Beacon technology is slowly coming to a high street near you, and it looks likely to change the way stores interact with their customers. It is another tool in the fight to draw business back to physical stores and away from the likes of Amazon and eBay.
Weve, the UK mobile-marketing venture between EE, O2 and Vodafone, is launching trials of a new location-based service that provides shoppers with offers via Bluetooth beacon technology.
The Weve scheme is being tested in the Eat caf’ chain, where 100 participants are informed of special deals and promotions via a notification on their mobile phone.
The app that handles the promotions is called Pouch. It acts as a wallet for digital loyalty cards. Beacons in the shop use Bluetooth 4.0, with a range of 20m to 30m, to scan for handsets with Pouch installed and push the relevant notification to the device.
Eat is currently using Apple’s iBeacon software protocols ‘ a UK first ‘ which are compatible with iOS devices. iBeacon has been used in US Apple stores since last year. Eat is not using Apple’s own beacons, and is using hardware from an unnamed third-party supplier.
Beacons are an alternative to near field communication tags (NFC). They have a longer range, but are more expensive, and Weve’s Ryan Barnes believes that beacons could ‘stimulate the retail experience in the UK, and could provide useful data we can feed back to retailers.
Mashable journalist Lance Ulanoff reports that Apple’s iBeacons have dramatically changed the way that Apple runs its flagship Grand Central store in New York. He recalls seeing a customer buy an Apple TV without once talking to an employee, thanks to the Apple Store app ‘ not to be confused with the App Store app.
The Apple Store app lets users scan barcodes and pay with a credit card, as well as call for assistance or book appointments at the Genius bar. The app uses the beacons to calculate where in the store the customer is, and provides contextual information. Ulanoff notes that he was pushed customer reviews of headphones and additional product information when standing in the accessories section.
Easy Pay asks the user to enter their App Store password, which then uses the details linked to the user’s App Store account ‘ and the credit card details stored there. It provides a digital receipt for users to show if challenged at the door, and iBeacons claim to not access the internet to provide the location-specific information. Apple claims to only use the information provided by the user’s privacy settings, so should not inspire Orwellian panics amongst shoppers confronted by iBeacon notifications.
iBeacon installations can be found in baseball stadiums, where coupons for food can be pushed to the phone. Scanned ticket barcodes can also provide maps to seats, and it is run using the At the Ballpark app.
iBeacons is also used to synchronize new Apple TVs with the old settings stored on a user’s iPhone. The process is said to save users a lot of time re-entering their old settings and could be used for other devices outside the Apple ecosystem. It also hints at the potential of Bluetooth LE in the home for Internet of Things installations ‘ where the phone can act as a coordinating hub for connected devices.
Apple has not said whether it is focusing on IoT technology, but the company is renowned for being tight-lipped. However, IoT developers stand to gain from the Bluetooth technology found in newer smartphones, as it bridges the gap between WiFi (a commonplace but relatively high energy usage system) and the other ultra-low power systems like ZigBee and Z-Wave ‘ which are not smartphone compatible, nor ever likely to be. So Bluetooth LE has strong potential for consumer IoT devices.
Bluetooth has filled the void that exists between GPS and NFC. NFC’s working range is too short for a system such as iBeacons, and while GPS is accurate to a few meters it does not work well indoors. Bluetooth 4.0 is a solid compromise for businesses.
Another limitation is found in the handsets themselves. The iPhone 4s onwards have Bluetooth 4.0, also known as Bluetooth Low Energy (LE), which is iBeacons compatible. These same iPhones also lack an NFC chip, which may have gone some way towards the small impact that NFC payment has made in the market – as Apple seems to be very influential in smartphone design and technical market trends. NFC was originally thought of purely as a payment mechanism, but a number of players have tried to extend the model to include in-store product tagging as well.
NFC was embraced by Windows Phone and Android, but has not lived up to the expectations of market analysts. Isis is an app that caters for contactless payment. Like Weve, it can store loyalty cards, but it allows users to add compatible American Express, Chase and Wells Fargo debit and credit cards. Isis says that 25 of the top 100 US retailers have already or are working on deploying contactless terminals.
