’s and TWC’s cable TV infrastructure. This could be a big deal, because as mobile traffic grows, backhaul is becoming a bottleneck, putting a big strain on bandwidth constrained options such as microwave and twisted pair copper in areas where fiber is not readily available or affordable. This is especially true as experiments in bonded DOCSIS 3.0 cables have shown speeds way beyond 1 Gbps.

At the same time the three operators will want to avoid creating undue tensions by competing for each other’s customers at the cable TV level. Indeed the deal could only be done because while Verizon Wireless has the desired national coverage that cable operators seek for mobile services, there is relatively little overlap in coverage between the networks of Comcast, TWC and for that matter Bright House, with Verizon. In fact the wholesale cooperation will take place mostly if not entirely in areas outside Verizon’s fixed-line footprint, which will combine there with one of the three cable companies to offer quad-play packages, although this will not happen for a year or two yet. However Comcast does have some overlap with Verizon in fixed line coverage and currently the two compete fiercely there, and it remains to be seen whether and if so how that will be resolved.

The deal has left some other US cable operators rather adrift. Cox Communications, the fifth largest US pay TV operator with 4.8 million subscribers, is currently out of the game, after announcing in November 2011 that it will discontinue selling its Cox Wireless phone service from the end of March 2012, with no details on future strategy other than a vague mention of how wireless is still important to the Cox experience.

The situation is rather more promising for Cablevision, the 9th largest US pay TV operator with 3.3 million subscribers, having been courting T-Mobile USA as a partner for wireless services. CableVision deemed that T-Mobile, with its national GSM network, would be a more suitable partner than one of the main alternatives, Sprint Nextel, which had been serving Cox Communications and other smaller cable operators on a wholesale basis. The Sprint Nextel network was based on the CDMA spread spectrum technology that until quite recently dominated North America, but Cablevision appears to favor GSM, as used by T-Mobile as a subsidiary of Deutsche Telekom, partly because it is less complex then to implement international roaming. Another reason for favoring T-Mobile is that it would embrace integration between Wi-Fi and 3G broadband, with the objective of enabling seamless hand off between the two around homes and public hot spots. This would allow customers to take advantage of the greater Quality of Service for video enabled by Wi-Fi when within range, but then be able to continue viewing in the event of the link falling back to 3G.

However this idea of partnering with T-Mobile suddenly looked doomed after AT&T tabled its $39 billion offer for T-Mobile in March 2011, since the former would then seek to provide national quad play services of its own. But since then events have run back in Cablevisions’ favor as the proposed merger has run into unprecedented regulatory opposition. Indeed Cablevision has done its bit to stoke such opposition with various statements that AT&T’s proposed purchase of T-Mobile would eliminate a significant wholesale provider whose absence would make it harder for new companies to enter the US wireless telephony market.

In fact the chairman of the FCC has just stated he does not believe that AT&T’s proposed deal is in the public interest. He has requested the other four FCC commissioners to approve an administrative hearing, in which AT&T would have to prove otherwise. This is a further hurdle for the deal, after it was challenged by the US Department of Justice, which filed a lawsuit in August 2011 to block the merger on competition grounds. All these machinations seem to have held up Cablevision’s quad play plans at a time when Comcast, Time Warner and Bright House are poised to steam ahead in league with Verizon.

Indeed the question arises whether the loose alliance between Verizon and these three cable companies will serve as a model for others. This really depends on competitive issues such as footprint overlap in the markets or countries concerned, but it looks certain there will be further alliances between wireless and cable operators, given the natural synergy with the former offering coverage without the pain of building or running a cable network, and the latter providing access to readymade customers as well as the potential backhaul capacity. Indeed the Verizon deal with those three cable operators came as a disappointment to other US service providers such as Sprint, and LightSquared, as well as Clearwire and T-Mobile.

Normally such deals might run smoothest when the mobile operator is wireless only, unlike the case with Verizon, since then there is no conflict. This has been the case so far with many deals in Europe. In Germany for example O2 has partnerships with Kabel BW, Kabel Deutschland, and the Liberty Global brand Unitymedia.

In the UK, Virgin Media has delivered quad play through a wholesale partnership with the 3G network now known as Everything Everywhere, which is a 50-50 joint venture between Deutsche Telekom and France Telecom, formed in 2010 through the merger of their respective T-Mobile (UK) and Orange UK operations. Virgin Media has exploited this cleverly through attractive multiple play, not necessarily quad play, bundles that include free Blackberry handsets within quite low priced packages. Essentially the pay TV revenue is subsidizing the mobile package, which in turn provides stickiness and combats churn. That indeed is the idea of quad play, which cable operators the world over are now stampeding towards if they are not there already.