Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 January 2012

S-LCD deal is some long needed good news for Sony, not Samsung

One of the big stories hidden in the Christmas dip from our point of view was the deal whereby Sony sold off its 50% of the S-LCD venture to its partner Samsung, giving it full control of the plant.

Most coverage struggled to make sense of the move, and more or less called it a draw. Sony would now be able to take advantage of cheaper component markets to buy both potentially better screens, possibly at better prices, while Samsung could re-target the 7th and 8th generation facilities at other, more modern technologies such as AMOLED. We’re not buying , this was a sorely needed win for Sony.

The joint venture was established back in 2004 when Sony had backed OLED technology arriving earlier and failing to make it happen. It had no subsequent generation screen products and needed to establish its LCD supply lines urgently, and it put $2 billion into the venture and has contributed more since. Now, although it has taken just $935 million out of its half, and will take a significant write down on the investment, the tables are turned.

It only takes a few seconds perusing the DisplaySearch graph below to see what’s happened to the LCD TV market, and it’s a market that looks like it is heading for commodity status ‘ good for revenue, but not for profit.

The global transition from CRT technologies is what has been driving LCD screen growth and now that transition is virtually over. The new transition is not about the screen, but about the backlight technology, as we move from LCD to LED TV sets, and Sony has already secured its supply lines in what is the current key differentiation technology ‘ LED, from Sharp in a deal that it cut in 2009. Since then it has even pulled out of a deal to secure this further, when last April Sony was supposed to take its ownership in the Sharp LED plant to 34%, but suddenly realized that the strength of the Yen meant it could buy LED technology outside of Japan even more cheaply. Buying cheaply is suddenly vital in a market where Sony stumbled last quarter, and where its products are always the most expensive. Sony is expected to retrench further in 2012 in a market where global growth when measured by units is expected to be just 2%. The landgrab for LCD TV’s is over and gone are the 50% growth per annum years.

Prior to 2004 Sony had shown that it had the best TV picture by owning the core screen technology, it then invested in digital end to end (no analog parts) in its Wega TV engine, and managed to continue its differentiation through its controller technology. But even that advantage has now gone. Sony spent many of the years from 2005 to 2010 reducing the number of parts it manufactured or sourced by integrating all of its designs. And yet still its TV manufacturing business has fallen on the worst of times.

Since then Apple has shown the world the way. It buys completed sub-systems using its financial might, design strength and brand to ensure that it maintains volumes, and then bids aggressively for priority or even exclusive component supply. It’s very tough to do that with a plant that you half own, and which is half owned by your biggest rival.

Sony may never achieve its goal of being more like Apple, but it will certainly never get there being tied in to rivals for its supply lines. Apple makes very few of the components in its devices, it makes even less of the components ‘ even the ones that it designs, such as its A5 chip ‘ and rarely even assembles the completed items. Apple puts all its energy into design, market approach, content stores and marketing. Sony has historically tried instead to control key component technologies.

In effect this is a simple decision ‘ which would you rather own if you ran Sony, half a plant that sold you expensive LCD TV screens, when your TV business was in pieces, or the half of a cellular phone business that you don’t own, although you control it, in the form of Sony Ericsson? In a cellular market which is still growing rapidly. The price of the two deals are comparable enough that Sony Ericsson has only taken a $600 million toll on its cash reserves, for the Sony-Ericsson deal, buy selling off the plant for what it can get, instead of the full $1.45 billion

All the rhetoric about Sony and Samsung reaching a new deal was analyzed by DisplaySearch this week in its quarterly bulletin, which said that Sony would likely continue its use of S-LCD screens through 2012 and then shift about 50% away from Samsung, sharing its favors with other players and in the process weakening Samsung.

The two also say they will continue cooperative engineering efforts focused on LCD panels, but this is really all face-saving stuff. We can see from the DisplaySearch graph that OLED is not coming to Samsung’s rescue very rapidly and there are those who question that it is ever going to be ready to replace OLED screens in TV sizes. Currently OLEDs are being sold in volume in sizes up to just 4 inches, so really just for phones, with Tablets the next target size. TVs are a long ways off.

The key to Sony’s future here is that the sources of supply do not dry up, and that Sony is smart enough to be more like Apple and ensure that it has enough panels, by committing on volumes in advance, with brave cash commitments. This should give it the opportunity to offer lower priced TV sets, which may offer a break on its declining TV market share ‘ a market which Samsung now leads.

Sony will take a non-cash impairment of ’66 billion ($860 million) in its third quarter numbers, but reckons that annual savings on panels will be ’50 billion ($650 million) and Sony will produce a new forecast to include these adjustments.

Sony is said to be now seeking LCD sourcing agreements with Taiwan’s AUO and Chimei Innolux, as well as Samsung’s main Korean rival LG Display.

We can see almost no upside here for Samsung and although it has always managed to get through periods of oversupply in areas like Flash memory, it will be far more hard pressed to do this in LCD panel supply going forwards.