Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2014

BT gets competition tribunal to reexamine case against Sky Sports

BT has scored a major legal victory which means that its ongoing battle with BSkyB over wholesale pricing of the key Sky Sports 1 and Sky Sports 2 channels will rumble on for some time yet.

BT has succeeded in forcing the UK Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) to re-examine its earlier decision in mid-2012 not to compel Sky to lower the wholesale price of the two Sky Sports channels to its pay TV retail competitors, primarily Virgin Media and BT. The decision is significant for communications and broadcasting regulator Ofcom, whose reputation had been shredded by CAT’s scathing report at that time. CAT had concluded that Ofcom’s assertion that Sky had deliberately withheld supply of its premium channels from other channels was unfounded.

But BT took the case to the Court of Appeal, whose writ presides over CAT and which has now found in an investigation led by Lord Justice Aikens that CAT had failed to appreciate the significance of Ofcom’s conclusion that the rate-card price and the effect of the penetration discounts that had been proposed by Sky themselves, gave rise to ‘competition concerns’.

‘The failure of the CAT correctly to interpret the Statement or to deal with the rate-card price and penetration discount issues, has the consequence that it is unclear whether, despite the findings of fact that the CAT has made in favor of Sky, there remain significant, independent, competition concerns based on the rate-card price and penetration discount, as found by Ofcom in the Statement.’

This is music to the ears of Ofcom, which can perhaps look forward to recovering somewhat its reputation in the industry. More importantly the case is significant for the whole sports broadcasting industry, given that the UK is the largest TV market for the world’s most popular sport, football, which is the primary source of competition between Sky and BT.

The case then hinges now not so much on actual pricing figures but on the mechanism adopted by Sky for discounting, which Ofcom argued had the effect of shutting out smaller players. In a sense Ofcom is right, which is why the Court of Appeal has at least ordered a review. The rate card listed standard wholesale tariffs, but augmented by discounts that increased in line with the number of subscribers for given channels’ hence the term ‘penetration discount’. Ofcom argued this was a deterrent against the emergence of new premium channels and operators.

BT’s victory is the latest round of a battle that began quietly in 2007 when it was just a fledgling hybrid DTT/IPTV operator with its BT Vision service and was seeking to offer Sky Sports as part of the package. At the same time the UK’s number two operator MSO Virgin Media, which has never sought sports rights, joined the fight. This prompted a three-year investigation by Ofcom, which then ordered BSkyB to cut its wholesale prices in 2010.

But then the situation was complicated by BT’s direct entry to the UK sports market, spending in total over £1 billion to acquire rights to English Premier League and Champions League football matches, as well as other sports such as rugby union. As a result rights deals involving BT now had to be reciprocal, with its wholesale prices balanced against those of Sky. This led to a parallel dispute between BT and Sky over pricing of Sky Sports for BT’s latest version of its pay TV service based on the Internet connected YouView platform, which is a partnership between four broadcasters BBC, ITV, Channel 4 and Channel 5, DTT infrastructure company Arqiva and ISP TalkTalk, along with BT itself.

BT said the Court of Appeal’s decision will give it the chance to raise the ongoing issue of reciprocal pricing over sports. BT claims Sky has failed to make its sports channels available at a reasonable price, but Sky is saying just the same, so this is now a case of hard commercial negotiation rather than abuse of monopoly power. In fact the more BT eats its way into the overall UK sporting rights cake, the less it can accuse Sky of breach of monopoly power. It is notable that in the case of sports, Virgin Media is now happy to take a back seat and benefit from lower prices from the fall out between the UK’s two big sporting rights hitters.

Alongside sports, movies are the other prime grade of pay TV content that determine commercial success and here the UK situation is even more backward, partly because of the distinction between different windows. With sports there are only two windows, live and highlights and only the first really counts, while with movies there are up to eight windows of varying value. Back in May 2013 after a two year battle, the UK Competition Commission ducked a decision that Sky had monopoly control of TV first run movies, and used the fact that Netflix and Love Film were launching OTT services in the UK to argue this did not count as a monopoly. The result is that Netflix has had to grow its customers on a fare of 18 month old movies, while Sky protects its own service and adds OTT versions, through access to recent blockbusters, fewer in number but a much greater draw for subscribers.

In any other country, if a single supplier held 66% of the pay TV market share and 40% of total TV homes, it would be under strict competitive review constantly. The telecommunications regulator Ofcom has been hot on the heels but the Competition Commission has been lax and even pusillanimous in comparison. Ofcom deserves to have its reputation restored following the latest Competition Appeal court verdict over sports and we believe it will.