Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 May 2014

Liberty Global, Ziggo deal stretches into a phase two investigation

On the back of a Reuters ‘exclusive,’ news leaked out this week that slowly the European Commission is going through the motions on the Liberty Global bid for Ziggo in the Netherlands, a deal which we say should not be allowed under anti-trust considerations.

Reuters told the world a few days back that the Commission has decided to move the deal to a phase two investigation ‘ which they reliably inform us gives them more time to scrutinize the deal ‘ to us this was automatic the moment it was announced.

This means that a preliminary review which calls for the Commission to respond by May 8 needs to extend into a deeper examination, which gives a further 105 working days, so would lead to a decision prior to August 20th, when we fully expect either further delaying tactics or a refusal to allow the deal to go ahead.

The problem here is that this is not really the province of the European Commission anyway, because the problem with this merger is a local one whereby dominance in both broadband and pay TV will happen only in one country. The European Commission only gets involved if the two companies merging are above a certain stature ‘ for instance the core condition is the two companies have a combined turnover above €5 billion.

There a lots of subordinate revenue targets that might qualify this deal for European Commission involvement, like having EU Turnover of both firms above €250 million. But there is an erroneous misunderstanding here, which goes something like this ‘ If the EU takes on the merger, then the country merger authority has lost control and if the EU decides that the merger is okay in European terms ‘ in other words it does not distort markets on an EU-wide basis, then there is nothing that the local merger authority can do.

And that’s just not true. Given that ALL of the Ziggo revenue is in the Netherlands, this merger can ONLY distort market shares and dominance in the Netherlands and that is the proper province of the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets, which has only just been formed through a merger of other regulators. It has requested the European Commission let it handle the case, while Liberty Global has openly said it wants to work with the European Commission ONLY.

But of course the real reason for the Commission to take this on is that it will require a lot of work and some experience ‘ it has the opportunity to block the merger at the Commission level, listen to the thrust of counter arguments and then prepare better for a local case, with a less experienced authority.

This way it gets two bites at the cherry, with the ACM having the second local bite if needed.

The Reuters story said that two people close to the investigation told it that the deal was complex and it would need more time to understand. This is of course nonsense. The deal is simple and the market distortion is obvious. What the time is needed for is to prepare a case, based on collecting evidence of market control, and to make it water-tight.

The backdrop of the merger between Comcast and Time Warner Cable was also raised by the Reuters story, but of course, these cases operate separately in separate markets and the fact that Liberty Global has major US TV assets as well, is neither here nor there. The two regions have separate legislation, and separate political motivation, as well as politically there being a US dead zone when a President is deep into his second term, which Europe does not have.

No-one is saying that Liberty Global should not continue to expand its cable empire in Europe, but it needs to do it in countries where its operating company and its target do not have 50% to 60% control of multiple services, which is almost any other country other than the Netherlands.

We would expect that come August, the case will be handed back to the ACM, which will then take its time and conclude, quite rightly that the deal is not in the public interest. The only real outcome from such a long wait, only to have a merger crushed, is that Liberty Global will only be half-hearted in other negotiations that normally it might win, and once it realizes this, we suspect that it may voluntarily pull out of the merger with Ziggo, to release capital for other deals.