Sometimes we do see the enemies of enemies become friends, and this looks to have happened in the formation of WiFiForward ‘ a collection of 18 companies that hope to persuade policymakers to open up access to the unlicensed spectrum that WiFiForward hopes will encourage growth and development for its members.
WiFiForward is targeting spectrum in the low, medium and high bands, and brings together a diverse range of partners, with what we suspect are at least two separate agendas. WiFiForward warns that a ‘WiFi spectrum crunch’ is imminent, although we think this is an exaggerated claim, imminent might mean 5 years. The most interesting point to note are the presence of US cable providers, who will no doubt want to secure more WiFi spectrum to push their own wireless agenda, ahead of their main telco rivals which constantly call for cellular spectrum.
The 18 partners include, the American Library Association (ALA), Arris, Best Buy, Broadcom, the Computer and Communications Industry Association (CCIA), the Consumer Electronics Association (CEA), Charter, Comcast, CompTIA, Engine Advocacy, Fastback Networks, Google, International Association of Venue Managers, Microsoft, Motorola, the NCTA, Schools Health and Libraries Broadband Coalition and Time Warner Cable.
Essentially this is a lobbying coalition that lumps together some unlikely partners. WiFiForward’s main aim is to add more capacity to WiFi networks without heavy (if any) capital expenditure. The group will focus on convincing the FCC, which is already trying to open up the 3.5GHz and 5GHz bands, before turning to Congress if it is unsuccessful. It also wants to push for the opening up of White Spaces to facilitate rural broadband ‘ which is where Microsoft and Google come in.
Our presumption is that many of these players would wade into the White Spaces segment if it was open to begin build out, with WiFi chipmakers and operators likely to work alongside the deep pockets of Microsoft and Google to almost annex White Spaces to WiFi, despite the differences in the technologies. We assume they would use White Spaces to deliver a point to point broadband signal and convert it to WiFi when it arrived, so it could talk to existing devices, a bit like MiFi does for mobile.
Advocacy groups feature heavily in the line-up. Engine Advocacy claims to be the voice of start-ups in government, CEA lobbies on behalf of the consumer electronics industry, CompTIA does the same for the IT industry, and the CCIA covers the computer, internet, information technology and telecommunications industries. The IAVM advocates for public assembly venues, the ALA lobbies for libraries, and the SHLB pushes for broadband access for the institutions and their local communities.
Charter, Comcast, NCTA and TWC represent the cable contingent and are usually who we are most interested in. Software giants Google and Microsoft will likely be pushing for the comfort of knowing that Net Neutrality is enshrined by at least one broadband route that does not belong to a large public carrier.
Neither Verizon nor AT&T are members, or are likely to become members of WiFiForward. As these telcos move into TV services, the cablecos are trying to compete with the telcos’ wireless broadband offerings via proxy by using WiFi. The core offerings of each sector are now becoming battlegrounds after years of clear divisions between the services offered by cablecos and telcos.
WiFiForward has released its own study that it claims proves the economic benefits of freeing up the unlicensed spectrum. It claims that unlicensed spectrum generated $222 billion in value for the US economy in 2013, while only adding $6.7 billion to the GDP ‘ perhaps proof of the profits that lie in unlicensed spectrum for those who expand WiFi networks, but figures more than likely to raise a few eyebrows among financial analysts.
The $222 billion is comprised of $12.6 billion generated from WiFi offload, WiFi-only tablet sales of $42.8 billion, ‘benefits and savings associated with WiFi enabled homes’ for a surplus of $36 billion, and RFID usage generating $130.8 billion. The $222 billion is problematic to justify.
More than half of the figure represents RFID – an industry that already operates within itself. Yes it does use unlicensed spectrum, some of it the same as WiFi, but it is not WiFi. RFID transmissions are almost exclusively very short in range and very small in size. It is very hard to find a news story in which RFID users are crying out for more bandwidth, so the US is never going to lose this ‘economic benefit,’ so surely there is no need to list it.
So $130 billion of the $222 billion is a tenuous part of an argument for more spectrum. The figure of $42.8 billion for WiFi-only tablet sales may be a figure that is more relevant, as is the rising tide of WiFi attached smartphones.
