Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 January 2014

Malone behind the scenes genius is ready to topple Time Warner Cable

John Malone has been busy this week, triggering the public offer from Charter for Time Warner Cable and following it up a day later with an impressive document aimed at winning a proxy battle before it starts. Charter, or rather Malone, has the TWC board in his sights.

Earlier this week the financial ping pong was begun with a public letter from Charter, calling for merger discussions. TWC came back with the usual epithets that it was grossly undervalued, blah, blah. And like a programmed trading campaign on the public markets, that immediately triggered a document which savages everything that the TWC management said. The option was offer more or go for the jugular.

The document shows how badly invested TWC is in its networks, how poorly it has pushed triple play, how slow its management has been to respond to the CBS crisis and the fall-away in subs. If you take away the effects of the CBS row, where TWC lost 300,000 subscribers by allowing the deal to go to a blackout of the CBS stations in the Fall, then TWC is a middle of the road US cable performer. It’s not done so bad, but not shone. But when you add that in, angry investors will want the team that allowed it to happen to fall on their swords.

The truth is, and this is the Charter message, that this deal has been rumored since the Summer, and the first approach was made in June. At the time the share price was 38% below where it is today and the reason that this premium has been caught up by the share price is not because of the confidence that investors have in the TWC management, but because they sensed a hostile takeover and the usual premium associated with such a move.

Usually you would conclude when a management team refuses to speak to rival about a merger, a hostile takeover is unlikely, but that denies the opportunism of this bid. Every financial organization that was publishing a target value for TWC back in June had it topping at around $100 a share, and today the share price is $136, entirely the result of the rumors and subsequent bidding from Charter. The implication is that if Charter walks away from this deal, the TWC share price will fall back to $100 or worse, resulting in a loss of some 26% of the value of the company, and it may never recover.

For a management team which holds shares you should never underestimate the effect such a fall would have on their personal fortunes. In our minds, the only thing that has prevented the deal being embraced by the management team is the speed and ease with which the share value has risen on the news. Perhaps it has further to rise? Perhaps another $10 or so.

Malone’s involvement in Charter became public around March last year and he wasted no time making it clear why he was there, with public statements about consolidation and TWC and related matters, like cable creating its own Hulu.

The stock took a sharp rise from around $121 to roughly where it is now on November 21. On August 30th it was down as $107 after the first rumor of his involvement. Charter has now released its timeline of courtship and clearly the team made a second bid in October and when it got the wrong answer back, somehow someone in the press got hold of the details of the bid, and the result was this second rise in the share price for TWC.

This is all part of the bait, and the nagging doubt in the mind of investors and management alike, and it makes this deal more likely to happen by the day, to the point where only a white knight can save TWC from merging with Charter, and the only cable operator big enough is Comcast, or COmcasst plus someone else, like Cox, and we genuinely feel that Comcast’s hands are tied by monopoly and media ownership rules, although that may not prevent it from trying.

Charter said it has made repeated overtures to Time Warner Cable and until December Time Warner Cable chose not to engage or even find out more about the offer. The first meeting between CEOS and CFOs was during December.

There has been some courting of opinion of Charter’s technology suppliers and one article appeared suggesting that such a deal, if completed would be great for ActiveVideo and TiVo, which are both favored at Charter, as well as Netflix, which will soon be able to work with both systems.

It will take two to three weeks for the message to get through to all shareholders and a formal offer will have to be made, and if during that time the no white knight emerges or there is not increased offer for TWC, then the current offer could go end up being recommended.