Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 January 2014

Liberty Global plans to challenge EU competition rules in bid for Ziggo

Liberty Global has gone ahead and ‘gone for it’ and tried to buy Ziggo in the Netherlands, a deal that we are fairly sure will be knocked back by the European Commission, if not the local competition regulator. Liberty may now come under increasing scrutiny as a default purchaser of weakened European cable companies as its dominance of European cable threatens to unbalance telecommunications across the region.

Our take is that Liberty has decided that the potential benefit of the deal far outweigh the potential pitfalls, of which there are many. There have been many cable rollups in Europe, which allow all of the larger cable companies in one country to be acquired by a single entity, but in most cases these represent a minority interest against the local telco, and regulators welcome it as an improved source of broadband competition over and above local loop unbundling.

Such examples include Numericable in France, Virgin Media in the UK, Ono in Portugal, Liberty Global in the Czech Republic and Slovakia and Austria Telekom in Croatia. There are other countries where there is one dominant cable player and a variety of smaller, non-viable cable operators such as in Portugal, where Zon dominates, and a similar situation in most of the Nordic countries. But in every case the market share of this merged cable entity is never higher than 48% of the pay TV market, and while in one or two others it is 40%, for the most part the largest cable groups in each country sit with 20% to 25% of total pay TV in their territory and even less of the broadband market.

But this transaction would give Liberty Global something like 60% by number of Netherlands homes (in Pay TV) and a significantly larger share if the amount of income was considered, because both Liberty Global and Ziggo have higher ARPUs than other pay TV providers in the Netherlands, a number that is heavily diluted by the 633,000 Digitenne customers, who pay under €10 a month for a paid digital terrestrial service. Their merged share of broadband would be around 50% and broadband is a market where it has been shown time and time again that it is essential to have at least two providers, preferably more, in any given territory, or prices spiral out of control, and create windfall profits and service stagnation.

This deal would put the cable operators in a strong position to price their fixed line telephony in an irresistible fashion, to ensure 50% of that market too and they would then use that to drive up the acceptance of the Ziggo Vodafone based MVNO cellular service, supported by their combined 2 million home based WiFi Homespots, annexing a strong quad play. In the past the Dutch Competition Regulator, now part of the Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM), has been very strict about now allowing mergers that create monopolies. It was previously called the Nederlandse Mededingingsautoriteit (NMa).

The move, if approved by both the local competition regulator and European Commission, would clear the way for similar roll-ups in Belgium, Switzerland, Austria and one or two other countries, once a precedent was set. As a result we don’t think that such a deal could feasibly be allowed by any regulator that wishes to see broadband and telecommunications competition across Europe.

Ironically the move would shake up a complacent KPN, the incumbent telco in the Netherlands and give it an even stronger rival, with the exception of its cellular operation, which the cable pair currently have little market share in, since only Ziggo has recently launched an MVNO, based on the Vodafone network. Such a weakening of KPN’s position would almost certainly lead to renewed efforts by overseas competitors, such as America Movile, to buy into Europe, with KPN as their bridgehead, something that was recently tried and only just failed.

We think that the Liberty Global management realizes all of this, and yet a change in regulation in the Netherlands would likely yield it such a huge prize, by setting such a precedent, so much so that we think it plans to fight for this deal in court.

But while this may curb the casual dominance of KPN in the Netherlands, subsequent deals in other territories could see a Europe wide monster created, fighting against local incumbents which have national dominance, while Liberty would have European cable dominance, as well as the cash flows to fall back on, and all the while its profits would be flowing back to the US, where the company reports and is public.

Right now the only companies that are large enough to take on Liberty Global are the cellular operators that dominate Europe ‘ Vodafone, Telefonica, Orange and T-Mobile ‘ and their involvement is largely dependent upon territory. Vodafone beat Liberty Global to a deal in Germany to buy Kabel Deutschland, being prepared to outbid it. That deal would have been threatened by anti-trust considerations in the same way had Liberty Global won, but Vodafone got the deal.

Vodafone is really only interested in securing its offload and small cell backhaul capabilities in its four largest European territories ‘ Germany, the UK, Spain and Italy ‘ which is why Vodafone is now being linked with a bid for Spanish cable group Ono and even though Liberty Global is in the middle of merger talks with Ziggo, it is also seen as being interested in Ono. Ono triggered all this talk of takeover by saying publicly that it wanted an IPO, making almost a last chance for Liberty or Vodafone to buy it before it went public, as what may be an inflated price.

