Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 January 2014

Google $3.2 billion Nest buy focuses attention on IoT

Google has bought Nest Labs, the maker of a smart thermostat and smart smoke detector, for $3.2 billion in cash. Founded by former Apple engineers Tony Fadell, and Matt Rogers in 2010, who were heavily involved in the development of the iPod and iPhone, Nest has already benefited from tens of millions of dollars of investment from Google Ventures.

The move surprised the markets and drags everyone who does not already have a strategy to take a long hard look at just how big the Internet of Things is going to be and to ask the question of whether or not they should also buy their way into that market.

What Google has bought is design indulgence. Nest’s most successful product is the Learning Thermostat. It is sold in Apple stores for Apple prices ($249) with Apple design and looks. It requires a good deal of DIY knowledge, or an electrician to fit, if you don’t already have an embedded thermostat ‘ which further adds to the cost of purchase. It is a premium product but comes with an established reputation as the leading implementation of smart home heating management. It can be controlled directly or through a smartphone app, but its main selling point is how it learns a user’s routine.

It can use temperature, movement, humidity and light sensors to determine if your building is empty and respond appropriately, and claims to save money and energy for those who buy it. It turned heads upon release, and Nest has followed it up with the Nest Protect smoke and carbon monoxide alarm. The Protect, another expensive top of the range product, has a smartphone app and can communicate with other Nest devices. It is billed as a smart solution that can alert people away from home via the app. It is also designed not to overreact to burnt toast, and the alarm can be turned off with a wave, when accidentally activated.

Both devices have been reviewed favorably apart from their price, and in a few months Google will own them. To us this seems like a pre-emptive strike at gaining mindshare in domestic IoT apps, which Google has the money and vision to absorb into its Search Engine, Android, Chrome, Google TV and Google Glass cloud based universe of personal automation.

The deal will have an uneventful move through regulatory approval and will finalized in a few months. Nest will continue to operate independently and under the leadership of Fadell.

Matt Rogers’ offered a Q&A session on the Nest blog, in which he addressed some of the concerns of Nest users. He said that Nest will still support iOS apps, and that Nest is still dedicated to its users’ privacy. He wrote that ‘our privacy policy clearly limits the use of customer information to providing and improving Nest’s products and services. We’ve always taken privacy seriously and this will not change.’

If you drank all of Google’s Cool Aid, and used all of its products, it would know what you search for on the web, the contents of your email, what you watch on TV, when you are at home, what temperature you like your bath at and who you share it with. This amount of personalized information makes suspicious civil liberty groups understandably jumpy. The problem is not that these services are provided, but that they are provided by a single company.

The criticisms so far leveled at Nest is the way it has focused on point products and has no generic approach to temperature control, home security, the automation of windows and doors, the installation of home security cameras and locks and the management of energy outside of heating (air conditioning, shades) and lighting. Other companies have focused on a route to market involving operators, which makes AT&T, Verizon and Comcast among the rivals for Google’s new fledgling.

Both companies sound optimistic about the deal. Rogers said that ‘Nest’s product line obviously caught the attention of Google and I’m betting there’s a lot of cool stuff we could do together, – but nothing to share today.’ Fadell is equally enthusiastic, writing ‘Google will help us fully realize our vision of the conscious home and allow us to change the world faster than we ever could if we continued to go it alone.’ This is quite a claim from what was once a trendy thermostat company, but now that Google’s behind Nest, it is not quite so farfetched and saccharine flavored.

Larry Page, Google’s CEO, said ‘Nest has built a tremendous team that we are excited to welcome to the Google family. They’re already delivering amazing products ‘ reinventing unloved but important devices in the home.’

The internet backlash in comment sections has already begun, with consumers scathing about the need to have a Google+ account to run your Nest product, and jokes about Google next getting into selling fire insurance. Google has recently garnered poor publicity from what is seen as forced integration between Youtube and Google+ (you can’t comment on YouTube videos unless you have a Google+ account), as well as being seen by the public to be complicit in the Orwellian NSA scandal,

Google is once again being criticized for paying too much, much like it’s the purchases of YouTube and Motorola, but in each case it turns out to be a high price to pay for a company, but a low price to pay for an early entry point into what can end up as a dominant player. Perhaps Google is just long sighted.

However the issue here is how the IoT and home automation in particular will be controlled. Will it go through operators as a route to market, will it accumulate around collections of App or fall to the companies that control browser experiences? Or do the manufacturers of the devices in the home directly attract consumers? And if they do are they attracted by what you can do with a smart, connected device or are they attracted by its look and feel.

We don’t think that home automation equates to the Internet of Things, it is a small part of it. The mobile world was once entirely controlled by operators with walled garden services which have since fallen away, so that they are now just bit pipes with the real control going to the handset OS vendors. But for the IoT to follow this roll-out, does it mean that operators will bring home automation to the masses, but ultimately be undone by the device vendors? But you must ask can Apple control part of the IoT, just by having iOS? and without investing in companies like Nest?

It is worth $3.2 billion for Google to cover all the IoT bases, but clearly Apple doesn’t think so because although Apple sells Nest products, in its Apple’s stores, it did not bid or counter bid to up the price.

So will Apple continue stocking Nest items? We expect so but that doesn’t meant that Apple won’t follow suit and create a devisiion of Apple to make devices like this.

While Google appears to be increasingly turning its attention towards hardware, its roots in advertising may well see the data generated through Nest used in ways that Nest currently opposes. Restructuring terms and conditions will not be hard for the giant, nor will interim cash flow. Google had more than $56 billion in cash and marketable securities as of Q3 2013, and the $3.2 billion it spent on Nest has hardly made a dent in that total. While the price may have been inflated, the Nest acquisition stands to give Google a physical entryway into homes, which it needs in the age of the Internet of Things. It can also market its Android platform to hardware manufacturers who want to develop products for the home. Could this be the beginning of a Google Home platform?