In a move that will prompt hundreds of frantic emails to lobbyists and Washington contacts, New York governor Andrew Cuomo is looking to secure $500 million in state funds to install a 6,000-mile fiber network in New York State – and he’s asking for a matching donation from service providers and interested parties who plan to compete in the footprint, going up against names such as Verizon, Cablevision and Time Warner Cable.
Cuomo’s statement is currently nowhere near being policy quite yet and is effectively a campaign promise for the residents of upstate New York who feel they have historically been underserved by the incumbents. But while the price of entrance is fairly negligible in the grand scheme of things for the large ISPs (a proportion of the other half-billion dollars), if the funding can be tied to legal guarantees and repercussions for lapses in service, then Cuomo could secure fiber broadband for a state at a marginal cost to the taxpayer – fiber that is as future-proof a communication technology as is available today, and a technology that the current US ISPs are in no hurry to install of their own volition.
The US broadband market’s rigid segmentation has led to companies operating many hundreds of small local monopolies – while saying that they compete fairly at a national level. As such, many customers are locked into markets in which there is a choice between broadband from a cableco or telco, with satellite broadband as their only other choice. This is not in the spirit of free market competition that the US was built on.
Consequently, the incumbent ISP faces little competition, if any, and the quality of the broadband in the market suffers. Since there is no competitor for customers to turn to. Networks receive slow upgrades which no amount of government interference can influence.
So it is always slightly amusing to see the toys get thrown out of the pram as soon as a municipality begins discussing laying a fiber network to compensate for the mass of complaints generated by the poor service of these ISPs. The furor generated by EPB in Chattanooga was particularly noteworthy, particularly as the opposition argument was that the municipal utility had a competitive advantage over the incumbents – something which the incumbent enjoys already thanks to the archaic local market provisioning and state funding and tax breaks. EPB also managed to do this with a budget of $300 million, which call into question the incumbent’s complaints about the cost of competition and operation.
EPB, the city-owned electricity utility, decided to lay a fiber network primarily as part of its smart grid upgrades– which adds processing and analytics power to an electricity grid to improve efficiencies and resiliency. One major benefit of these upgrades was that EPB could provide gigabit internet to any customer who had a meter owned by EPB in their homes in and around the city of Chattanooga.
EPB is currently petitioning the FCC to allow it to run a triple-play offering to all of the residents in its footprint, with plans to expand to any community that requests fiber service – i.e. all those underserved by the incumbent. Incentivizing customers with such an offering also lets a utility like EPB to lay the FTTH connection required for the smart meters – which many customers might otherwise be reluctant to have fitted.
And the tide seems to be turning, with EPB securing the tacit support of the FCC, with Tom Wheeler criticizing Tennessee’s municipal broadband laws by saying Chattanooga was “the poster child for both the benefits of community broadband networks, and also a prime example of the efforts to restrict them.” Lafayette, Louisiana and Bristol, Virginia have also gone the gigabit route, and Syracuse, New York is also planning on laying fiber, Google Fiber is only a lawsuit away from national operations.
But Cuomo’s plan is part of a re-election campaign, so we must be careful of getting too excited about the potential impending shake up in the broadband markets. Nonetheless, “broadband availability is going to be what the interstate road system was in the 50s,” said Cuomo in the Times Union, “you’re going to need access to broadband if you’re going to be competitive.”
He went on, adding “it’s not just about a campaign. It’s about a relationship and how we govern. One of the fundamental shifts in state government over the past few years is we’re not warring with the business community, we’re no jockeying with the business community, and that makes a major difference.”