Cord shaving has become a greater fear for pay TV operators than cord cutting, since it has a direct impact on the bottom line. Cord cutting can even be given a positive spin as a way of removing the dead wood from bottom end unprofitable subscribers.
But now cord shaving appears to be having a direct impact on cable networks as well as the overall operators, at least in the US where the latest data from Nielsen reveals a significant drop in subs for the leading TV networks. The aggregate decline for the 40 leading cable networks is 3.2 million households over four years or 3% of the total audience.
ESPN is one of the biggest losers, down 4.5% at 95.2 million households, equalled by TNT down 4.5% at 95.9 million, while Nickelodeon, HLN, TBS, Weather Channel, Discovery, CNN, and the USA Network are all down just over 3%. It is hard to tell whether it is the same households ditching all of them or whether the figures represent people getting more discriminating, but one clear point is that the figure is well in excess of the decline in pay TV subs over the period of around 300,000, depending on how it is counted and who is included. Therefore cable network subs have been declining 10 times faster than pay TV, suggesting that cord shaving is responsible for 90% of that and cord cutting only 10%.
For the moment the networks remain bullish, pointing out that revenues are actually up on the back of rising transmission fees. This echoes the argument of US MSOs a year or two back when ARPU was rising even though subs were falling, because of upselling to premium packages among customers rather than churning. This data on the networks suggests that subscribers have more recently been converting to lower priced packages, given that many of the network channels are part of premium offerings. It does not suggest particularly that many people are switching completely from traditional pay TV to OTT providers, but some cord shavers may be turning to the latter to top up their programming. There is also some evidence that the high price of live premium sports is squeezing some subs away from those providers, although at the same time there is no real OTT alternative there as yet in the US.
Meanwhile pay TV operators themselves are on the verging of being forced to tap the cord shaving trend to some extent and eat their own lunch by taking the OTT plunge as some put it. Sky has done this in the UK and Germany with Now TV but US operators have mostly not yet followed suit. Instead they have come out with cloud based offerings like Comcast’s X1 service, DirecTV’s Genie and DISH’s Hopper, centralising DVR resources with IP integration.
For Comcast, X1 has increased ARPU among existing customers but has done nothing to recruit new customers. We are now waiting for the arrival of genuine OTT-only offerings from US operators, which looks imminent as Dish Digital, Dish Network’s division in charge of the satellite operator’s OTT project, has registered the name “Nutv” and associated logo. The hope is that at least they can pick up some of the cord shavings themselves.
But that may not happen because there is another trend related to cord shaving not picked up by Nielsen here, which is a shift from linear to online versions of some of these premium channels themselves. In the case of the Weather Channel viewers may be drifting away from the TV network but traffic to its web site weathe.com has doubled over the last two years. If this is a trend not confined to the Weather Channel it is far more worrying for traditional operators.