Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2014

Content owners and EBU go for broke over net neutrality

A key moment is arriving for net neutrality in Europe with a European Parliament vote on February 24 on the draft Single Telecoms Package Regulation. A key part of this package concerns net neutrality, which is for the first time to be enshrined in EU law, with major stakeholders such as the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) and the Computer and Communications Industry Association (CCIA) lobbying hard to make the rules as strict as possible, supported by content owners and industry technology vendors. There is a sense of going for broke, since events had already been going in favor of full net neutrality advocates.

At one time it looked like EU rules on net neutrality would be rather watered down in the face of counter lobbying from ISPs, but at the last hour the legislation appears to have been tightened up in the wake of crucial support from the EU’s digital agenda commissioner Neelie Kroes. The two main changes strengthening the proposed net neutrality law concern rights for ISPs to offer ‘specialized services’ like IPTV or Voice over IP that are prioritized over the Internet and limitations on the situations where traffic can be shaped. In a sense these two changes address the two sides of neutrality, which on the one hand sets out to inhibit positive discrimination in favor of specific services while on the other outlawing negative blocking of traffic that may for example be generated by a service such as Voice over IP that competes with one provided by an ISP.

The first change relating to positive discrimination may not make much difference, which is partly why lobbying is continuing right down to the wire. As the proposed legislation currently stands, ISPs and content providers have lost the explicit right, which was included in the original proposals, to strike deals with each another for ‘specialized services’, primarily IPTV or increasingly OTT. They are still allowed to strike such deals, but just don’t have that as an entrenched right in Europe-wide law, with some constraints as well over the exact terms that can be struck.

Broadcasters lobbying the EU believe that rules governing such specialized services should be tightened up further to ensure they don’t contend with other bandwidth intensive video services across the open Internet. ‘The definition of specialized services must be tight and accurate, and distinct from Internet Access Services,’ said the BBC Head of International Policy Daniel Wilson on behalf of the EBU. ‘It should refer to their end-to-end nature. Crucially, while we accept the availability of specialized services for those who want to use them, their provision must not be at the material detriment to the quality of the Open Internet.’

There is a problem here in that like it or not there is effectively a parallel Internet evolving beyond the access network in the form of CDNs. This means that broadband service providers can cut deals with content operators or broadcasters and ensure that they can deliver end to end QoS better than a pure play OTT provider. This factor supposedly disadvantages OTT providers such as Netflix over the open Internet, compared with content providers that have deals with broadband providers to enable end to end QoS. But now Netflix is collaborating with ISPs over end to end delivery by connecting its CDNs to the access network, so that it can compete on a level playing field with IPTV operators, as well as those content providers that are also tapping directly into the last mile.

The situation is also somewhat murky when it comes to the negative aspect of net neutrality relating to traffic shaping. Naturally Microsoft, as owner of the leading voice over IP brand Skype, has been vociferous in its lobbying against traffic shaping for commercial motives. ‘Arbitrary restrictions to the use of online apps such as Skype has been a persistent problem,’ said Microsoft Director of Policy Jean-Jacques Sahel. ‘We need to ensure that this stops and that new innovative Internet companies don’t face the same problem.’

He argued that traffic management measures should be restricted to an exhaustive list of cases and applied transparently and proportionately without prejudice against specific services. It looks like Microsoft will be fairly happy with the EU legislation on this count, since it appears there will be stricter limitations on how Internet traffic can be shaped or limited. Essentially it will be restricted to traffic shaping needed to deal with network congestion, or in response to specific court orders, such as shutting down a child pornography site. But it cannot be done during the investigation of a crime or at the whim of national governments. It remains to be seen though whether there are any loopholes that wily governments or ISPs may be able to slip through.

One other subtle change has been made to the proposed EU net neutrality law, by eliminating the paragraph, ‘End-users shall be free to enter into agreements on data volumes and speeds with providers of internet access services and, in accordance with any such agreements relative to data volumes, to avail themselves of any offers by providers of internet content, applications and services.’ This was cut largely because it still seemed to imply that access to the open, non-discriminatory internet was a liberty almost at the gift of the ISP rather than an absolute right.