WiFi is arguably already the largest wireless network in the world, and the question is basically economic ‘ should operators have dedicated spectrum so they can avoid or manage all forms of wireless contention, and sell service for high prices i.e. cellular, or should operators share spectrum that is free and end up passing through many of the savings to consumers. Both arguments have merit.
The $6.7 billion GDP figure in the report was based on the estimate for WiFi offload ($3.12 billion), wireless ISP operations ($1.439 billion) and revenues from Bluetooth, Zigbee and WirelessHART ($2.166 billion). These figures are based on sales revenues and not speculative estimates, but much of WiFiForward’s literature seems wide of the mark in exaggerating the WiFi crunch. It is little more than scaremongering tactics for a vested interest group.
The FCC’s ongoing plan to open up the 3.5GHz band will already provide more bandwidth, but it comes at a price. With every cycle of WiFi equipment new generations of chips had to be constructed to use the new spectrum. New spectrum means more chip sales for the likes of Broadcom.
If the FCC does mandate new spectrum allocations, the impact will not be felt in the near future, but the long-term. It will take time for manufacturers to supply the necessary chips if the spectrum lies outside already populated bands. While WiFiForward likes to warn of the imminent ‘WiFi spectrum crunch’ the impact of the lobbying will take a few years at least to be felt.
Cablecos see that WiFiForward is critical. They need more capacity for WiFi, better still, in spectrum that propagates longer distances, which might one day allow them to compete against cellular rivals. Between them, TWC, Comcast, Cox, Bright House and Cablevision have 250,000 shared WiFi hotspots ‘ part of an agreement made in 2012, rising to 350,000 they say, this year.
Comcast has 6 million WiFi access points in homes, and has pushed a number of these to Hotspots status along with building out hotspots. It says it has 1 million Hotspots due to aggressively deploying new WiFi routers to its broadband customers, supplementing about 100,000 carrier class hotspots deployed in public space. By comparison Verizon has only 5,000 hotspots, and AT&T has around 32,000.
In the white space segment, Carlson Wireless’ RuralConnect is the first commercial service operating in the US, a fixed wireless broadband system marketed at rural and hard to reach locations, which operates in the UHF band (470-698 MHz).
Another leader in the White space market is the UK’s Neul’s offering its Weightless white space implementation, focused on providing IoT and M2M connectivity. BT is currently trialing the NeulNet system in the UK, which is intended to connect sensors with 10-15 year lifecycles to cloud networks. Neither Carlson or Neul are members of WiFiForward.
The cableco involvement in WiFiForward is part of their long-term plans to compete with the telcos. Currently, the telcos are losing broadband customers to the cablecos year on year. This shows no sign of slowing. With somewhere between 250,000 ‘ 350,000 shared WiFi hotspots, the cablecos can offer a competitive WiFi Offload service. But it remains unclear how it will push that advantage.
There are two clear ways ahead ‘ it can keep undercutting broadband at the telcos while offering a faster service, and forcing Telco prices and therefore fixed line revenues downwards in broadband. Or it can combine the WiFi offloading with an MVNO and go after the quad play market. Comcast executives have said publicly that they are not interested in the latter approach, but we feel that at some point, US cable HAS to enter the quad play market.
Comcast’s claim of 1 million hotspots for its customers to use is the potential killing blow that hangs above the telcos. If it paired the coverage with an MVNO, such as Sprint, on a WiFi first basis to keep its costs down, it could undercut the telcos on price and decimate their customer numbers.
Free did much the same in France, and if Comcast offered phones with contract pricing similar to Republic Wireless (with WiFi only starting at $5 and roaming from $10 to $40) it could ruin the business models of Verizon and AT&T.
Comcast is also likely able to quickly expand its hotspot number from 1 million several times over using Homespots. It claims those 1 million include special hardware to offer two SSIDs, but really this only needs a software change at the home router.
Cablecos insist they want to maintain the status quo, eating all the new fixed line broadband in the US market, while telcos tread water in broadband. This is why WiFiForward is so interesting, as the cablecos will use it to lobby to the detriment of the telcos the cable companies will move rapidly to take advantage of it.