Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2014

Qualcomm sees no future in specialist Smart TV chip

What is it that makes the chip market for TVs so tough to enter. The answer must lie in the margins we suspect. Intel and Broadcom pulled out of Smart TVs in October 2011, with Intel having only been in the business since July of that year, a mere 12 weeks earlier. Now in a move very reminiscent to Intel’s, Qualcomm has this week managed to complete the same about turn in less than 5 weeks.

Broadcom had already fallen by the wayside a month before Intel, dropping out of DVD, Blu-ray and Smart TV chips ‘ on the basis, we think of margin and the size of the opportunity.

We said in an analysis last week that while Broadcom and MediaTek are heavily incentivized to enter the high margin businesses of Qualcomm, it was less likely to find any benefit entering their slightly smaller, lower margin businesses, specifically the MStar business of making chips to drive the intelligence in smart TVs.

Broadcom exited the sector despite having design wins at high profile CE customers such as LG and Intel despite providing the intelligence on the Google TV. It was probably the failure, at the time, of Google TV, to knock a large hole in the TV market, which halted Intel’s foray.

For Qualcomm this time around it must be doubt raging about TVs in general, such as those we raised in our report, ‘Requiem for Television, ‘ which shows that volume in this market is headed south and with it the little margins this market had left.

Interestingly both Broadcom and Intel remained very cheerfully in the set top business, a marketplace that supports perhaps 60 separate product families around the globe, compared to the 6 or 7 major smart TV designs, dominated by Samsung, LG, Sony and Vizio as well as a handful of Chinese specialists such as TCL.

Qualcomm said in a statement this week only that it had decided not to commercialize the recently announced Snapdragon 802 processor, because demand for processors for smart TVs has proven to be smaller than anticipated. It had been specifically aimed at 4K TVs. The device had Quad-core Krait 1.8 GHz CPUs, an Adreno 330 GPU, the Hollywood Quality Video processing engine which up-converted 1080p and a Hexagon DSP for Dolby processing and 802.11ac
Wifi. This was exactly the same spec as the 800, except it also had a cellular modem. Either TV makers are now expected to use the 800 as it is, or Qualcomm is out of this market for good.

It is the size of the misstep that is surprising given that the variant, while unlikely to have taken years to develop, would have been an expensive variant. The 802 was due for sampling in early 2014 and shipping later this year.

In the TV sector, major vendors like Samsung and LG have entrenched relationships with their own chip partners, but a while back LG tried to move to in-in-house designed chip and then a year ago acquired WebOS from HP, and built its smart TVs around this. We assumed its own chip still drives the applications. We’re sure the now defunct Qualcomm 802 chip could have coped with running WebOS if it had to, but it was optimized for Android KitKat and this splintering of standards in Smart TVs may have hampered the chip. We’re not sure how LG can maintain its stance on the Smart TV Alliance, where developers are supposed to be able to design apps for TVs made by LG, Philips, Toshiba and Vestel, but we assume that this must be operating system independent.

We think that Samsung tends to get its Bluetooth from Broadcom, voice control from Conexant, HDMI from Silicon Image, WiFi from Railink and provide its own App processors in its TVs.

Between the two of them (Samsung and LG) that puts a good 41% of the global market out of reach for Qualcomm, although Samsung over the years has been one of Qualcomm’s biggest fans in mobile chip design, and it may well have been able to convince it to take the 802 eventually ‘ however price would have been an issue, we’re sure.

Qualcomm has insisted to some US papers that this is all about the economics of this chip and that it’s not the sector generally and anything shipping now will continue to ship. The next thing to worry about will be its set top chip, but we expect that to have a much longer run for its money.