Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 January 2014

Operators divided over cloud UI rendering

It is often assumed that over time all computationally intensive pay TV functions will migrate to the cloud, but the actual situation is not quite that simple. This is certainly turning out to be the case with UI rendering, where Dutch MSO Ziggo has been blazing a trail with its deployment of ActiveVideo’s Cloud TV platform. Launched in October 2012 Ziggo’s cloud TV service involved migration of VoD navigation as well as guide features such as content discovery, search and previews and full UI rendering, into the network.

This broke new ground not by absorbing ‘computationally intensive’ functionality from a set top as such, since this had been done before, but by rendering the whole UI in the cloud and then distributing it as part of the MPEG Transport stream, instead of relying on a local rendering engine running typically in a set top or gateway. Ziggo is still almost unique among major operators in doing this for commercially available services, although Deutsche Telekom is on the verge of deploying the same UI rendering based on ActiveVideo’s platform in European markets outside Germany, while Liberty Global is doing it to reach devices not served by its Horizon hybrid box.

Ziggo refers to its UI rendering as a streaming graphical user interface (SGUI) and has been deploying this steadily across its user base in the 14 months since the launch. By the end of Q1 2013 there were 60,000 devices activated with the SGUI, rising to 150,000 at the end of Q2 and 229,000 three months later according to Ziggo’s figures, so we reckon it will be closing in on 300,000 now. It is quite likely that Deutsche Telekom and Liberty Global will overtake Ziggo during 2014 in terms of cloud UI rendering deployments given their larger user bases.

Yet overall deployment of UI rendering will be patchy because it does not make sense in many cases. It certainly will not work for satellite or digital terrestrial broadcast environments because latency would be too great, leading to a poor user experience. We only have to look at the poor channel zapping time that ruined many earlier IPTV services to see that no operator will want to risk alienating subscribers that way again. Then cloud UI rendering only makes sense for those cable operators with full DOCSIS 3.0 infrastructures, while for Telcos offering IPTV services it may only be viable for a proportion of the user base where sufficiently high bandwidth and low latency can be guaranteed. For smaller operators the necessary investment in infrastructure may not be justifiable.

There are also situations where nearly all subscribers have modern set tops rendering the UI very well and in those cases there is a heightened risk that cloud UI will initially, at least, reduce quality of experience.

Even where UI rendering in the cloud would work well, it may not, initially at least, stack up economically. This is because rendering the whole UI in the cloud requires just as much computation per user as doing it in the home on a set top and the average cost of server side processing units is a little higher. Therefore cloud UI rendering can actually impose higher computational costs than set top UI rendering.

ActiveVideo, along with Ziggo and its other customers such as Deutsche Telekom, reply by pointing out that computational costs are only part of the economic equation and that ongoing maintenance and support is much cheaper when done in one place, rather than distributed across a large set top or gateway population. On top of that cloud UI rendering accelerates time to market and as a result can increase ARPU. Ziggo says that turn-around time for upgrades has been slashed from over a year to a few months as a result of deploying cloud UI rendering and also that sales of Transactional VoD have massively increased.

Nevertheless these latency and economic considerations have led to an alternative approach to cloud TV UI emerging in the US from Comcast, now joined by Time Warner and others, in the shape of the RDK (Reference Design Kit). This is based on traditional local rendering in the set top, but now inside an HTML5 browser via a webkit engine. The other difference from the legacy approach is that RDK obtains metadata from the cloud to perform the rendering of the UI inside the set top or gateway browser. Comcast argues that full cloud UI rendering will remain a niche solution, appealing to those operators with a large base of legacy set tops perhaps that would otherwise face high replacement costs.

Certainly Ziggo fits this bill, having a very diverse set top installed base as well as a large population of TVs with CI+ interfaces capable of working directly with cloud UI rendering. But Deutsche Telekom reckons that the economics are swinging towards full cloud UI rendering because of the trend towards virtualization, achieving far greater economies of scale for server side processing, coupled with continuing high cost of support associated with legacy set top box populations. The argument is that the fragmented approach of RDK will entail PC-like support and maintenance costs.

The interesting case here is Liberty Global, which is deploying Active Video’s CloudTV while also having licensed Comcast’s RDK. It looks like Liberty Global is hedging its bets, or at any rate complementing an overall Cloud UI strategy around Active Video for existing set tops as well as future connected devices such as tablets and Smart TVs, falling back to RDK in those markets where it is not economically feasible to upgrade set tops to deliver Horizon-like experiences.

We could be looking at a US/Europe split here, with RDK gaining a lot of ground in the former, especially now that Samsung has taken a license and is set to come out with boxes half the price of today’s models. This will at the very least postpone onset of cloud UI rendering, since economic benefits would be less clear cut.

Meanwhile latency remains a challenge for full cloud UI rendering that is only on the way to being solved, as Ziggo itself admits. We can see that echoed in the reception given to Sony’s new cloud-based gaming service announced at CES 2014, which will bring classic PlayStation titles to a range of gadgets, from tablet computers to televisions. PlayStation Now is launching with a limited beta in the US this month, followed by a likely global roll-out in the summer. Early feedback is that latency is still an issue on some broadband networks, suggesting this will also be the case for cloud UI rendering. Ziggo has agreed that as the bleeding edge operator it has had to contend with latency issues and still has some work to do on that front.