Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2014

Devicescape highlights the size of the Free WiFi opportunity

While at the WiFi Offload Summit in Frankfurt last month we saw a presentation from Devicescape CMO, David Nowicki, and it subtly altered our thinking about WiFi Offload. So we looked him up, and had another chat this week to clarify all of the presentation’s data.

In essence the thrust of the Devicescape business, and therefore its point, is that in the US downtown WiFi, in other words that WiFi which comes from Joes’s Coffee shop or some such and other venue owners, is tending more and more to be free. Nowicki showed slides that said that it used to cost money, but slowly venue owners are changing, and that change began on the US west coast and is slowly moving across the US, then Europe and eventually, in his opinion, the world.

And just for a second, if we pass over the Devicescape story and think instead about how that affects the WiFi Offload equation, it means that this category, let’s call it Amenity WiFi, can be used to offload data traffic for consumers when they are away from both work and home ‘ when they are indoors in the urban environment. In essence pre-offload users currently opt to use WiFi when they are at work or at home, with a prior log-in stored in the device.

Adding to those connections when people are at a ‘venue,’ whether that is a coffee shop, a place of entertainment or an airport, or even walking indoors at a mall, is perhaps a part of the equation that MNOs should reach for first and urgently. Free WiFi means that the MNO learns a lot about offload and still does not have to pay, so why not sort that out first, prior to looking at the use of paid commercial Hotspots, whether that’s building them or paying to use them, and Homespots.

There seem to be plenty of these Amenity connections around ‘ according to Nowicki some 47% of access points in San Francisco are free to access, while around 23% are in New York and Europe varies between around 15% being free up to something like 43%.

Nowicki talks about how each of these amenity WiFi owners allow people to log on and how the Devicescape system uses this to allow for automatic connection. ‘We can connect to 20 million access points which are either shared and open or which have an open portal for connection.’ Does this mean that some these purely open access points have unencrypted traffic? He admits as much, so it’s not ideal, but says that accounts for just over 10% in most places.

‘But those where we have to log in, we create a script for the portal in the cloud and download that in real time to the handset, making the user agree to the terms and conditions of the portal as well at the same time. Most retail chains that offer free WiFi use this shared open portal approach.’

Other access points such as those run by FON, or Comcast or The Cloud, use a password that can be distributed by the operator, so these can be accessed too, where the user is a customer of these operators. ‘Others are what we call shared locked, and these use link-layer encryption and we cannot associate with these at all.’

But Nowicki talks about having Quality of Experience data on some 300 million access points, so this includes those which Devicescape has no log in details for, but where users have keyed their passwords into their phones, and the Devicescape software has the job of choosing between that access point and others and a mobile network.

The way these WiFi access points are used, is then down to a policy, but Devicescape pushes its own policy of ‘Always best connected,’ meaning that the connection type is decided by its own app on the phone, based on a proprietary Quality of Experience measurement. We assume that this data is dynamically created in real time, since conditions at each base station and access point change in real time, and Nowicki talks about this QoE data being held in the cloud and shared with other devices.

So if an operator signs up to the Devicescape service, any of its WiFi enabled smartphones can connect seamlessly, to these 20 million access points. ‘At the moment 19 million of those access points are in the US, and only 1 million are international.’ Last week Devicescape announced that it was doing a deal with Virgin in the UK, so it is likely that this international number will shortly rise.

Of course if individual users happen to also have access to other WiFi, such as their home WiFi, then Devicescape at least gets a chance to look at the quality of experience data of that network and compare it with cellular networks and other nearby access points.

As we said this is hardly going to encourage large WISPs such as Comcast – which has both Homespots and hotspots ‘ to be signed up by cellular MNOs. First those MNOs will turn to amenity WiFi, including any municipal WiFi, using perhaps WiFi aggregators, or companies like Devicescape – and then to hotspot owning groups that have no rival services. But this only accounts for WiFi usage in urban environments. When customers go home to the suburbs, then they will have either their own home Wifi, or a guest SSID at a friend’s house or the operator’s second Homespot SSID (for instance AT&T is setting this up via FON right now).

It is only after all these are exhausted that paid offload services using Homespots, will become an option.

