Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2014

Belgium’s Telenet drops DVB-T2, as DTT services in Europe falter

Belgian MSO Telenet is the latest to pull out of digital terrestrial after some earlier high profile defections in Germany, notably broadcaster RTL. This ironically comes at a time when the DVB-T2 standard has been gaining adoption outside Europe in both developing nations of Africa and advanced economies of the Far East, as well as Russia.

Yet this is not quite the contradiction it sounds, for on the one hand there is near universal agreement now that DVB-T2 is the best version of digital terrestrial technology around today, while on the other sentiment is turning against DT in general in some regions on economic and logistical grounds as well as under assault from the mobile lobby. There is a growing feeling in a number of European countries, particularly Germany and Belgium, but even to an extent the UK, that DTT lacks the capacity and flexibility in the long term to enable advanced interactive ultra HD services.

This is certainly the case for Telenet, whose flirtation with the second generation DVB-T2 has proved short lived, despite initially having been encouraged by its parent, Liberty Global. As Belgium’s largest pay TV operator with 2 million subs of which 1.5 million are digital, Telenet has been seeking to expand its footprint so that it can compete universally with Telco Belgacom’s IPTV service, which has been growing faster with close to 1.5 million subs now. Accordingly it launched its DTT service called Teletenne in July 2012 to attract new viewers beyond its cable footprint as well as to serve second homes, student houses and bedrooms for existing customers.

But with prices at €11.50 per month and requiring customers to buy an aerial and decoder package for €129, the service has had few takers and has now been closed. Telenet is reimbursing the cost of the decoder plus one month’s subscription, at a total of €140.50 per sub. Instead Telenet is focusing on its online Yelo TV service, which was launched on tablets, smartphones and computers in March 2013. This provides an OTT basic package free, but charges for additional features, such as the ability to watch recordings on smartphones, tablets or PCs. It was first introduced to customers that already had a recent HD Digicorder, which is over half the installed digital base, with others offered the upgrade to this box for a one-off €39.

Yelo TV dovetails better with Telenet’s overall multiscreen strategy than the DTT service Teletenne has, since the operator has veered towards a combination of WiFi and cellular for extending its footprint in the first instance to existing customers, before looking to offer OTT versions of its offering to new subscribers. Telenet owns one of Belgium’s four 3G networks and even though it did not bid in the 4G auction for 20 year licenses of 800 MHz spectrum held in October 2013 it has an arrangement to use Mobistar’s network. 3G and 4G therefore loom in Telenet’s longer term plans for nationwide OTT video distribution.

Meanwhile Telenet has been building out WiFi hot spots by upgrading the wireless LANs of its business customers to support ring fenced external access using the same router partitioning technique adopted by Ziggo for example for residential customers in the Netherlands. As it happens Ziggo’s hotspot network is being merged with Liberty Global’s UPC Netherlands as part of a strategy to build a pan European WiFi network. Telenet’s Belgian WiFi hotspot network is being folded into that venture.

With all this going on, it is not difficult to see why Telenet abandoned DTT, although the package was hardly priced attractively for customers. That was not the main factor, as we are seeing the tide turning against DTT elsewhere as well. In the UK true DTT will continue to deliver Freeview for a long time to come, but BT has been migrating its TV customers away from the Arqiva DTT infrastructure used to deliver broadcast content over its BT Vision hybrid DTT/IPTV service, towards broadband for customers with at least fiber to the kerb available. It is notable that the BT YouView box used for the current version of its TV service does not support CAMs or the Merlin encryption system that BT now uses for remaining legacy Vision customers still on DTT.

Meanwhile over in Ireland a report commissioned by the country’s Broadcasting Authority (BAI) and published in August 2013 gave a very damning indictment of DTT. The BAI’s predecessor, the Broadcasting Commission of Ireland (BCI), had initiated a licensing process for three commercial DTT multiplexes in 2008, attracting applications from three consortia, but terms were not agreed and licenses were not issued. The process was then shelved in 2010, and the BAI next commissioned a report to help decide whether it was worth reinstating DTT deployment around the next generation DVB-T2 that had by then emerged.

