Broadcom and Entropic are preparing entr’es for CES that are mouthwatering in terms of demonstrating what kind of digital home dust up we are in for during 2012. Broadcom has jumped suddenly and early to MoCA 2.0 on all of its core set top chips, adding OTT services in the process and Placeshifting, while Entropic has put in a stalking horse bankruptcy bid for its own set top chip business from Trident.
Entropic has been saying for some while that it is ready to deliver MoCA 2.0 capability first quarter 2012, and this is clearly a spoiler from Broadcom, saying that it has it on its major, app capable set top SoCs. Broadcom omits to discuss delivery dates, strategically suggesting that it has caught up with Entropic, when clearly it hasn’t.
Broadcom took a long time, almost a year, from first announcement until when it began to actually ship MoCA capability, but Broadcom now says that it will show 6 set top chips and hybrid gateways at CES with the MoCA 2.0 capability. Likely delivery will be third to fourth quarter.
It also points out that MoCA is supported at Charter, Cogeco, Comcast, Cox, DirectTV, Dish Network, Rogers, Time Warner Cable and Verizon’s FiOS, as if this scoped out its opportunity ‘ which of course it does, but it has yet to unseat Entropic at any of them.
Broadcom says that its SoCs have advanced power management for low power sleep and Wake-on-Lan modes and says they support higher levels of security for enhanced content protection, by which we assumed it means the Cryptography Research Inc (CRI) on-chip security root and cryptographic core which we revealed were on there in September, although Broadcom may equally have been referring to DTCP-IP and possibly Nagra’s NoC on chip system, as well and they are likely all supported.
Broadcom will be pitching this as the first integrated portfolio which has MoCA 2.0 on-board and cites MoCA 2.0 as offering double the video bandwidth and lower power. Back in November we told you that ST Micro was also about to put MoCA 1.1 into its set top chips, as it passed compliance tests, to further undermine Entropic’s 100% grip on MoCA. MoCA uses QAM modulation on thousands of OFDM sub-carriers, but also adds complex bit loading algorithms, so that for each carrier a calculation is done about how many bits it can deliver given its specific carrier to noise ratio, dynamically changing over time. This makes it a complex design and makes the Silicon difficult to nail down.
Both MoCA and MoCA 2.0 operate above 500 MHz and MoCA 2.0 goes up to 1650 MHz , which allows multiple MoCA networks to find frequencies alongside existing cable services.
Broadcom first added MoCA to existing set top SoC chips, back in 2009, but clearly struggled with the technology. Entropic said at IBC that it was ready with MoCA 2.0 chips, while both ST Micro and Broadcom were seen to be struggling with MoCA 1.1 ‘ well if it is still struggling, Broadcom has at least decided to struggle with the more advanced MoCA 2.0 version.
But the writing is on the wall for Entropic. Without its own integrated set top SoC it was bound to struggle once both Broadcom and ST Micro successfully implement MoCA 2.0, which is why this week it has offered $55 million for the set top part of Trident Microsystems, which went into Chapter XI on the same day, and for which it will need a court’s permission to sell off. The idea is that it can do a back to back deal, with a rapid court agreement, so that it can apply the $55 million to other creditors, along with other relief measures Trident has taken, and get back to its knitting, which is making image display processors.
This is a make or break deal for Entropic, which has done well to stay ahead in the MoCA market which it virtually invented, without getting acquired. Back in February 2010, Trident acquired the TV and STB businesses of NXP and merged it with its own nascent teams to create what it hoped would be a set-top box contender. If it does manage to buy the division and no more bids are filed at the court, Entropic is likely to pick up LG as a customer, which has just agreed with the Trident set top division to get into the Android set top market for cable, jointly developing a hybrid cable set top for Korea ‘ which would be a good start.
Trident also said it has entered a license agreement with RDA Technologies offering a non-exclusive license to its SX-5 SoC product for the TV for $7.5 million and expects to receive an additional $8.5 million in the near term, which when added to the proceeds from the sale of its facility in China, should provide adequate liquidity for it to continue as a going concern.
Trident’s set top product line-up features ARM Cortex-A9 based SoCs optimized for Adobe Flash, HTML5 and OpenGLES2.0 and Entropic would hire 385 Trident employees located in China, India, the UK, Taiwan, Korea and the US.
Entropic has in the past told us that its MoCA 2.0 chips will deliver 400 Mbps in a single 100 MHz channel, double that to 800 Mbps in two bonded MoCA channels, with an extra 20% throughput when it operates in Turbo mode, so 500 Mbps in one channel and 1 Gbps in two.
Broadcom says that its 40nm MoCA 2.0 set top and gateway platforms use dual-threaded MIPS-based CPUs which deliver 3000 DMIPS and will be available on its BCM7429 Multi-Room HD-DVR chip; its BCM7428 IP HD set top; its BCM7425 and 7422 HD Transcoding Hybrid Gateways; as well as its BCM3325 IP Transcoding Gateway and BCM3322 IP Gateway.
But it also said that it had signed a deal with EchoStar to put its Sling Media’s Sling Loaded platform into some of these same SoCs. Many rivals to EchoStar’s once parent company, Dish Networks have been unsure of offering placeshifting on EchoStar made devices, especially while that was under a patent suit from TiVo, which is why incorporating the technology into Broadcom set top SoCs, makes so much sense. The resulting streams can then be sent around the home or from the home, for wireless delivery of video to portable devices.
The Sling Media software ecosystem will be supported on the Broadcom BCM7425 Dual HD Transcoding MoCA Gateway SoC and these will be available in the third quarter of 2012.
Finally Broadcom said that it will introduce OTT services on most of its SoCs too, to enable existing TVs to be turned into smart TVs which can play Apps and connect to the internet. These will come with access to Broadcom’s own Web Application Framework, Adobe’s AIR for the Digital Home, Nokia’s Qt and Android.