There is one other use case that has to be taken into account and that’s outdoors. In places like New York there are outdoor WiFi specialists such as Towerstream, that have this coverage, and although we all imagine data still being more of a sit down and watch experience, where WiFi access is guaranteed, like watching video ‘ it is also good for social media and maps which can often be used on the go and transfer plenty of data.

So perhaps WiFi offload has a longer ways to go than perhaps even we imagined, with these cheaper options being where MNOs pioneer the concept, until they are brought kicking and screaming to the door of rival WISPs, and just have to use their data in return for payment, as well.

So back to the Devicescape story ‘ the company calls its offering the Curated Virtual Network and it clearly needs to offer something back to the free WiFi venue owner, and this has to be something better than that offered by WiFi aggregators and cellular operators in the past that mostly branded in-store WiFi as their own, not allowing the venue owner access to analytics data or any marketing opportunity, but perhaps paying them for the service.

The DeviceScape answer is to offer proximity marketing ‘ paying off the venue owner with a chance to get WiFi users to click into its own promotional ‘Wall’ with a service it calls PopWiFi. This is effectively a discussion board for people within range, and this can lead to feedback on its overall services, and a chance to counter with on the spot offers.

‘That service is just coming out of beta test and so far 5,000 users have created 50,000 walls in just 3 months, driving an 8% click through rate, and a 10% sign up rate,’ says Nowicki. This process is now rolling out to millions of users, and like its service, it all sits in free downloadable Android and iOS apps.

One of the first observations that Nowicki makes about WiFi offload is the way that it stimulates people into being ‘better data users,’ something he shows in the graph below.

This data comes from an unnamed operator, and shows that once consumers indulge in WiFi offload using Devicescape, their data revenues won’t collapse, and yet the consumer will experience a 60% or so upswing in data usage. Other operators have endorsed this phenomenon.

‘I’ll give you an analogy ‘ when fixed line operators introduced cheaper or free calls at the weekend, at first everyone (both operator and customer) was suspicious ‘ if everyone used off peak, then the phone bill would go down and the operator would suffer. What actually happened was that the primary device usage went up considerably and the consumer felt a lot happier, and so didn’t mind paying a bit more,’ Nowicki explained

The big problem for the video tsunami that everyone insists is in the way, as consumers get more and more used to watching video on portable devices, is that data usage could go up close to 100% a year, while revenues, which are reliant on the cellular portion of it going up, are unlikely to go up very fast, if at all.

If MNOs simply arrange for most of the data to go over free WiFi then there is no basis for increasing the ARPU at all.

So how does Devicescape policy management tend to get used? ‘We sell our service to an operator and that operator decides how to use it,’ said Nowicki, ‘but we push them towards always best connected.’

Given that his customers include pure cellular players like MetroPCS, Cricket and US cellular, they are likely to offer either LTE first or best connected. LTE then only defaults to WiFi when there is no LTE. For best connected, it surveys the quality of both signals and picks the clearest one.

‘We currently offer WiFi first, LTE First, WiFi only and Best connected,’ said Nowicki. It is in our roadmap to add ‘chose this option for this app’ and ‘choose the lowest tariff,” he said. It would be interesting to see those two operating together, a consumer might set the policy as ‘Choose cheapest tariff for texts and video, best connected for voice, and LTE for maps.’

We asked Nowicki how operators talked about such decisions. ‘In almost every instance the operators just wants the best outcome for the consumer, and wants to offer the most flexible package for the customer. The trick is what are the defaults out of the box, or as the app is downloaded. All operators will allow the consumer to override their defaults and set their own preferences, but most consumers don’t really want to keep managing the process. If they do change the default settings they do it once and after that it just connects.’

Most operators that have used Devicescape so far have left the default as always best connected, but we see that Republic Wireless is one of its customers, and we know that it has a Sprint MVNO, and has caused something of a revolution, in that its service is always set to WiFi First and it has plans that start at just $5 a month, although you have to provide your own device for that.

This highlights the basic conundrum of WiFi Offload, which is that cellular data seems to be charged for at such a higher rate than WiFi. Perhaps that’s because companies like AT&T, Verizon, Vodafone and Telefonica are used to making so much money out of cellular, whereas Republic Wireless is only now getting into the business.

The simple truth is that data through the air will become a commodity and eventually, however it is delivered, it will have a price ‘ and it can only have one price ‘ so cellular one day has to come down in value to meet the value of WiFi and there is no getting away from that fact.