Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 January 2014

Farewell then Net Neutrality ‘ quaint idea, but business is business

US papers have been quick to write off Net Neutrality as if a) The US owns the concept and b) because a US court has said the FCC has stepped beyond its remit in enforcing it. Actually what we have is a stand-off.

The court was speaking about a ruling made by the FCC to prevent operators from charging companies to speed up their access, or rather to not slow it down. No-one, not the US Congress, nor the European Commission, wants the weighty task of writing a law, that will invariably be interpreted and then re-written and involve years of litigation, if they don’t have to, and while Europe might get one through, it is by no means certain that the business friendly US Congress would support such a law.

The FCC tried to suggest that it would come down hard on US operators who breached Net Neutrality principles, primarily so that Congress would not have to give it the sanction to do so. All that the US court has done is say ‘if you want to bully the operators, you can only do it if there is a common carrier service which has universal carriage principles’ ‘ because that’s why the FCC was created in the first place.

Actually the FCC was created around the 1934 Telecommunications Act and its later update in 1996. And its function is now quite complex. It’s job is largely seen to promote fair competition in communication and best use of national resources, such as spectrum assets, but in recent years it has strayed as far afield as policing decency on the TV, a move which led to it being widely censured and President Bush introducing his own legislation to back up the FCC stance.

And that’s pretty much where we are today. One judge in a federal appeals court has said no to the FCC, the next step is to do nothing and wait for an offending practice from the plaintiff ,Verizon or another operator. But if it begins charging say Google for access to its consumers, right now they will vote with their feet and desert its broadband lines. And while that is going on, Congress (perhaps stimulated by the President) could hastily produce legislation that will back up the FCC remit.

In the meantime the case could be pushed towards the Supreme Court, although our feeling is that there is no need to, not while all US operators are too scared of competition to break ranks and cross the Net Neutrality line. The FCC can come down hard in terms of promoting competition in the future, and preventing growth, for instance by acquisition, of any of those companies who want to ignore its party line on Net Neutrality. The FCC can quid pro quo control.

The court ruled that the FCC has no authority to prevent internet ‘discrimination’ until broadband is classified as a ‘common-carrier’ service, like the phone service. It would not be easy for Congress to simply upgrade broadband to that status, since the providers of broadband include companies who are not considered Common Carriers, i.e. the US cable MSOs. And anyway if US cablecos were made into Common Carriers and broadband was to take on universal obligations, then Verizon would be very happy that cable was lumbered.

So while most people in the US are saying that this is one of the most important decisions on the future of the Internet, the truth is that it is an ‘un-decision,’ and the outcome won’t matter a damn. The situation is the same in Europe, where the European Commission agrees it does not have the power to regulate Net Neutrality, but says if companies step out of line it WILL introduce it as legislation, which may well be worse than self-policing. Right now the way to support Net Neutrality is to ensure that multiple sources of broadband are available everywhere and that all the broadband operators in one region cannot act in concert in changing the rules, and there are already laws about that.

If Verizon suddenly blocks Netflix, or access to online ESPN it would send a shock through the US broadband system, and overnight destabilize the Verizon share price, as its few broadband customers deserted in droves (wee say few, it has about 8.9 million, but way less than cable). And the same for any other US broadband supplier. Net neutrality concerns of US broadband ISPs have really already been addressed by the FCC, confirming that it is okay to ‘prioritize’ certain types of traffic, just not to de-prioritize traffic from one single rival, as well as it having no problem with the use of Deep Packet Inspection ‘per se’ for these purposes, or with data caps for consumers.

There are more subtle areas of debate, such as Comcast not counting the delivery of its own video services towards a home’s data cap, but this has done nothing to slow down Netflix, although it has boosted Streampix.

But prior decisions made by the FCC could potentially be reversed such as Comcast blocking Vonage VoIP traffic and blocking P2P file sharing indiscriminately on its network. But as we say, the new status quo created during this two year legal challenge may well hold, whereby caps and prioritization of a traffic type has been allowed and this might be seen as good enough for now.

The ruling left part of the FCC’s Open Internet Order intact, which was one of the most important, that an ISP must disclosure how it is treating its traffic and managing any priorities. We don’t think Net Neutrality is dead, but the balance of power, purely in the US, has shifted from one foot to the other.