The launch of the UltraViolet (UV) digital locker in the UK two months after the US debut comes amid continuing complaints over its usability. The issues raised highlight how the business and technical challenges facing UV are interlinked and cannot be resolved until the DECE (Digital Entertainment Content Ecosystem) consortium which set it up really gets fully behind it.
So far in its first incarnation it is largely a Warner Brothers initiative, does not support the business model it was built for – digital only purchase. It also fails to deliver on the promise of making content easily accessible on all devices. There are fears over the underlying security of the UV model among some rights holders, likely to be unreasonable fears, but they are there. Another factor likely to dog UV in Europe is the ‘not invented here’ syndrome, since UV is regarded as a US centric initiative. This obscures a genuine debate among pay TV operators over the introduction of a third party in managing their relationship with customers on content and digital rights.
The situation now is that UV allows subscribers to purchase a physical copy of a movie such as ‘Horrible Bosses’ from Warner Home Entertainment in DVD or Blu-Ray form, and they can then obtain a code for the associated digital copy that in theory will play on multiple devices without needing any DVD ripping or transfer. At the same time the plan is to allow streaming of content to smartphones and tablets for mobile viewing, given that downloading to these devices will soak up their memory.
This idea of forcing people to buy the physical product in order to get the far more convenient online product has been tried by studios before in the DVD era, and quite simply it doesn’t work. Consumers have no desire to travel to the shops when they want to see movies. Otherwise Blockbuster wouldn’t have gone bust. This sort of short sighted behavior just promotes piracy, because pirating the content is ‘easier’ and more rewarding than the business models that the studios are adopting.
UV is capable of creating an ecosystem like Apple has, but for open platforms. Apple already delivers on the full promise of UV among its own device constellation, allowing iPhones, iPads, Apple TVs and computers running iTunes to download purchased content that will then run on any of them if they are authorized devices. For this reason iTunes already has about 65% of the digital movie market, and this is likely to rise in the short term following the launch of iCloud, which makes management and storage of content easier and more intuitive.
But Apple does not address non-Apple devices, including TVs, and has no intention of doing so. UV will support any connected TV set, as well as any mobile and TV platform. This should be UV’s big opportunity, but is where UV’s promise diverges sharply from reality. Most of the promised device and platform support has simply not yet been implemented, and clearly it is a rubbish idea to launch the platform in its current half-baked form. Subsequent experience by early users seems to have confirmed these misgivings, which can best be summarized by considering what tends to happen in practice.
At present if you want to get a digital copy of a movie available from UV, you have to firstly create accounts with both UV itself and also Flickster, in order to enter the code that comes with your physical copy. But many users would then want to watch their movie on the move, and to do that say on an Android phone they need to install an app on that to download the content, as they cannot transfer the copy across from their computer. The same applies to the iPad or iPhone.
These hurdles deter users from buying into UV, but worse are rumors that because of problems downloading movies to PCs, Flickster has referred people to Apple’s iTunes and issued coupons for that. If this is happening on a significant scale it’s a massive shot in the foot, since Apple is not part of DECE and may still be hoping to revive the rival KeyChest digital locker being promoted by its strong partner Disney. The only good news here for UV is that we have heard very little from KeyChest lately, which has virtually no support beyond Disney.
At least UV has widespread industry support, numbering all the studios apart from Disney, major CE vendors like Sony and Samsung, content security vendors like NDS, pay TV operators like Comcast, retailers such as LoveFilm, and the major technology players such as Microsoft and Cisco. Conspicuous by their absence though are many Telcos and mobile operators, which have expressed concerns over the security challenges and are also worried that widespread video streaming over cellular networks will cause serious congestion. Ironically though rights issues are likely to restrict streaming of movies to the US for the time being, which is another issue facing UV.
That too highlights the dilemma facing the many rights owners among UV members, which want to provide legitimate users open access to content they own, without opening the door to pirates. This could prove a big challenge because the UV model allows use of several DRMs, creating potential weak links given that history tells us interfaces are more vulnerable to attack than the components they interconnect. The truth is that the system operates a complex negotiation to be sure that the key to one DRM is never passed to another, weaker DRM, but that leads us back to the downloads and streams, which replace that.
Until UV has been deployed in anger it’s impossible to know if that negotiation is sufficiently robust and anticipates these threats. In practice it is impossible within an ecosystem as complex as UV to anticipate all threats until they have occurred, so it is almost certain some security breaches will arise that will need to be countered, just as has happened throughout the era of pay TV. UV premium content will have a high value when it enters the UV ecosystem because windows for release of the digital version and physical DVD will coincide. In fact the digital version in the US may even precede full theatrical release elsewhere in some cases. It will therefore present an enticing target for pirates.
The other concern rumbling around Europe in particular centers on the US centricity, and the fact the digital rights are hosted there. This might sound inconsistent given that European service providers have never seemed too concerned about Apple or Google being US companies, but perhaps with UV they sense a more permanent ceding of control if the universal digital locker resides in the US. Telcos are also fearful of having a third party intruding on their relationship with the customer, relegating them almost to the dreaded role of pipe provider, making little revenue from movie sales.
This is a misguided attitude. For one thing the US centricity largely reflects that country’s dominance of the movie business through the Hollywood Studios, and beyond that UV’s membership is genuinely international, with Sony in fact one of the strongest advocates. Secondly, despite all the issues we have raised, UV could represent the future for not just the movie industry, but digital content as a whole. Consumers want it as well, or certainly law abiding ones do, with even techies getting fed up with having to rip and download apps all over the place and even then find that some of their devices cannot access their content.
In the end broadband service providers really have no choice but to get behind UV. Communications revenues are falling, while spending on entertainment is holding up despite the collapse in music sales, so how else will they be able to maintain ARPU.
Telcos counter by saying that movie sales will do little to help ARPU when it is based on DVD retailing, and anyway the likes of major UK retailer Tesco make virtually no money on DVD sales anyway. But they would do well to pay closer attention to what Tesco is saying, since it knows a thing or two about ARPU itself. Tesco is in fact one of UV’s greatest advocates, and argues that even if the immediate sales of movies make little money, the key lies in having a comprehensive digital entertainment platform that will spawn sales of other products. This is the point Telcos should also be taking on board.
Tesco incidentally appeared at first sight to be snubbing UV this month by launching a non UV digital locker in partnership with Blinkbox, the online TV and movie service it acquired in April 2011. This actually preceded the UK launch of UV itself, and provides access to much more content, with the first 25 eligible titles including Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2, The Hangover Part 2, Crazy Stupid Love and Final Destination 5 from Warner Bros, but also Disney’s Cars 2 and The Lion King.
But significantly as the UK’s second largest video retailer, accounting for about 15% of unit sales, Tesco has reaffirmed its commitment to UV, presenting its initial non UV digital locker as a positioning exercise with its own retail loyalty card customers. Its strategy for opening out its digital entertainment platform to the world resides with UV. Notably Tesco is already talking to the other Hollywood studios that are UV members about getting content for this initial non UV platform, including Universal and Fox.
Tesco’s own offering does also hold one important lesson for the UV community as a whole. It allows regular Tesco customers to purchase a participating film on DVD or Blu-Ray in a Tesco store or from Tesco.com, and then via their Clubcard a digital version is created automatically without needing to set up a Blinkbox account. Such facility would answer some of the early criticisms of the current UV service in the US.
We think Telcos should adopt a similar model, especially as in their case they have a readymade base of online customers ready and willing to participate in the ecosystem. The fact that the impact on ARPU is not immediate should not deter them.