Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 April 2014

SFR and Bouygues remain sandwiched between Free and Orange

The battle for ownership of second placed French mobile carrier SFR has raised cheers from investors, as it drove up the share price of the victorious Numericable. But Faultline cannot help wonder at the disaster that is French telecoms ‘ across broadband, cellular and pay TV networks. We fear that what has happened in France will shortly come to a country near you and wonder if there can ever be a market that is too competitive. If there is, it is France.

In most normal investment environments (we haven’t seen normal since 1995), Iliad’s Free network would have been largely ignored by rivals, who would adopt a wait and see attitude to how it bales itself out of its peculiar predicament ‘ it has not built out hardly any cellular base stations and yet it has an obligation to, and its right roam with Orange will need to be renegotiated at some point.

If things were normal, Free could have disrupted the French cellular equation all it liked, but in the end the incumbents would either force it to take on a ton of debt to buy its way out of network trouble or its service would be simply switched off by the authorities for failing to meet build out provisions. Consumers would have been reluctant to end up relying on such a provider. In the end France does not have four cellular networks, it has three, and another that is permanently due to be built.

But instead we are seeing that while market disruption may not be permanent, it can be devastating, and how anyone can celebrate the continuation of there being four cellular networks in France, is a mystery to us. It is certainly a mystery to shareholders of Bouygues, which in the end finally outbid Numericable and its Altice shareholder and its billionaire owner, but only after negotiations had gone into their exclusive phase ‘ far too late to make a difference and win SFR.

Bouygues could not afford to underbid its hand. It had the right answer to the perilous cellular equation ‘ merge its network into that of Free, to strengthen it, perhaps assuaging Free’s desperation for new customer acquisitions, meanwhile Bouygues would throw in its lot with SFR.

The problem is that Bouygues is a long term enemy of Vivendi and as the owner of popular TV channel TF1, it remains a rival in Vivendi’s core content business. But although its shareholders and management team chose a merger with Numericable, there are still four players in the French cellular market, and whether rumors are true or not, that Bouygues is already in the middle of negotiations to merge its Telecoms division with Free, it is likely to be the final outcome and the only way to take the pressure out of the market.

In a single year Bouygues Telecom has lost 10.75% of its telecoms revenues, falling to €4.7 billion, now just 14% of the diversified group’s total revenues, the rest of which falls across property, engineering, real estate, media and telecoms.

If Free continues with its cut price approach to the market, both SFR and Bouygues will struggle to prevent further market share losses, while Orange will be compensated for any losses with a generous roaming payment from Free creating a genuine price sandwich on the two middle players. That will lower the value of both businesses, and this won’t let up until either France is the world’s least profitable cellular market, or the market falls to just three operators.

Both Free and Bouygues share prices raised on merger discussions, but only after both share prices had already fallen, after Monday’s announcement that the Numericable deal was made irrevocable.

The suggestion is that for €8 billion, Bouygues would be happy to sell, but that Iliad is currently offering around €5 billion. If Bouygues thinks this through, it will find a price to sell at, and get the hell out of the cellular market there. It has other fish to fry.

Bouygues became increasingly agitated as the deal finalized, increasing its offer for SFR as late as Saturday 5 April, making its cash component in the deal up to €15.5 billion, and proposing only a 5% continuing equity involvement for Vivendi. It also offered to match the ‘no job cuts’ promise of Numericable. In the end the supervisory board accepted an offer of €13.5 billion at closing, an additional earn-out up to €750 million, and 20% control, with a chance to sell it at a later stage. This made the total value similar to the deal that Bouygues had offered.

Interestingly, in order to complete this deal, Altice needed first and foremost to buy out its other shareholders in Numericable, by swapping their 35% in Numericable for shares in Altice, the parent, and then immediately launched a rights issue to raise €4.7 billion to help fund the acquisition. The remainder of the cash, around €8.8 billion will come from debt financing. So the new merged entity will be debt laden, and have the job of integrating a cable network with a cellular network ‘ they could do worse than ask Vodafone’s advice ‘ which is now taking this on in both Germany and Spain.

Much of the deal has upside ‘ but to two failing businesses. There are new quad play packages to offer, a switch to more in-house backhaul options for Macro and small cells, and a chance to flip any home WiFi locations into Homespots for cellular offload. All of which will take down costs at SFR. However all of these are things that Free has either already done, or has available to it, so just how it is going to turn the tide at Numericable SFR, is unclear. These moves can halt customers losses, but not grow customers, we suspect.

At Faultline we don’t expect pressure to let up in the French market at all, until the number of fixed and mobile operators there falls to just three.