Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 February 2014

Comcast predictably steps in to shore up Time Warner Cable

Comcast this week stepped straight into the hostile takeover stirring between Charter and Time Warner Cable, by planning a bid this week for Time Warner Cable. We see this as a cynical move to reduce competition in the marketplace, with a deal that the regulator cannot allow to go through.

The news broke in a Reuters piece on Tuesday, saying the deal will be announced this morning (as we go to press). It values TMC at $45 billion, or $158 a share.

Comcast can pay over the odds in a deal that will never happen, giving shareholders a false glimpse of what is possible in the share price of TWC, valuing the company at over $45 billion. The clue is in the deal details ‘ friendly, no cash involved ‘ just a share swap. This is not a deal that focuses on value for money for the Comcast shareholders, this is a deal simply designed to kill of the bid by Charter for Time Warner Cable.

Comcast management has woken up to the fact that John Malone wants create a rival cable giant to Comcast by merging Charter and Time Warner Cable, by a shareholder that already has control of the US number 2 pay TV operator, DirecTV.

Earlier this week charter nominated TWC directors sympathetic to its cause of taking over TWC at a price closer to $38 billion, or $132.50 per share, and called to have them voted in at the AGM, so they could pass through the deal. Charter said that existing shareholders overwhelmingly wanted Time Warner Cable to be run by a different management team and that they favored a deal with Charter.

Time Warner Cable responded by saying that the offer was a lowball offer, despite the fact that Time Warner Cable has gone ex-growth after the management fumbled the ball on renegotiating a carriage deal with CBS, which led to a blackout and a big loss of TV subscribers. Its quarterly result shows revenues up just 0.1%, out last week.

There are many reasons why Comcast cannot be allowed to buy Time Warner Cable, but investors will only see the share price offered. The market has not had time to respond to the deal, but it is likely that some investors will be intrigued by the coming battle, and will buy into the stock, although not at a price anything like $158, but somewhere between where it is now and that price.

Regulators work on behalf of the US government and the consumers and the potential for continued price rises in pay TV pricing, the ability for the new entity to dictate what is successful programming and what is not, would leave the US studios at the dictate of Comcast. It would also have undue influence in terms of its reach among the US voting population and that will make regulators uneasy. But what it does is remove the threat of Charter creating a viable alternative to Comcast, and increases the threat it offers to Telcos such as AT&T and Verizon, already weak on broadband and still minnows in terms of pay TV and only strong in cellular.

Comcast appears to have addressed these issues saying privately that it would only end up with 30 million cable customers and would sell the remaining cable subscribers, about 3 million, to a rival, possibly Charter. The deal price is remarkably close to the value asked of Charter by the Time Warner Cable management. The new Comcast deal might still be undone by TWC voting in alternative directors and opting for the lower priced Charter bid, except this relies on investors seeing through the Comcast position, and that’s not guaranteed.

The idea is that the new combined company would divest 3 million subscribers, about 25% of Time Warner’s 12 million customers, additional to Comcast’s existing 21 million plus video subscribers, making 30 million which is around 30% of the US pay TV market.

Our take on this is that investor greed will initially win out and the Charter deal will be off. Regulators will take a look at the Comcast deal and that process may take 6 to 9 months. At some stage it would become obvious that regulators will not allow the deal to go through or even greater concessions would be asked for, concessions that Comcast would find unpalatable, and either way the deal would be off.

Charter would then be free to come back, but large tranches of stock will have changed hands and the price will have risen substantially in the eyes of new shareholders. This is the outcome that Comcast wants, as does TWC management. But shareholders will be livid and there could be either immediate or subsequent ramifications with calls for the CEO’s head and the rest of the Board for what we see as collusion in a deception.

The next thing after the announcement later today of the Comcast offer will be endorsement by the TWC board and some nice fake justification of what the merged company will do. One of the regulator issues will be creating a company that has almost 30% of US broadband, with no rival anywhere better than half that.

Charter can either bide its time or denounce the deal openly as fake, and it will be interesting to see the tactics employed by the old hand John Malone.

One of the key issues is whether or not there is a nominated break-up fee promised to TWC, of any consequence. If not then this deal is truly designed to fail and never expected to go through.

From the regulator side of the fence a deal between Charter and TWC will have the effect of creating a more balanced cable economy in the US, but because there is little or no overbuilding in cable, there is no increase or decrease in the number of competitors in any given market, only in the ability for the larger companies to better negotiate for equipment and content due to volume.