The agreed bid for Ziggo should involve more money than a bid for Ono would entail, having reached a deal valuing Ziggo at €10 billion ($13.7 billion) in cash and stock in Liberty Global. But if you take out debt the valuation is closer to €6.9 billion ($9.5 billion). Given that Liberty Global has already bought 28.5% of the stock this means that it now has to stump up some €4.9 billion or $6.8 billion to claim the asset, with most of that paid in shares (only $2.2 billion in cash) plus €300 million in transaction and financing costs.

Observers of Ono have been talking about a value close to €6.4 billion ($8.7 billion) in Ono’s IPO, on revenues of around €1.5 billion (4th quarter is not out yet but more or less), making a small loss on the third quarter and an EBITDA of €172 million, down 9% on last year. Ziggo has just published its full year results with revenues about the same of €1.56 billion, but a €79.3 million profit on the quarter (€347.3 million on the year) and EBITDA considerably higher at €222.8 for the quarter and €886.8 million for the year and up a single digit percentage.

But we suspect that coming so close after Liberty Global’s deal to buy Virgin in the UK, it would be too much for the company to swallow both of these cable companies at the same time ‘ it would potentially need an unhealthy amount of debt leverage, and take too long to pay it down, leaving it vulnerable and cash constrained. It would not be the first time that a major cableco took on that amount of debt (Comcast did something similar when it bought AT&T Broadband in the US to become the US market leader), but it is not in keeping with the financial prudence that Liberty Global is known for.

The price it plans to pay for Ziggo is a 22% premium to its closing share price on the day when Liberty Global first made its offer to buy the company and remember here it is buying a public company while at Ono, it might be better to let it go public and buy it later, especially if the price crashes and it can pick up some of the stock cheaply. Also we reckon that the Ono deal would require a lot more of the value to be in cash, making it more of a debt burden for Liberty Global to buy Ono.

Our take on this is that Vodafone will outbid Liberty for Ono, but that it has no interest in Ziggo. We think that Liberty will simply keep Vodafone honest (so it doesn’t get Ono for a song) and focus on the Dutch deal, which we believe cannot happen ‘ and once it is blocked by the authorities it will leave Liberty Global fat with cash, hungry and unhappy, ready to buy other cable operators around Europe.

If it was to land Ziggo the company in the Netherlands would take on its name, and headquarters, and it would reach 7 million of the 7.2 million Dutch homes, and have business at 4 million of those homes, with revenues of €2.5 billion and it says it would reap €120 million in savings by 2018, plus other revenue related synergies.

Liberty Global said that if it acquires either 80% or 95% of the shares of Ziggo from this offer, it would end up owning all of the company, with a Dutch law allowing it to force the last 5% or in the 80% case, using a liquidation process and buying out the assets.

Liberty Global knows perfectly well that this deal is unlikely to go through and has only risked €69.5 million in termination fees, which goes both ways in the event of the deal being off. However in order for this payment to be made, one of the two companies has to commit a breach in their agreement, so it would end up seeing this deal blocked and walk away with no termination fee. That shows that neither Liberty Global nor Ziggo have any expectation of this deal going through, otherwise the termination fees would have been one way, and far more and would be trigged by any cancellation.

There have been reports that Liberty plans to bypass the Dutch regulator and seek regulatory clearance for the merger from the European Commission, this, of course can only happen if the local competition authority calls in the Commission, as every European country has slightly different competition laws, and these have to be satisfied in the first place. So in effect, we don’t think Liberty Global has this right to bypass the regulator.

Finally, Ren’ Obermann, CEO of Ziggo freshly arrived from running Deutsche Telekom, while backing the deal, says that he has no plans to be part of the new combination. However, once this deal is sabotaged by the European Commission, we suspect that Obermann will really start to earn his money.

We have been wracking our brains to see a way that the European Commission could allow this deal, and short of a legal challenge to its authority, not likely to work in Europe, we can’t see it. We wonder if the Liberty Chairman, John Malone, a genuinely resourceful Billionaire, has something else up his sleeve?