However, RSR Research’s 2013 Payments Benchmark Study reports that only 10% of respondents had an NFC-enabled phone, and that 34% of those had used NFC in the past month. Only 18% of merchants were trialing mobile payments, 17% had budgeted for them and 30% had plans for the technology.
Google Wallet’s switch from a digital cache to providing a physical plastic card is an admission that NFC has not taken off among consumers. Some speculate that customers are not comfortable with storing all of their payment details on one device, and that a system like iBeacons is not as daunting. iBeacons only needs the App Store details that almost every iPhone user will have already used on their handset. PayPal’s Beacon is an equivalent service (one username and one password) that would likely prove as popular among shoppers who are uncomfortable adding their credit cards to a service like Isis or Google Wallet.
Apple is not the only company working on the beacon hardware ecosystem. Qualcomm’s Gimbal Proximity Beacons are Apple compatible, and use the same Bluetooth technology. Qualcomm produces two types of beacon, the Series 10 and Series 20. The former is not much bigger than the CR2032 battery that powers it, and has a heat sensitive thermistor sensor, with a 3-month battery life when transmitting twice per second. The latter is a wall-mounted unit that runs on 4 AA batteries, with a 1-year battery life when transmitting 10x per second. The series 20 can work outside and indoors, as it is NEMA3 rated. It has a configurable antenna, with multi and omni directional capability.
Tod is another manufacturer that builds Bluetooth LE beacons, although it was funded through crowdfunder Kickstarter and hasn’t been commercially adopted yet. Estimote is a company that has just launched to sell beacons. It sells preorders of its developer preview kits, which contain 3 Estimote Beacons, for $99.
For an idea of cost per store for implementing beacons, GigaOM calculated that a typical Macy’s store (16,000m2) would cost $5,000, with one beacon for every 100m2. NFC tags cost about 10c each, so should Macy’s want to tag 100,000 products, it would cost $10,000. It must be noted that not all products need to be tagged, but it does provide a rough cost equivalent.
Pocket-lint uses Starbucks as an example, where the average store would need only one beacon. If Starbucks were to choose to NFC tag every product (the bottom of a cup for instance) it would cost them millions per year for chips ‘ a sunk cost that can’t be reused, unlike the beacons. Companies that chose to use NFC tags would likely use much smaller volumes of tags fitted to shelves or shop furniture rather than t-shirts or cups.
On this basis, NFC could be implemented at a much lower cost, but it loses out to beacons in terms of range and marketing capabilities. It is a passive technology that users must operate themselves, not an active one like Bluetooth LE that can engage customers proactively. It also requires customers to wander around the shop pressing their phones to things to engage with the shop, whereas beacons push the equivalent of a text message to an iOS phone ‘ a much less intrusive or irksome user experience.
Philips has developed a lighting unit that has beacons built into it, at a retailer in Dusseldorf. If shops choose to include beacon units in the budget for their next refit, beacons might soon become commonplace in businesses. The above numbers suggest that it would not cost an exorbitant amount to retrofit their shops with beacons, and there are notable benefits that can be gained from the technology.
If the Grand Central Apple store is used as an example, then customers who use the iBeacon system do not have to queue to pay for their purchase. There may be savings made by needing less staff on tills, or the ability to move staff from tills to more useful jobs, such as generating sales on the shop floor. Time is a valuable commodity for the high-paying customers, which is often wasted standing in queues. The system can add value to the shopping experience for both customers and retailers. Beacons also possess the ability to bring customers to the store which they may not have visited without a pushed coupon or offer, turning high street footfall into sales.
A Beacon service can only be implemented alongside the uptake of compatible consumer handsets. As Bluetooth 4.0 is incorporated into more smartphones and tablets, beacon systems will likely be adopted by more shops looking to capitalize on passing traffic and providing the best possible shopping experience.