The report concluded that ‘changes in the economic landscape and the TV market since that time make it less likely that a commercial proposition will emerge which investors could back in a new licensing round today.’ This partly reflected the collapse in Ireland’s economy after the credit crunch of 2008, precipitating a significant and sustained fall in gross domestic product, but chiefly the ‘limitations of DTT compared with competing distribution platforms.’

The report argued that DTT was now an expensive means of transmission compared with digital satellite, while lacking the functionality of digital cable, such as on-demand TV, telephony and internet access.

The report suggested that ‘investors are likely to judge DTT a less appealing technology to fund than it was five years ago when fully 30% of Irish households were still watching analog TV and digital switchover was a driver of migration to digital platforms; the time horizon for investments to reach profitability has also shrunk, and projects which were marginal in 2008 will not be invested in in today’s economic climate.’

Three potential business models for a commercial DTT service were identified in the report as being ad funded free TV, pay TV and as part of a triple play package. For the commercial FTA model it is already becoming clear that DTT, despite the capacity and performance improvements of DVB-T2 through improved encoding, forward error correction and statistical multiplexing, would still be unable to compete with satellite or cable platforms in the number of HD or especially ultra HD channels it could carry and so struggle to be economically viable.

For pay TV DTT is really only fit as a medium for an entry level service, which is how the BAI envisaged it and dismissed it as being unable to compete with Ireland’s two principal operators, BSkyB over satellite and Liberty Global’s UPC over cable.

As for the triple play option, where broadcast TV over DTT is bundled with broadband and voice, that is a model already well tried by operators such as BT, many of which are now abandoning DTT in favor of broadband for linear TV.

Meanwhile Spain’s DTT platform is also in a state of terminal decline, following the closure of a second DTT channel, Intereconomia TV, after losing money. This follows the decision by MTV Spain’s to pull out of the DTT platform and opt for pay TV.

Intereconomia TV was occupying one of the DTT channels operated by NET TV, with up to four channels, and its position may be taken by Real Madrid TV, currently a pay-tv channel. Meanwhile the private TV Association UTECA has urged the Spanish Government to end the uncertainty currently surrounding the country’s DTT market regarding allocation of the digital dividend for provision of 4G mobile services, by announcing a decision that had been scheduled for January 2014. That decision is imminent, but the DTT industry is not optimistic it will come out well.

The first major reverse for DVB-T2, which had been advancing on almost all fronts, came in Germany early in 2013 when commercial broadcaster RTL announced its four RTL channels, RTL, RTL 2, Vox and Super RTL, would exit the airwaves on August 1 2013. RTL also threatened to remove all its channels from DTT on the grounds that there was currently neither long-term security to safeguard the frequencies for broadcast usage, nor any prospect of the introduction of basic encryption. Marc Schr’der, managing director of RTL Interactive, argued then that despite intense efforts by the infrastructure operators, it saw no economically viable business model for DTT.

Schr’der cited the pressure for terrestrial frequencies to be handed over to mobile services as another factor making it impossible for RTL to justify long-term investment in DTT, which in any case only accounted for 4.2% of its audience, with the vast majority being cable, satellite or IPTV. RTL also estimated DTT to be by far the most expensive broadcasting method, costing 30 times more per channel than satellite. RTL also dismissed DVB-T2, despite its greater spectral and encoding efficiency, because of lack of support from the German media authorities.

This was followed swiftly in March 2013 by the announcement from Bavarian media regulator that a number of broadcasters in that region will cease DVB-T distribution later this year. The Bayerische Landesanstalt f’r Neue Medien said that Euronews, home shopping Channel 21 and Regionalfernsehen Oberbayern would end transmissions in Munich and South Bavaria on May 31 2013. Euronews, Channel 21 and Bibel TV stopped broadcasting in N’rnberg on the same date.

At the time this setback for DTT was dismissed as being uniquely German, because it was associated with the government’s lack of support and also very low penetration of DTT, contrasting with the very different situation in neighboring Austria, which being German speaking is served by many of the same channels and content. But Germany was hardly an insignificant market and since then the contasion has spread. So while it is far too soon to write off DTT as medium, given its widespread adoption among many developing nations, its long term future is looking increasingly bleak.

Faultline in its ‘Faultline Revisited’ report released last year, has forecast that 50% of broadcast TV channels will cease terrestrial broadcasts by 2021. It looks like we are on target for this.